October 17, 2024 Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar killed in Gaza, Israel says | CNN

October 17, 2024 Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar killed in Gaza, Israel says

FILE - Yahya Sinwar chairs a meeting with leaders of Palestinian factions at his office in Gaza City, April 13, 2022. (AP Photo/Adel Hana, File)
Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar killed in Gaza
05:04 - Source: CNN

What we covered here

Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, believed by Israel to be chief architect of the militant group’s deadly October 7, 2023, terror attack that set off the war in Gaza, was killed by Israeli forces, officials said.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Sinwar’s death marked “the beginning of the day after Hamas.” He vowed that Israel would continue fighting Hamas in Gaza until all hostages are returned home.

• In a call discussing Sinwar’s death, Netanyahu and US President Joe Biden agreed there was an opportunity to advance the release of the hostages in Gaza. US officials said they would redouble their efforts with mediators to push for a ceasefire deal.

• Despite optimism that Sinwar’s death could bring a Gaza deal closer to fruition, two sources told CNN that Israel’s approach to Iran and its proxies in other countries are seen as “distinct” operations. Israel’s pending retaliation against Iran could come within days, one source said.

66 Posts

Our live coverage of the conflict in the Middle East has moved here.

Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar is dead. Here’s a look at global reaction

Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, believed by Israel to be chief mastermind of the October 7, 2023, terror attack that set off the current war in Gaza, was killed by Israeli forces.

Many global leaders in the West expressed hope that his death signals the beginning of the end of the war in Gaza and could provide an opportunity for the release of the more than 100 hostages still being held by Hamas.

More than 42,000 Palestinians have been killed since Israel’s military operation in Gaza began and nearly all of the strip’s 2.2 million residents are displaced amid a spiraling humanitarian crisis.

Here’s a look at international reaction:

  • US President Joe Biden called Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu praised the Israel Defense Forces for carrying out “excellent work,” according to a statement from the Israeli prime minister’s office. Biden said the killing of the militant leader,was a “good day of Israel, for the United States and for the world,” according to a White House statement.
  • British Prime Minister Keir Starmer called Sinwar “the mastermind behind the deadliest day in Jewish history since the Holocaust” and said the UK “will not mourn his death.” He added: “Today my thoughts are with the families of those victims.”
  • French Prime Minister Emannuel Macron said “Yahya Sinwar was the main person responsible for the terrorist attacks and barbaric acts of October 7th. Today, I think with emotion of the victims, including 48 of our compatriots, and their loved ones. France demands the release of all hostages still held by Hamas.”
  • Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said “Sinwar’s death ends a reign of terror.” He added Hamas “must lay down its arms, release the hostages, and play no future role in the governance of Gaza,” and reiterated calls for an immediate ceasefire to end the suffering in Gaza.
  • German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock said “Sinwar was a brutal murderer and terrorist, who wanted to destroy Israel and its people.” She added Hamas must immediately release all hostages and lay down its weapons, saying “the suffering of the people in Gaza must finally end.”
  • Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said “I am convinced that a new phase must now begin: it is time for all hostages to be released, for an immediate ceasefire to be declared and for reconstruction to begin in Gaza.”
  • President of the European Commission Ursula von der Leyen said “Sinwar was the leader of a terrorist organization, the terrorist organization of Hamas. And he was basically the mastermind behind the 7th of October with the killings, the massacres, the rapes and the kidnapping. So his death is certainly significantly weakening Hamas.”
  • European Union foreign affairs chief Josep Borrell said “[Sinwar] was an obstacle to an urgently needed ceasefire &the unconditional release of all hostages.” He added, “There must be an end to violence, liberation of hostages & stop to the suffering of Palestinians.”

US officials, surprised by Sinwar's death, see a rare opportunity but won't make predictions about the war 

It was around 5:30 a.m. Thursday in Washington, DC, that senior US officials first got word — and photographs — from their Israeli counterparts: Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar might be dead.

Top Israeli and American officials would stay in close contact throughout the morning as the Israeli military worked to confirm that a body found in the rubble in northern Rafah was Sinwar. But even the pictures of Sinwar’s body had senior US officials feeling confident that the mastermind of the October 7 attacks had been killed, according to a senior US official.

There had been significant leads about Sinwar’s whereabouts in the past, and even a few moments when US officials believed the Israeli military had gotten close to the terrorist leader. That Sinwar was ultimately killed in an operation that was not intended to target him made the development — coming just days after the one-year anniversary of the start of the Israel-Hamas war — all the more remarkable.

President Joe Biden said that for the Israeli people, Sinwar’s death was comparable to Osama Bin Laden’s death for Americans in 2011.

But US officials are reticent to make any predictions about what that will ultimately mean for the volatile region.

Hamas operatives were certain to be reeling from the news and figuring out what’s next; Israel’s retaliation against Iran for its October 1 missile attack is expected within days; and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will need time to determine how to handle the next stage of the Gaza conflict.

Netanyahu’s phone call with Biden on Thursday was brief, according to the official, and the prime minister made clear that while hostages must come out of Gaza, he would only end the war under terms that he could accept.

Iran's mission to UN says Sinwar’s death strengthens “spirit of resistance”

Iran’s mission to the UN said the circumstances of Yahya Sinwar’s death in an active warzone will strengthen the “spirit of resistance.”

Along with Hezbollah, the Houthis and other groups, Hamas is part of an Iran-led alliance spanning Lebanon, Yemen, Syria, Gaza and Iraq that has attacked Israel and its allies since Israel’s war in Gaza began. They say they won’t stop striking Israel and its allies until a ceasefire is reached in the Palestinian enclave.

Blinken speaks to Saudi and Qatar leaders about ending conflict and ensuring "Hamas does not remain in power"

Antony Blinken speaks at a press conference during the 44th and 45th Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) Summits in Vientiane, Laos, on October 11.

US Secretary of State Antony Blinken spoke with his counterparts in Saudi Arabia and Qatar on Thursday to discuss ongoing efforts to end the Israel-Hamas conflict and secure the release of hostages after the death of Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, according to the department’s readouts.

They also discussed the situation in Lebanon and the urgent need to deliver humanitarian aid to all vulnerable populations there, according to the readout.

During Blinken’s call with Qatari Prime Minister-Foreign Minister Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani he similarly “emphasized the need to chart a path forward that will enable the people of Gaza to rebuild their lives and realize their aspirations free from war and the grip of Hamas,” the department readout said.

In both calls, Blinken also “expressed appreciation for the humanitarian aid Saudi Arabia is providing to Lebanon and reaffirmed continued U.S. efforts to promote a diplomatic resolution along the Blue Line that implements United Nations Security Council Resolution 1701,” the readouts said.

Hezbollah announces "new and escalating phase" in war with Israel

Hezbollah announced a “new and escalating phase” in its war with Israel on Thursday.

The Iran-backed militant group said it has killed 55 Israeli soldiers and injured 500 since the start of Israel’s ground operations in Lebanon. CNN has reached out to the IDF for comment on Hezbollah’s claim.

Hezbollah’s statement on the Telegram app did not mention Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, who the Israeli military said was killed on Wednesday in the Gaza Strip.

The world is "now a better place" without Sinwar, Israel’s military chief says

The world is “now a better place” without Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, the Commander-in-Chief of the Israel Defense Forces, Herzi Halevi said on Thursday.

Halevi said he met with the troops who killed Sinwar, and said that they acted “correctly, with professionalism and determination — not because they knew Sinwar was there, but because our soldiers excel in every encounter with terrorists, in all sectors.”

Meanwhile, US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin called Sinwar’s death a “major achievement in counterterrorism.” He added that he hoped the death brings “some small measure of justice and solace to the families and the loved ones of the many victims of Sinwar’s premeditated cruelty.” Echoing what President Joe Biden and others have said, Austin reiterated that now is the time to reach a ceasefire agreement that secures the release of the remaining hostages, including American citizens.

Drone video shows Sinwar's final moments, Israeli military says

The IDF released drone video reportedly showing the Yahya Sinwar during his final moments.

The Israeli military has released video that it says shows Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar’s final moments.

Israel Defense Forces spokesperson Daniel Hagari played the video in a news briefing on Thursday.

The edited clip shows a drone going into a damaged building where a person — who the IDF says is Sinwar — can be seen sitting on a chair. The figure’s body is positioned away from the drone, but they appear to be looking toward the unmanned craft. The person’s face is obscured and they appear to be sitting alone.

Hagari said Sinwar had been shot in his hand, as the edited IDF video points to his hand.

The drone video shows the figure holding what the IDF highlights as a piece of wood, which the person lobs in the direction of the drone.

Israel says a drone later discovered Sinwar’s body in the rubble of the building, which was struck by an Israeli tank on Wednesday. Only after sending in soldiers on foot did the Israeli military identify the man as Hamas’ leader.

Watch the edited IDF video below:

still_21051131_4223.665999999999_still.jpg
IDF releases edited drone video they say is of Sinwar's final moments
00:29 - Source: CNN

5 Israeli soldiers killed in southern Lebanon, military says

The Israel Defense Forces said five of its soldiers were killed during military operations in southern Lebanon on Thursday.

The soldiers were Maj. Ofek Bachar, Capt. Elad Siman Tov, Staff Sgt. Elyashiv Eitan Wieder, Staff Sgt. Yakov Hillel, and Staff Sgt. Yehudah Dror Yahalom, the IDF said in a statement.

An officer and two additional soldiers were severely injured during the incident, according to the statement. These soldiers have been evacuated to a hospital and their families have been notified.

Israeli forces have been carrying out ground operations in southern Lebanon after launching an incursion across Israel’s northern border on October 1 in its campaign against Hezbollah.

CNN identifies building where Israeli military killed Hamas leader

Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar was killed in one of the only houses still standing in a residential area of Rafah, a CNN analysis of videos and photos released by the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) has found.

CNN was able to make the geolocation by comparing recent satellite imagery to videos and photos from the vicinity that were shared on social media by the IDF.

The home was roughly 1,000 feet (300 meters) from what appears to be an IDF forward operating base or vehicle depot.  Multiple satellite images from Planet Labs taken this month show a number of military vehicles, and even a bulldozer, parked among newly constructed earthen berms in the same spots over multiple days and weeks.

On Thursday, IDF spokesperson Daniel Hagari confirmed Sinwar was killed in the Tal al-Sultan area of Rafah.

It’s unclear whether Sinwar was sheltering in the area for some time or had only recently sheltered there.  But the area was largely untouched by the war until August 28, when a group of homes was destroyed just north of where Sinwar was killed, according to CNN’s review of the Planet Labs satellite imagery.

By September 2, the home where Sinwar was found was surrounded by destruction. Bulldozing immediately followed. Several of the roadways around the home on September 10 are seen destroyed, and homes are seen completely leveled, in the satellite imagery.

Helping recover Gaza hostages is closely linked with tracking Hamas leaders, US officials say

While US special operations forces in Israel have been primarily focused on hostage recovery efforts, officials told CNN on Thursday that those efforts often overlapped with helping find Hamas leadership, due to their practice of keeping hostages around the group’s leaders.

US officials have said since last year that special operations forces were in Israel to assist with hostage recovery, but President Joe Biden on Thursday said he directed them to go to Israel after Hamas’ October 7 attacks “to help locate and track” Yahya Sinwar and other Hamas leaders.

Sinwar was killed in Gaza during an Israeli operation on Wednesday, Israel says.

US officials believed for months that Sinwar was underground and possibly surrounded by hostages he was using as shields. An Israeli military spokesperson said Thursday that Sinwar was killed in an area close to where the bodies of six hostages were recovered last month.

Still, officials don’t believe US intelligence was actively a part of the operation that killed Sinwar. National security adviser Jake Sullivan said Thursday that it was “an IDF operation,” and the special operations personnel and intelligence professionals “deserve our thanks for the work that they did alongside the IDF over the course of many months to help create the kind of counterterrorism pressure that put a lot of these guys on the run.”

The Israeli military believes Sinwar was trying to escape the Rafah area in southern Gaza and head north at the time he was killed.

US sees Netanyahu and Biden nearing common ground on Gaza, though Israel's retaliation on Iran still expected

As frustrations mounted between the US and Israel in recent months, calls between the two countries’ leaders – which became increasingly rare – have been described as “direct,” “candid” and “frank,” with the leaders mincing no words as President Joe Biden pressed the need for a denouement and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu defended a war expanding on multiple fronts.

Now, with the death of Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar in Gaza seen as a watershed moment for the conflict’s escalation, US officials are optimistic that Biden and Netanyahu are more closely aligned on a diplomatic resolution as being within reach, citing the parallel language in Israel’s readout of today’s call.

“Both leaders agreed that there is an opportunity to advance the release of the hostages and that they would work together to achieve this objective,” the prime minister’s office released in its official readout of the call, which Biden placed from a secure line aboard Air Force One.

Biden and Netanyahu – and their national security teams – are expecting to stay in close contact over the coming days as next steps are decided.

But despite optimism that Sinwar’s death could bring a deal in Gaza closer to fruition, two sources familiar with the matter acknowledge that Israel’s approach to Iran and its proxies elsewhere are seen as “distinct” operations. Israel’s pending retaliation against Iran could come within days, one source said, with CNN previously reporting it was expected before the US election.

Analysis: What does Sinwar's death mean

What does the death of Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar mean? The release of Israeli hostages in Gaza? Too soon to say.

To think through what happens next, perhaps the most crucial piece of information is the fate of his brother Mohammed. Last month a very senior Israeli official told CNN that Mohammad Sinwar had taken over as Hamas’s military commander after the killing of its pre-war chief Mohammed Deif in an Israeli air strike on July 13.

Yahya and Mohammed were always very close and rose through Hamas’s ranks together; the same senior official told CNN that as recently as late August they were often still together. Could they have died together on Wednesday? If Mohammed survived this week, he will likely continue his brother’s hardline negotiating tactics as Israel seeks to extract its remaining hostages from the Palestinian enclave.

Until a clear picture emerges, it will be hard to know the terror group’s next move in the deadlocked negotiations for a hostage release and ceasefire deal.

As Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu mulls the success of Wednesday’s strike, he may calculate he is edging closer to being able to declare that Hamas no longer constitutes a threat of invading Israel again. In reality, those capabilities faded many months ago, but now the killing of Sinwar — seen as one of the architects of the October 7 attacks — could give Netanyahu space for compromise in negotiations.

Sinwar was trying to escape to the north when he was killed, Israeli military spokesperson says

Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar was trying to escape to the north when he was killed by the Israel Defense Forces in Gaza on Wednesday, Israeli military spokesperson Daniel Hagari said at a news briefing Thursday.

“We continued to operate to check terrorists are not running from this region,” Hagari said.

Israeli forces found Sinwar with a vest, a gun and 40,000 shekels, the IDF spokesperson said.

He went on to say Sinwar’s DNA was found in tunnels a few hundred meters from where the six hostages were killed earlier this year.

Some families of Israeli hostages say they feel like "justice has been served" with death of Sinwar

Gil Dickmann, 31, the cousin of Carmel Gat, who was killed by Hamas weeks ago alongside five other hostages, appears on CNN on Thursday, October 17.

Some of the families of those taken hostage on October 7 in Israel said they feel like “justice has been served” after the Israeli military said it killed Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar.

Gil Dickmann, 31, the cousin of Carmel Gat, who was killed by Hamas weeks ago alongside five other hostages, that Sinwar’s “activity in Gaza has had so many victims, among them thousands of Palestinians, and of course, my cousin, who we just learned today was with him in captivity,” according to the Hostages and Missing Families Forum.

Meanwhile Daniel Lifshitz, the 36-year-old grandson of Oded Lifshitz, who turned 84 while in captivity in Gaza, said that Sinwar had been a “major obstacle” to reaching a deal to release remaining hostages, but now “this obstacle has been removed.”

“We urge all involved parties to work toward an immediate agreement to bring everyone back home,” Lifshitz added.

Israeli strikes killed at least 45 people in Lebanon on Wednesday, ministry says

Smoke billows near Nabatiyeh, as seen from Marjayoun, near the Lebanese border with Israel, on Wednesday, October 16.

At least 45 people were killed and 179 injured in Israeli airstrikes across Lebanon on Wednesday, according to a statement by the Lebanese Ministry of Health.

The strikes targeted cities and villages in southern and eastern Lebanon, including Nabatiyeh, Beqaa, Baalbek, and the southern region, the ministry said in the statement sent to CNN on Thursday.

It brings the overall death toll to 1,750, with 9,067 others injured since Israel escalated military operations in Lebanon on September 16. The number is a CNN count based on previous reports from the ministry.

Sinwar was killed in Rafah, Israeli military spokesperson says

IDF International Spokesperson Major Doron Spielman speaks with CNN on Thursday, October 17.

Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar was killed in Rafah in southern Gaza, close to where the bodies of six hostages were recovered in September, a spokesperson for the Israeli military said.

Israel Defense Forces spokesperson Doron Spielman told CNN Israeli ground and tank troops were there as they believed that “very senior terrorist commanders” including Sinwar were in the area. The troops came under fire, so they returned fire with a tank, he said. Later, when they went to inspect the building, they realized that Sinwar was amongst the rubble.

The Hamas leader was found alongside three people, Spielman said, “one of which is a person that has been by his side the entire time, which is the battalion commander of the Khan Younis brigade. He was also killed in that rubble.” He did not provide the name of the commander.

Some background: Last month, the IDF said the bodies of six hostages were found in a Hamas-run tunnel in Rafah, and that they were “brutally” murdered “a short while” before troops were able to reach them.

Hospital receiving Palestinians injured in an Israeli strike is struggling to treat them, doctor says

The chaotic scene as casualties arrive at Kamal Adwan Hospital following Israeli strike Thursday, October 17 on aschool in northern Gaza.

The director of the Kamal Adwan Hospital – one of the last remaining operational hospitals in northern Gaza – said it received “a very large number of casualties” on Thursday after an Israeli airstrike on a school-turned-shelter in the Jabalya refugee camp, and health care workers are struggling to treat them.

“Most of the cases that we deal with are critical cases, and are now in operating rooms,” he added.

The Israeli strike on Abu Hussein School killed at least 28 Palestinians and wounded 150 other people, Abu Saifiya said, adding that the death toll expected to rise in the coming hours.

The Israel Defense Forces claimed an Israeli warplane had carried out a strike on a “command and control center used by Hamas and Islamic Jihad terrorists.”

Footage: Dozens of men and boys wounded in the airstrike are seen being carried out of ambulances in the courtyard of Kamal Adwan Hospital, in video shared by Abu Saifiya. Paramedics, nurses and doctors line the entrance to the facility, where rescue crews delicately treat patients.

The footage also shows several children surrounding a young boy, who lays motionless on an orange gurney. The children are crying and clutching onto the stretcher, as other residents scream in the background. Wounded men lay on the blood-streaked hospital floor.

Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar has been killed, according to the Israeli military. Here’s what we know

Yahya Sinwar during a meeting with leaders of Palestinian factions at his office in Gaza City, April 13, 2022.

Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, one of the masterminds of the October 7 massacre in Israel, was killed during an operation in the Gaza Strip on Wednesday, the Israeli military announced on Thursday.

The Israel Defense Forces confirmed Sinwar was “eliminated” after Israeli officials ran DNA tests and used dental records to confirm his identity.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu addressed the killing of Sinwar by saying, “This is the beginning of the day after Hamas.”

“Evil has suffered a heavy blow, but the task before us is not yet complete,” Netanyahu said in a recorded video message. Netanyahu called Sinwar’s killing an “important moment in the war,” telling residents of Gaza that it is an “opportunity” for them to “finally break free from (Hamas’) tyranny.”

Here’s more on what we know about Sinwar’s death:

Body discovered by drone, identified by Israeli soldiers: The bodies Sinwar and others killed with him were spotted by a drone in rubble in Gaza on Thursday, following a Wednesday tank strike on a building, a person familiar told CNN. It was only when Israeli soldiers went in on foot and got a closer look that they started to suspect that it was Sinwar, the source said. Sinwar was killed in the area of the southern Gaza city of Rafah, the person said.

Netanyahu issues warning to Hamas and asks for hostages to be released: The Israeli prime minister warned Hamas its leaders will be eliminated and called on those holding Israeli hostages captive to lay down their weapons and return the hostages, saying whoever does so will be allowed to “go out and live.”

US sees potential in Sinwar’s death for restarting ceasefire talks: US President Joe Biden praised the killing of Sinwar, adding it’s his hope that now is the opportunity for looking toward the next steps for Gaza. Despite all the unknowns, the moment was viewed inside the White House and across Biden’s administration as a momentous one. The US will “redouble its efforts with partners to end this conflict” after the death of Sinwar, Secretary of State Antony Blinken said.

Hostage families plead for loved ones: The families of American hostages still being held in Gaza called for their release following Sinwar’s death. “It is now time for every single hostage held in Gaza to be returned to their families,” they said in a joint statement released Thursday. Also, the parents of Israeli American hostage Omer Neutra said the news of Sinwar’s death is “a critical, time-sensitive development as it relates to the hostages. Their lives are in great danger now more than ever.”

What Gazans are saying: Palestinians in Gaza told CNN they do not believe Sinwar’s killing will put an end to the war. But others remain hopeful. “Sinwar has died, but so many of our people have been killed, and there is no excuse now for Netanyahu to continue the war,” 22-year-old Mumen Khalili said.

Israelis notified US early today that they believed they killed Sinwar

Israeli officials notified the US early Thursday morning that they “believed” they had killed Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, but needed to conduct testing to confirm it, according to a State Department spokesperson.

After that, the US and Israel had “a number of conversations, as you might imagine, at several different levels to try and confirm that information,” State Department spokesperson Matthew Miller said at a news briefing.

Miller said US officials across the government, including at the State Department and the US embassy in Israel, were notified by Israel about Sinwar.

He added that US Secretary of State Antony Blinken spoke with Qatar’s Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani, who serves as the country’s prime minister and foreign minister, as well as Saudi Foreign Minister Faisal bin Farhan Al Saud. Blinken made those calls while aboard Air Force One with President Joe Biden on their way to Berlin.