The latest: House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has said Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell must publish the rules for the Senate trial before the impeachment articles would be sent to the Senate.
Where the articles are now: Pelosi has yet to formally introduce them to the Senate, so a trial has not yet been set.
Our live coverage has ended, but you can scroll through the posts to read more.
28 Posts
Fact check: Trump claims Republicans won on impeachment
From CNN's Tara Subramaniam and Daniel Dale
SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images
At a campaign rally in Ohio, President Trump praised the unity of the Republicans on impeachment saying, they “won 196 to nothing in the House.”
Facts First:This claim is absurd. Trump did not win any vote related to impeachment, let alone win “196 to nothing.” In fact, he had decisively lost a key process vote and then the two votes to actually impeach him. He appeared to be referring to the fact that no Republican voted against him on these three occasions, but he wasn’t clear at all that this is what he meant.
The Democratic-controlled House voted 232-196 in October in favor of the Democrats’ proposed rules for the impeachment inquiry. (That is possibly the basis of Trump’s “196” figure in this quote, but the claim that “we won 196 to nothing” remains nonsensical.) The House voted 230-197 and 229-198 in December on the two articles of impeachment.
Link Copied!
Meanwhile, Trump holds a campaign rally in Ohio
From CNN's Allie Malloy and Tara Subramaniam
Saul Loeb/AFP/Getty Images
A handful of protesters interrupted President Trump at the beginning of his Ohio rally tonight.
“Go home to Mommy!” Trump said to the crowd as the protesters were taken out. “Thank you security. Do we love law enforcement by the way?
After a protester was loudly booed out of the audience, Trump resumed talking about the military. He repeated one of his most frequent claims, that he has “taken care of our vets with choice.”
Facts First:The Veterans Choice bill, a bipartisan initiative led by Sen. Bernie Sanders and the late John McCain, was signed into law by former President Barack Obama in 2014. In 2018, Trump signed the VA Mission Act, which expanded and changed the program.
Trump also made two false claims on the environment at his rally tonight.
Facts First: The US has not just “now” become the world’s top energy producer: it took the top spot in 2012, according to the US government’s Energy Information Administration – under the very Obama administration Trump is accusing of perpetrating a “war” on the industry.
The US became the top producer of crude oil in particular during Trump’s tenure. “The United States has been the world’s top producer of natural gas since 2009, when US natural gas production surpassed that of Russia, and it has been the world’s top producer of petroleum hydrocarbons since 2013, when its production exceeded Saudi Arabia’s,” the Energy Information Administration said.
Facts First:By several measures, US air was cleaner under Obama than it has been under Trump.
There were more “unhealthy air days” for sensitive groups in 2018 than in 2016. Additionally, the lowest amount of unhealthy air days – 598 – occurred in 2014 under Obama. You can read more here.
Link Copied!
McConnell rejects Pelosi's demand to unveil resolution on trial procedures before articles are sent over
From CNN's Manu Raju
Stefani Reynolds/CNP/Sipa USA
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell rejected House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s demand that he must first unveil the resolution detailing President Trump’s trial procedures before she sends over the articles of impeachment to the Senate.
McConnell added he’s at a loss when the Senate trial will start. “Haven’t heard a thing,” he said, adding that speculation that the trial could start next week is based on the “same thing you’ve been hearing.”
His statement is the latest indication that the ball remains in Pelosi’s court about when she’ll appoint her impeachment managers and send over the articles, which will start the trial.
As she’s criticized the process outlined by McConnell, Pelosi continues to be vague in public and private about her exact plans — but said the articles would be sent sometime “soon.”
Link Copied!
Schiff shoots down having Bolton testify in the House before Senate trial
From CNN's Manu Raju
Photo by SAUL LOEB/AFP via Getty Images
House Intelligence Chairman Adam Schiff told CNN that his committee has no plans to hear testimony from former national security adviser John Bolton before President Trump’s impeachment trial in the Senate, arguing there’s “little to be gained” by going that route.
Schiff said they have not had discussions with Bolton or his team since the former White House aide announced that he’d be willing to testify before the Senate if subpoenaed.
With GOP senators resisting calls to bring him in before their chamber, some have suggested that House Democrats should instead compel testimony from Bolton, who previously warned the House Intelligence Committee he’d fight any subpoena in court.
But Schiff said Thursday that Bolton should testify before the Senate — not the House.
Schiff added: “There’s little to be gained by having him testify separately and then have the Senate get the stale records. If we’re doing this rationally and we’re trying to achieve a fair trial, he should testify before the Senate.”
Link Copied!
McConnell signs onto resolution allowing articles to be dismissed
From CNN's Clare Foran
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has signed onto a resolution from Republican Sen. Josh Hawley to allow for articles of impeachment to be dismissed because House Speaker Nancy Pelosi still has not transmitted them to the Senate.
Hawley introduced to resolution earlier this week on Monday. However, Republicans don’t have the votes to dismiss the articles.
Where things stand: Republicans are now anticipating that Pelosi will in fact send over articles soon.
Sen. John Cornyn said today that Republicans believe the impeachment trial will begin next week. He said articles of impeachment would likely come by the end of the week.
Link Copied!
Republican senator says he thinks the impeachment trial will start next week
From CNN's Ted Barrett
Photo by Zach Gibson/Getty Images
Republican Sen. John Cornyn said today that Republicans believe the impeachment trial will begin next week.
He also speculated that the articles of impeachment would likely come by the end of the week.
Link Copied!
What's happening behind closed doors in the impeachment talks
From CNN's Manu Raju and Jeremy Herb
US Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi speaks during her weekly press briefing on Capitol Hill on Thursday.
BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP via Getty Images
Two sources say at a closed meeting in House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s office, she did not tip her hand to her six chairmen — who are investigating President Trump — about her timeline on sending the articles of impeachment to the Senate.
At a separate meeting with her top messengers on impeachment, sources indicated that Pelosi was still insistent on seeing the details of the Senate procedures before sending the articles over.
CNN’s Dana Bash reports they discussed polling on the public backing a fair trial in the Senate.
Link Copied!
Pelosi is privately telling people she hopes to move on the impeachment articles soon
From CNN's Dana Bash
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is telling people privately that they should to stay close, signaling, without saying, that she is hoping and planning to move on impeachment articles soon — like in the next 24 hours.
Pelosi understands that vulnerable members in her caucus especially will have a hard time going home again without having sent the articles to the Senate.
Her hope is that this is made easier by Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell actually sending her the outlines of the trial plans, as he said publicly he would.
Link Copied!
GOP lawmaker expresses frustration on articles not being sent over to Senate
From CNN's Ali Zaslav and Ted Barrett
Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images
As she was leaving Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell’s office, Republican Sen. Lisa Murkowski told reporters that it is “frustrating” the articles of impeachment have not been sent over to the Senate.
What we know: House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has yet to formally introduce the articles to the Senate. Asked about the articles today, the California Democrat said, “I’ll send them over when I’m ready. And that will probably be soon.”
Link Copied!
Internal debate rages over adding House members to Trump defense team
From CNN's Sarah Westwood and Phil Mattingly
Rep. Jim Jordan makes remarks during a House Judiciary Committee markup of Articles of Impeachment against President Donald Trump on December 12.
Jonathan Newton/Pool/Getty Images
President Trump is receiving conflicting advice on whether to bring conservative House members onto his defense team for the impeachment trial, multiple sources familiar with the discussions said.
Some of his allies and advisers have pushed the White House to include some combination of Republican Reps. Jim Jordan, Matt Gaetz, Mark Meadows, John Ratcliffe and Mike Johnson to the defense team, believing those staunch Trump supporters could deliver the kind of robust defense the President believes he was denied during the House inquiry.
But top Senate Republicans, including Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, have been advising Trump that bringing on GOP House members could frustrate efforts to keep Republicans as unified as possible during the trial. Trump and McConnell met Wednesday at the White House, and the upcoming trial was one of the subjects raised CNN reported.
Other Trump allies, like House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy, have suggested Trump consider waiting to name any member of Congress to his defense team until House Democrats unveil their managers, who will act as prosecutors in the upcoming trial. They suggested he then pick the Republicans who would be most effective against those specific Democrats.
It’s something Republican senators and White House aides have been grappling with for weeks. And the President’s shifting ideas about the trial and what his team’s strategy have left some lawmakers confused.
Some background: CNN previously reported that Jordan, Ratcliffe and Johnson met with Pat Cipollone — who is expected to lead the President’s defense — at the White House just before Christmas, and the President spent much of his two-week working vacation at Mar-a-Lago polling friends and advisers about who would do the best job representing him at the trial.
Link Copied!
Senators plan to leave DC after last votes today
From CNN's Ted Barrett
With the impeachment impasse ongoing, Republican and Democratic senators told CNN they plan to leave Washington after the last votes today.
The votes are expected at about 2 p.m. ET, but are not scheduled yet.
Republican Sen. Jim Risch, the chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, dug into his pocket to show off the boarding pass for his afternoon flight home.
More context: The GOP senator noted — something CNN reported Wednesday — that even if House Speaker Nancy Pelosi abruptly changes course and sends the impeachment articles to the Senate immediately, trial rules provide time for President Trump and his legal team to be summoned to the Senate. They will be given two days to appear.
That would also give senators time to return to DC if needed.
Link Copied!
Sen. Lindsey Graham on impeachment: "The dam is broken"
From CNN's Ali Zaslav
Sen. Lindsey Graham, a Republican from South Carolina, told reporters today that he thinks the impeachment trial will start next week because “the dam is broken.”
He went on to say that he doesn’t think that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi can sit on the articles of impeachment for another few days.
Link Copied!
Trump says he has "no problem" with Bolton testifying but wants to "protect presidential privilege"
From CNN's Betsy Klein
Sergei Gapon/AFP/Getty Images
President Trump weighed in today on former national security adviser John Bolton’s announcement that he is willing to testify in a Senate impeachment trial if subpoenaed, saying he wouldn’t stop it but he’d have to ask his lawyers.
“I always got along with him, he didn’t really get along with some of our people, but that’s really going to be up to the Senate,” Trump said.
“I don’t stop it, no,” Trump said, but added, “I’d have to ask the lawyers.”
He continued: “I would have no problem, other than we have to protect — we have to be able to protect — people can’t go up and say whatever my thoughts are … We don’t want that to be out so we have to protect presidential privilege.”
Link Copied!
Trump says he's open to witnesses in Senate impeachment trial
From CNN's Kevin Liptak
Asked if he’d like to see witnesses testify at an impeachment trial, Trump said, “I’m going to leave it to the Senate,” before listing off a group of people who he’d like to hear from.
Speaking at an announcement of proposed National Environmental Policy Act regulations at the White House, the President went on to list all of the witnesses he’d like to see during a trial.
That included the whistleblower, House Intelligence Chair Adam Schiff, Hunter Biden, and Joe Biden, “and some others,” including “the informer that never showed up” and the “second whistleblower.”
Link Copied!
Pelosi says she'll miss the Niners playoff game: “I have, unfortunately, responsibilities to save our country from peril”
As she wrapped up her weekly news conference, Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi was asked if she would attend the San Francisco 49ers’ NFL playoff game this weekend.
Some in the briefing room laughed at the remark. Pelosi did not elaborate on what “peril” exactly means.
Tensions between the US and Iran escalated this week following a US airstrike that killed Iran’s top general. The House is expected to vote today on legislation that could restrain Trump’s ability to launch military action against Iran.
Meanwhile, Pelosi is also holding onto the articles of impeachment against President Trump. She has not yet sent them to the Senate, which will hold a trial and determine if he should be removed from office after the articles are formally transmitted.
Link Copied!
Pelosi on impeachment articles: "I'll send them over when I'm ready"
Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi was just asked if she plans to hold the articles of impeachment “indefinitely.”
Here’s how she responded:
Link Copied!
Pelosi still doesn't say when she plans to send impeachment articles
Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi repeated some Democrats’ request that the Senate outline its protocols for the impeachment trial before she formally transmit the articles over.
Pelosi has given no indication for when she could send the articles of impeachment over. Lawmakers close to Pelosi insist they have been given no sense of when she will tee up the vote on the House managers to transmit the articles to the Senate.
“As I said right from the start, we need to see the arena in which we’re sending our managers. Is that too much to ask?” she asked at a news conference today.
Link Copied!
SOON: Nancy Pelosi takes questions
Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi will have her weekly news conference at 10:45 a.m. ET. Reporters will likely ask her questions about the articles of impeachment, which the House has approved but not yet sent to the Senate.
Lawmakers close to Pelosi insist they have been given no sense of when Pelosi will tee up the vote on the House managers to transmit the articles to the Senate.
However, in the words of one senior House Democrat: “We’re all working under the assumption it’s coming this week.”
Link Copied!
Democratic congressman: "We should do everything we can to force the Senate to have a fair trial"
From CNN's Haley Byrd
Rep. Adam Smith, a Democrat from Washington state, has walked back his comments about the timing of the articles of impeachment handover.
On CNN’s “New Day” earlier this morning, the chairman of the House Armed Services Committee said he believed it was time to send the articles to the Senate.
“I do believe we should do everything we can to force the Senate to have a fair trial. If the Speaker believes that holding on to the articles for a longer time will help force a fair trial in the Senate, then I wholeheartedly support that decision,” he tweeted now/
Here are his tweets:
Link Copied!
This swing district Democrat thinks it's time to send over articles
From CNN's Manu Raju
Rep. Ben McAdams of Utah, a freshman from a swing district, told CNN: “I think it’s time” to send over the articles.
Link Copied!
House Democrats say they're close to sending impeachment articles to Senate
From CNN's Manu Raju
Two key House Democrats indicated today there was not going to be an indefinite delay to turning over the articles of impeachment, signaling they were close to being sent over to the Senate.
House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer said, “no,” there won’t be an indefinite delay.
And Rep. Jamie Raskin, a member of the House Judiciary committee, defended House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s strategy on holding the articles thus far, but said:
Link Copied!
What Mitch McConnell has been doing during the impeachment standoff
From CNN's Phil Mattingly
The Senate doesn’t have the articles of impeachment yet: While the House passed two articles last month, Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi hasn’t formally transmitted them to the Senate, which means the looming impeachment trial has not yet been set.
So what’s Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell doing in the meantime? Publicly, he’s taking the Senate floor each day to lambaste Pelosi and Democrats for not sending over the articles of impeachment.
However, he’s also working in a detailed manner behind the scenes to tee up the looming trial.
He’s methodically walked through, and brought along, his conference for months now on the trial structure he prefers, using briefings, presentations and one-on-one meetings and calls, according to multiple senators — and now every member of his conference is on board.
In a much quieter fashion, he’s done the same thing with President Trump, people familiar with their conversations say, in regular phone calls and some in-person meetings. He’s made his points on the trial structure he wants to see, on the drawbacks, in his view, that calling witnesses may have for the President and made clear the President’s defense team should be geared around ensuring Republican senators are comfortable with what they’re seeing and hearing on the floor, not Fox News hosts.
Link Copied!
4 key events to watch today
The impasse over the articles of impeachment continues, and lawmakers close to Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi insist they have been given no sense of when she will transmit the articles to the Senate.
That said, here are four events were watching today:
10:45 a.m. ET: Pelosi will take questions at her weekly news conference. Reporters will likely ask her about the impeachment articles.
11 a.m. ET: President Trump will announce new proposed National Environmental Policy Act regulations. It’s not clear if he’ll mention impeachment at this event.
11:30 a.m. ET: House Republican leader Kevin McCarthy will hold his news press conference.
7 p.m. ET: Trump will host a rally in Toledo, Ohio.
Link Copied!
What the House's Iran War Powers vote could mean for impeachment
The House will vote today on the Iran War Powers resolution, which would direct President Trump to halt US military action related to Iran unless or until he comes to Congress for authorization.
This is a significant vote intended to send a message from House Democrats on a deadly serious issue that has enormous stakes.
What this means for impeachment: It would seem unlikely that Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, who has yet to send the articles of impeachment to the Senate, would want to do anything to step on that before that vote occurs.
Additionally, there’s a measure in the Senate, introduced by Democrat Sen. Tim Kaine, which calls for the removal of US armed forces from hostilities with Iran not authorized by Congress. Senate Democrats are hoping to proceed quickly with it, and he told CNN yesterday that he hopes to see action on it in the Senate as soon as next week — although the timeline may be complicated by the impending impeachment trial.
You can follow live updates on the US-Iran crisis and today’s House vote here.
Link Copied!
Trump tweets: Pelosi doesn't want to send impeachment articles because they "are a joke and a scam!"
From CNN's Betsy Klein
President Trump has impeachment on his mind this morning, tweeting that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi doesn’t want to hand impeachment articles to the Senate because “they show no crimes and are a joke and a scam!”
Pelosi, who has not said when she plans to transmit the articles to the Senate, will hold her weekly news conference at 10:45 a.m. ET. She could talk more about impeachment then.
Link Copied!
Pelosi hasn't sent the impeachment articles to the Senate. Now, Democrats say it's time.
From CNN's Phil Mattingly
Patience with Speaker Nancy Pelosi has run out…among Democrats.
While the House approved two articles of impeachment against Trump last month, Pelosi has yet to formally introduce them to the Senate, so a trial has not yet been set.
The current frustration over the impasse is not just Senate Democrats, who have become quite vocal in their desire to see the impeachment articles transmitted, finally, to the Senate. Several House Democrats CNN spoke to yesterday made clear that while they believe Pelosi’s strategy has been successful to a degree and their trust in the Speaker remains rock solid, it was time for the Speaker to pull the trigger and send the articles to the Senate.
Here’s the bottom line: Lawmakers close to Pelosi still insist they have been given no sense of when Pelosi will tee up the vote on the House managers to transmit the articles to the Senate, but in the words of one senior House Democrat:
Link Copied!
McConnell met with Trump yesterday to talk about impeachment
From CNN's Manu Raju, Phil Mattingly and Pamela Brown
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and President Trump met yesterday at the White House and discussed the upcoming Senate impeachment trial, according to multiple sources familiar with the matter.
McConnell, one of the sources said, walked Trump through the trial format and discussed how Senate Republicans were reacting to the developments around the trial.
McConnell was at the White House to introduce Trump to a judge, and later the Senate leader and the President met privately.
The majority leader has not shared with the White House the text of the resolution that would set up the trial, according to one of the sources, who insists there’s no negotiation with the GOP leader’s office on how the language should be drafted.
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has demanded to see the resolution before sending to the Senate the two articles of impeachment, which would set up the Senate trial.
For weeks, the White House has been engaged in a continuing discussion with the leader’s office and has reacted to various ideas and proposals about how they believe the trial should be set up.
McConnell wants a quick trial in the Senate — and White House officials confirm to CNN that they are on the same page with the leader.
“We want this to start as quickly as possible,” said Eric Ueland, the White House legislative director. “We want the president to be acquitted as quickly as possible.”
Link Copied!
Catch up: Senate trial negotiations and other developments in Trump's impeachment
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi remain at an impasse over the impeachment articles and upcoming trial against President Trump.
Here are the latest developments:
Senate Democrats want to start the trial: Senate Democrats are growing eager to start Trump’s impeachment trial. The delay is upsetting efforts for senators to plan — both their work and personal schedules as well as their legislative efforts — amid the uncertainty over the standoff, according to multiple senators.
Wait-and-see approach: Pelosi told reporters yesterday that Democrats continue to wait and “see what the terms are” for a Senate impeachment trial. She said, “How we choose our managers depends on what the arena is we are going into.”
McConnell not budging on trial terms: The Senate majority leader said yesterday that Pelosi has no leverage in determining the rules of the Senate trial. He went on to say, “There will be no haggling with the House over Senate procedure. We will not cede our authority to try this impeachment. The House Democrats’ turn is over. The Senate has made its decision.”
Democrats defend Pelosi: House Judiciary members backed Pelosi’s decision to hold the impeachment articles until they see the parameters of a Senate trial. Rep. David Cicilline said he thinks it’s important for Pelosi to “understand and that we understand what those proceedings look like.”