January 3, 2023 Latest on the new Congress and House speaker vote | CNN Politics

January 3, 2023 Latest on the new Congress and House speaker vote

Chip Roy Manu Raju vpx
'Who will blink first?': Hear why the vote for speaker is taking so long
02:03 - Source: CNN

What we covered here

  • GOP leader Kevin McCarthy failed Tuesday to secure enough support to win the speakership after a third round of voting – and lawmakers decided to postpone future votes until Wednesday.
  • House members can’t be sworn in until the speaker stalemate ends. Neither McCarthy nor the Republicans voting against him appear ready to back down.
  • A nominee needs 218 votes, but the number required could change if members withhold their votes.
  • House Democrats united behind caucus chair Hakeem Jeffries of New York as leader of the Democratic minority, a historic move that makes him the first Black lawmaker to lead a party in Congress.

Our live coverage for the day has ended. Follow the latest political news here or read through the updates below. 

88 Posts

McCarthy says he won't drop out of race for speaker

Rep. Kevin McCarthy said late Tuesday there is no scenario under which he will drop out of the race for House speaker.

“It’s not going to happen,” McCarthy said.

The House GOP leader told reporters he believes he is “not that far away” from clinching the votes, saying he only needed “11 more votes to win,” implying that he thinks he can get a number of members to vote present. 

McCarthy said he spoke to former President Donald Trump on Tuesday night and that the former president “reiterated support.” 

 “He thinks it is better that all the Republicans get together and solve this,” McCarthy said of Trump. “It doesn’t look good for Republicans, but we want to be able to solve it when we’re stronger in the long run. What we went through today, in the end, becomes a positive that we’re actually focused, united, much more.” 

As to why the House adjourned after three rounds of voting for speaker, McCarthy said, “I didn’t think we were going to get any more productive by continuing on the day.”

Rep. Patrick McHenry says more negotiations are needed but he's confident McCarthy will be speaker

GOP Rep. Patrick McHenry emerged from Kevin McCarthy’s office Tuesday night and said there is a “longer process of negotiation” that needs to happen within the GOP conference, but that he is still confident McCarthy will ultimately be elected speaker.  

McHenry even said he believes some of the 20 lawmakers who voted against McCarthy will come around. “Not 100% of them,” he said. “But I don’t need 100% of them.”

McHenry said there needs to be “a clear understanding” about what offers were made going into today, and now that 20 members have come out in opposition to McCarthy, “we have to have a wider group of members understand what the tradeoffs are, what they look like, and the opportunity for the conference to come to terms with getting the 20 on board.” 

“So this is a longer process of negotiation than just a narrow group, talking to a person,” he said.

McCarthy dropping out is “not on the table,” McHenry said.

Rep. Bruce Westerman echoed McHenry’s sentiment that McCarthy will not drop out of the race.

He told CNN that he met with the GOP leader and described him as “upbeat.”

“I have not seen him dejected,” Westerman said.

The Arkansas Republican said he too believes McCarthy will turn it around, but acknowledged that he didn’t know exactly how it would happen.

“I think there’s opportunities to get that headed back in the right direction,” he said of McCarthy’s vote count.

McCarthy failed to secure enough support to win the speakership after three rounds of voting on Tuesday — and lawmakers decided to postpone future votes until Wednesday.

Trump declines to reiterate McCarthy endorsement despite appeals from McCarthy allies

Former President Donald Trump declined to issue a statement Monday to reiterate his endorsement of Rep. Kevin McCarthy as House speaker, despite a behind-the-scenes effort from several of McCarthy’s allies to get Trump to do so, according to two sources familiar with what happened. 

Trump has not rescinded his endorsement of McCarthy, and ultimately may not, but the former president is watching closely as the dynamic plays out on Capitol Hill.

His silence as McCarthy faced three failed votes did not go unnoticed as Trump privately seemed to side with the hardliners against McCarthy in some conversations Tuesday, according to one of the sources. 

It’s important to note that Trump made calls on McCarthy’s behalf to those hardliners Monday.

Analysis: How the Capitol drama is turning into a horror show

There’s a slow-motion, open-ended drama playing out on the floor of the House in which Republicans cannot come behind a speaker – one of the most powerful and important jobs in US government, and the prize they won with a slim House majority.

And Congress can’t function until it has a House speaker. Nobody knows how this will end.

Here’s how the Capitol drama is turning into a horror show:

20-member roadblock. It’s a story of how 20 Republican lawmakers, despite obtaining most of their demands from Rep. Kevin McCarthy, simply will not support the man. The first two votes started with 19 holdouts but grew to 20 in the third vote.

Can’t ‘close the deal.’ Some small cracks in McCarthy’s support were starting to show in the third vote, after 4 p.m. ET, when Rep. Byron Donalds of Florida jumped camps from supporting McCarthy earlier in the day to backing Rep. Jim Jordan of Ohio.

By backing Jordan, Donalds joined the original 19, including people like Reps. Matt Gaetz of Florida, Rep. Lauren Boebert of Colorado, Rep. Chip Roy of Texas and Rep. Andy Biggs of Arizona, who are equally committed.

‘Sold himself.’ Gaetz, in nominating Jordan before the second round of voting, stood right in front of McCarthy and accused him of having “sold himself” in the quest for the speaker post.

This drama – or sideshow, if that’s how you view it – does presage a very difficult year for the ultimate speaker in which the debt ceiling must be raised to avert an economic meltdown.

Read more:

House GOP not now expected to hold conference meeting Wednesday morning

As Kevin McCarthy scrambles to find a path out of the current stalemate, the GOP leadership tells CNN that – as of Tuesday night – there is no longer a conference meeting scheduled for tomorrow morning.

Sources earlier had said a House GOP leadership meeting was expected Wednesday morning to hash out their disagreements and find a way forward.

Meanwhile, talks continue tonight, with McCarthy in his office making calls, sources said.

Allies say the GOP House leader is not dropping out and is still prepared to grind this out.

McCarthy failed to secure enough support to win the speakership after three rounds of voting on Tuesday — and lawmakers decided to postpone future votes until Wednesday.

The headline and story have been updated to reflect the latest news on the conference meeting.

Hakeem Jeffries says he does not want to help Republicans out of their "dysfunction"

Jeffries, accompanied by incoming House Minority Whip Rep. Katherine Clark,  and incoming Incoming Democratic Caucus Chair Pete Aguilar, speaks at a news conference  on Capitol Hill on Tuesday, January 3.

Incoming House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries told reporters he is not willing at this point to help Republicans elect a speaker. 

Jeffries said he has not had any outreach from Republican leadership or individuals on the other side of the aisle “with respect to the chaos crisis and confusion that we saw unfold before the American people today.”

McCarthy supporter says he sees two ways forward: Negotiate with critics or team up with Democrats

With a harsh reality setting in, Rep. Kevin McCarthy’s supporters acknowledge they will have to do more than just keep voting for him on multiple ballots and hope the critics back down. 

The only path forward for McCarthy, one lawmaker said, is he “negotiates with the 20 or looks for ways to get bipartisan support,” referring to the 20 Republicans who voted for Rep. Jim Jordan in opposition to McCarthy during the third round of voting Tuesday.

McCarthy, however, has ruled out courting the support of Democrats, while Democrats said they won’t bail him out. Theoretically, Democrats could vote present or not show up, which would lower the threshold McCarthy needs to be speaker, but they would certainly demand something in return.

As far as negotiating with his GOP opposition, McCarthy has already given them almost every concession they have asked for. So he doesn’t have many more cards to play. 

In other words, it’s a difficult and narrow path ahead for McCarthy, with his hardline critics digging and feeling more emboldened.

McCarthy is negotiating with lawmakers Tuesday night in pursuit of speakership

Kevin McCarthy speaks with lawmakers on the House floor on Tuesday.

A source familiar with Rep. Kevin McCarthy’s thinking tells CNN “negotiations are ongoing” Tuesday night but declined to comment further.

The House adjourned after McCarthy failed to reach the majority needed to be elected speaker three times.

The CNN team outside McCarthy’s office has also observed a large number of pizzas being wheeled in.

GOP moderates already laying groundwork for far-fetched team-up with Democrats

Moderate Republicans are already laying the groundwork for far-fetched plans of how to potentially team up with Democrats in the coming days if the dynamics with the 20 GOP holdouts remain.

Democrats have said they do not want to help Kevin McCarthy become speaker and are facing pressure not to cave. But even the whispers among Republicans show how desperate the situation could be.

One way GOP lawmakers are considering teaming up with Democrats is to get them to vote present or not show up, sources say.

The source added there have even been rogue conversations between rank-and-file Democrats and Republicans about what concessions it would take for Democrats to vote present or not show.

GOP Rep. Don Bacon, a firm McCarthy supporter, told CNN he is willing to stay in these rounds of voting but “at some point” he believes Republicans should discuss with Democrats how they find a concession candidate and path forward, which could include “committee leveling.”

The House has adjourned without a speaker. Here's everything you need to know about what happened

The House still does not have a speaker and cannot move forward with any business after a historic stalemate on the first day of the 118th Congress.

The chamber has adjourned until noon ET on Wednesday. Lawmakers went through three rounds of voting, but Republican Rep. Kevin McCarthy was unable to get the majority that would win him the job.

Here’s what you need to know to catch up:

  • The candidates: Democrats have united behind caucus chair Rep. Hakeem Jeffries as the leader of the Democratic minority. The Republican side of the aisle is less united. After being chosen as the party’s candidate in closed-door meetings ahead of the vote, McCarthy was nominated in all three ballot rounds. But there is opposition. Rep. Andy Biggs was nominated in the first round and Rep. Jim Jordan was nominated in the second and third rounds, even though Jordan says he’s not interested in the role.
  • Opposition to McCarthy: The major opposition is coming in the form of a handful of conservative lawmakers, many of whom are members of the House Freedom Caucus. They don’t trust McCarthy to hold President Biden or the Democrats accountable. They have refused any concessions McCarthy has offered in the weeks leading up to the first day of Congress. During the first vote, 19 lawmakers voted for someone other than McCarthy, 19 voted for Jordan during the second ballot and 20 voted for Jordan during the third ballot.

Here’s how the votes played out:

  • More to come: Throughout the day, McCarthy said he is not backing down. A senior GOP source summed up his mentality as “never backing down.” After McCarthy made concession after concession to the right flank, he is done negotiating— now his strategy is to grind down his opponents by staying in the race for as many ballots as it takes, the source added. “We stay in until we win,” McCarthy said.
  • If not McCarthy then who? The longer the fight drags on, the more uncertainty over whether he can win. The contentious, drawn-out fight threatens to deepen divides among House Republicans with McCarthy’s political career on the line. Meantime, hardliners say they were not backing off their opposition — and, in fact, expect the opposition to grow.
  • How voting works: Since McCarthy did not get the 218 votes needed to win a majority, the House keeps voting until someone wins the majority. They voted three times Tuesday and then decided to adjourn until noon on Wednesday. The House does not kick off the new Congress until a speaker is elected. However, McCarthy can win with less than 218 votes. If enough people skip or vote “present,” this would drop the threshold for a majority.
  • Once-in-a-century fight: This is the first time in 100 years the House speaker was not elected on the first ballot. But, since it’s such a rare occurrence, there’s not much of a playbook. In the most recent occurrence, the vote in 1923 was decided on the ninth ballot. Before that, the 1869 speaker vote lasted through 60 ballots over the course of two months.

Dive deeper into the House speaker election here.

Jim Jordan says he will not become speaker of the House

US Rep. Jim Jordan speaks to the media after the third vote Tuesday.

Rep. Jim Jordan said Tuesday there is no chance he will become speaker of the House.

He told CNN he wants to be House Judiciary chairman, adding that he would lobby his colleagues to back GOP Leader Kevin McCarthy.

In a speech nominating McCarthy before the second round of voting, Jordan said he believed McCarthy was the right guy for the job and encouraged Republicans to “rally around him.”

But hardliners said they were not backing off their opposition — and, in fact, expect the opposition to grow.

“We are done with Kevin McCarthy,” said Rep. Bob Good, with Rep. Matt Gaetz echoing similar thoughts.

The House adjourned Tuesday after McCarthy failed to secure enough votes after three rounds of voting on the speakership.

In the third round, there were 202 votes for McCarthy and 20 votes for Jordan with Rep. Byron Donalds joining the 19 GOP lawmakers who had voted against McCarthy in the first two rounds.

These are the 20 Republicans who voted against McCarthy on the third ballot

Twenty GOP lawmakers voted against Rep. Kevin McCarthy in the third round of voting for speaker.

Rep. Byron Donalds joined the 19 GOP lawmakers who voted against McCarthy in the first two rounds. 

Rep. Jim Jordan has said he does not want the job and nominated McCarthy in the second round. 

These are the 20 lawmakers:

  1. Rep. Andy Biggs
  2. Rep. Dan Bishop
  3. Rep. Lauren Boebert
  4. Rep. Josh Brecheen
  5. Rep. Michael Cloud
  6. Rep. Andrew Clyde
  7. Rep. Eli Crane
  8. Rep. Byron Donalds
  9. Rep. Matt Gaetz
  10. Rep. Bob Good
  11. Rep. Paul Gosar
  12. Rep. Andy Harris
  13. Rep. Anna Paulina Luna
  14. Rep. Mary Miller
  15. Ralph Norman
  16. Rep. Andy Ogles
  17. Rep. Scott Perry
  18. Rep. Matt Rosendale
  19. Rep. Chip Roy
  20. Rep. Keith Self

Abby Phillip: A better rules package may need to be introduced to move votes for speakership

With the House adjourning for the day without selecting a speaker, Republicans and Rep. Kevin McCarthy have a lot of things to consider, CNN’s Abby Phillip and Dana Bash said.

Bash noted how while Republican members such as Rep. Chip Roy, who has been more vocal about specific asks that may sway their vote toward a specific speaker nominee, others have been more vague and performative.

If the asks and goals were more clear, maybe the vote would have been more clear-cut, Bash said.

Phillip highlighted how McCarthy’s initial package of rules changes catered to those who were a hard “no” against him — and that now that the House has adjourned a new rule package for a broader group may be more helpful to move votes for McCarthy or a new nominee altogether.

If members would have more specific conversations, there might be room for compromise, either over McCarthy or a new nominee, she said.

“It’s still a tall hill to climb, not just for McCarthy, but for a compromise figure who we still have not identified,” Phillip added.

NOW: House adjourns after McCarthy fails to secure enough votes in third ballot for House speaker 

House GOP Leader Kevin McCarthy failed to lock down the votes needed for speaker again as the House has concluded voting for a third round.

GOP Rep. Tom Cole called for the House to adjourn until noon Wednesday following the vote. Most Democrats supported the motion to adjourn, so the House stands adjourned.

The final vote was 212 votes for Democratic Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, 202 votes for McCarthy and 20 votes for GOP Rep. Jim Jordan.

Twenty GOP lawmakers voted against McCarthy in the third round of voting for speaker with Rep. Byron Donalds joining the 19 GOP lawmakers who voted against McCarthy in the first two rounds. 

Jordan has said he does not want the job and nominated McCarthy in the second round. 

Here’s a look at the third-vote tally:

Republican lawmaker who flipped his vote says McCarthy failed to close the deal

US Rep. Byron Donalds, center, talks with fellow Republicans on Tuesday.

Republican Rep. Byron Donalds — the one Republican who flipped his vote from Rep. Kevin McCarthy to Rep. Jim Jordan during the third ballot — told CNN that the House needed to adjourn so that GOP members could hash out their differences internally.

He said McCarthy failed to “close the deal.”

The House has adjourned until noon Wednesday.

Rep. Paul Gosar asked Ocasio-Cortez if Democrats were planning to help lower the threshold for McCarthy

US Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez speaks to Reps. Matt Gaetz, bottom, and Paul Gosar, right, on Tuesday.

GOP Rep. Paul Gosar, who has voted against Kevin McCarthy three times, was seen at one point on the floor speaking Tuesday with Democratic Rep. Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez. 

Ocasio-Cortez spokesperson Lauren Hitt told CNN that Gosar was asking Ocasio-Cortez if any Democrats were planning to leave the floor or vote present so McCarthy could have a lower threshold, something that hardliners against McCarthy do not want.

Ocasio-Cortez, according to Hitt, told Gosar that there was no plan to do that. 

The image of seeing the two next to each other is striking: The House voted to censure Gosar and remove him from committees in November 2021 after Gosar photoshopped an anime video to social media showing him appearing to kill Ocasio-Cortez and attacking President Joe Biden.

The interaction shows how far the “Never Kevin” lawmakers against McCarthy are willing to go to stop him.

Discussions underway about possible motion to adjourn, sources say

US Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick, a Republican from Pennsylvania., yawns after the third round of votes Tuesday.

With the votes dragging on and no resolution to the speaker standoff in sight, there are discussions underway about an alternative, sources said.

There’s talk among House GOP Leader Kevin McCarthy opponents of making a motion to adjourn, multiple sources said.

But that would take 218 votes, which means it would take help from Democrats. 

Democrats are undecided but actively discussing how to proceed, sources said.

They previously said they wouldn’t help McCarthy but this is not what McCarthy is pushing for.  

Rep. Jim Jordan was nominated for speaker by conservative hardliners during second and third ballots

US Rep. Jim Jordan speaks on behalf of Kevin McCarthy on Tuesday.

Conservative hardliners nominated Rep. Jim Jordan of Ohio on Tuesday to be speaker of the House during the chamber’s second and third votes amid the floor fight for House leadership.

Jordan, in an effort to show party unity, nominated GOP leader Kevin McCarthy in the second round of voting. Speaking on the House floor Tuesday, Jordan said the differences among Republican lawmakers “pale in comparison” to the differences between Republicans and Democrats.

“We need to rally around him,” Jordan said of McCarthy.

Rep. Matt Gaetz of Florida nominated Jordan in the second round where he earned 19 votes. Republican Rep. Chip Roy of Texas, who already voted twice against McCarthy, nominated Jordan for speaker in the third round.

Jordan’s nomination by another member marks a new layer of leadership drama as Republicans take control of the House.

The first order of House business as the 118th Congress convenes is the selection of a new speaker, but McCarthy is being stonewalled by a group of conservative hardliners. Because the GOP holds only a narrow majority, those hardliners hold more influence in the conference and have already denied McCarthy the votes necessary to secure the gavel on initial rounds of balloting.

Key things to know about Jordan: Jordan is a high-ranking conservative and a founding member of the conservative House Freedom Caucus, serving as its first chair from 2015 to 2017, and as its vice chair since 2017. He was the ranking member of the House Oversight Committee from 2019 to 2020. He vacated that position to become the ranking member of the House Judiciary Committee, where he is expected to become chairman in the newly GOP-held House.

Jordan is a close ally of former President Donald Trump. After Joe Biden won the 2020 presidential election and Trump refused to concede while making claims of election fraud, Jordan supported lawsuits to invalidate the election results and voted not to certify the Electoral College results.

Warning sign for McCarthy: Conservative supporter says he believes he will eventually lose more backing

A warning sign for Kevin McCarthy – conservative supporter Rep. Ken Buck says he believes the House GOP leader will eventually lose more backing if the voting drags out.

Buck, a member of the House Freedom Caucus, believes more Republicans will defect from McCarthy. He does not expect those who oppose McCarthy to be won over. 

This is key because Buck has been talking to the hard-liners but he doesn’t see them to be moving.

Asked if he himself could defect from McCarthy, Buck said, “I think eventually you have to.”

“The only thing that could change is Democrats walking away and not voting and then the denominator changes,” Buck said. “Otherwise Republicans are gonna have to start moving around.”

During the third round of voting, Rep. Byron Donalds switched his vote from McCarthy to Rep. Jim Jordan.

Rep. Chip Roy nominates Jim Jordan for third ballot

Rep. Chip Roy nominates Rep. Jim Jordan for House speaker on Tuesday.

Republican Rep. Chip Roy, who has twice voted against Kevin McCarthy on Tuesday, nominated GOP Rep. Jim Jordan for House speaker. 

A third vote for House speaker is underway now.

“Jim has said that he does not want the nomination,” Roy said, but added that Jordan has a track record that he likes.  

“This is not personal,” Roy said. “This is about the future of this country.”

“I don’t want any more empty promises,” Roy added.

READ MORE

McCarthy faces make-or-break moment in vote to elect House speaker
For freshman members of Congress, January 3 feels a bit like first day of school
Why the right has already won the House speakership election
What you need to know about the House speaker election
Kevin McCarthy’s problem: historically unpopular with a historically small majority
Inside McCarthy’s struggle to lock down the House speakership
McCarthy commits to key concession in call with frustrated lawmakers but it’s no guarantee he’ll win speakership

READ MORE

McCarthy faces make-or-break moment in vote to elect House speaker
For freshman members of Congress, January 3 feels a bit like first day of school
Why the right has already won the House speakership election
What you need to know about the House speaker election
Kevin McCarthy’s problem: historically unpopular with a historically small majority
Inside McCarthy’s struggle to lock down the House speakership
McCarthy commits to key concession in call with frustrated lawmakers but it’s no guarantee he’ll win speakership