Biden and Xi meet in San Francisco Bay area | CNN Politics

Biden meets with China’s President Xi

US President Joe Biden (R) and China's President Xi Jinping (L) shake hands as they meet on the sidelines of the G20 Summit in Nusa Dua on the Indonesian resort island of Bali on November 14, 2022.
Watch: Biden delivers remarks after his meeting with China's President Xi
- Source: CNN

What we covered here

  • The US and China have agreed to restore high-level military communication and take steps to curb fentanyl production following a meeting Wednesday between President Joe Biden and President Xi Jinping.
  • Biden touted the resumption of military communication during a rare news conference, saying, “We’re back to direct, open, clear, direct communications.”
  • Biden characterized the talks with Xi as “some of the most constructive and productive discussions we’ve had.” But he also doubled down on previous comments that he believes the Chinese president is a dictator.
  • Chinese state media said Xi called on the United States to “not scheme to suppress or contain China.” He also urged the US to stop arming Taiwan and support China’s “peaceful reunification,” state media said.
  • The meeting appeared to accomplish Biden’s initial goal of steadying the relationship between the two nations. But the US president summed up his approach as, “Trust, but verify.”

Our live coverage has ended. Follow the latest news or read through the updates below.

32 Posts

Biden raised human rights concerns in Xinjiang and Tibet during talks with Xi, White House says

President Joe Biden raised concerns of China’s “human rights abuses” in Xinjiang, Tibet and Hong Kong during his nearly four-hour-long talks with Chinese President Xi Jinping on Wednesday, according to the White House’s readout of the meeting.

Biden described the meeting as “some of the most productive” talks. In a rare news conference following the summit, the president touted the resumption of military-to-military communications and shared that the two leaders agreed on curbing the flow of fentanyl.

However, Biden said he also raised the issue of detained Americans in China and reiterated US policy on Taiwan. At the news conference, Biden also doubled down on his previous comments and called Xi a dictator.

Biden accuses Hamas of “war crime” for operating what US and Israel claim is command node at Gaza hospital

US President Joe Biden accused Hamas of committing a “war crime” for operating what the US and Israel have claimed is a command node under the Al-Shifa hospital in Gaza.

Biden said he discussed the dangerous situation at the hospital, Gaza’s largest, during his meeting with China’s leader Xi Jinping on Wednesday.

Some context: Israeli forces launched a raid early Wednesday morning on Al-Shifa, after accusing Hamas of operating from tunnels beneath the vast complex – a claim denied by the militant group and hospital officials.

CNN cannot verify either side’s claims.

Israel said its troops found “military equipment used by Hamas,” the military said in a statement but offered no evidence yet of a vast tunnel network it claimed was used by the militant group.

Israel said it will present more evidence to support their claims of a Hamas command center, an adviser to the prime minister told CNN Wednesday.

Conditions at Al-Shifa, which has run out of fuel and is no longer considered operational, have deteriorated rapidly in recent days amid intense fighting, with doctors warning of a “catastrophic” situation for patients, staff and displaced people still inside.

Wednesday’s raid has also sparked widespread international criticism.

Biden noted that the US has called on Israel to be “incredibly careful” as it targets Hamas in the area, but suggested that action was justified.

“We discussed the need for them to be incredibly careful. You have a circumstance where you know there is a fair number of Hamas terrorists. Hamas has already said publicly that they plan on attacking Israel again, like they did before.”

The president also noted the savagery of Hamas’ October 7 attacks in Israel. “And so, the idea that they’re going to just stop and not do anything is not realistic,” he added.

Israeli forces, he suggested, are “bringing in incubators” and “other means to help the people in the hospital,” adding that there have been efforts to get doctors, nurses, and other personnel out of harm’s way.

Evidence: In a follow-up exchange with CNN, Biden told MJ Lee, “Yes,” he was absolutely confident based on intelligence he’d seen that Hamas was operating a command center under the Al-Shifa hospital, but declined to share details on the evidence.

“No, I can’t tell you—I won’t tell you,” he told CNN.

Biden says Xi is a "dictator" hours after summit

US President Joe Biden looks on as he holds a press conference about his meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping before the start of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Woodside, California, on November 15.

President Joe Biden doubled down on his previous comments and called Chinese President Xi Jinping a “dictator” just hours after the two leader met for a summit, which he described as “some of the most productive” talks.

Asked by CNN’s MJ Lee if the president would still describe Xi as a dictator as he has in the past, Biden said:”Well look, he is.”

Biden previously compared Xi to dictators during a June political fundraiser in California as he discussed Xi’s reaction to US fighter jets shooting down a Chinese balloon in February.

Biden says talks with Xi were "some of the most productive" between the 2 leaders

US President Joe Biden greets Chinese President Xi Jinping before a meeting during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Leaders' week in Woodside, California, on November 15.

US President Joe Biden reflected on the state of his relationship with China’s President Xi Jinping following what he described as a constructive and productive meeting. 

He said the talks with Xi were “some of the most constructive and productive discussions we’ve had.”

“We haven’t always agreed,” Biden said, but his talks with Xi are always “straightforward.”

Pressed on whether he trusts Xi, Biden said, “Trust but verify, as the old saying goes. That’s where I am,” describing the relationship between the US and China as “competitive.”

Biden cultivated a deep relationship with Xi during their time as vice presidents that has since deteriorated. Still, he cast Xi as “straight.”

“I know the man, I know his modus operandi, looked into his eyes – we have disagreements. He has a different view than I have on a lot of things, but he’s been straight. I don’t mean that good, better, indifferent, just straight,” he said. 

Biden said the leaders agreed to be willing to pick up the phone if either wants to talk going forward.

Biden says the two leaders agreed on curbing the flow of fentanyl, restoring military communication and working together on artificial intelligence during their four-hour summit. 

Biden said the agreement from China to reduce precursor chemicals for fentanyl would “save lives” and said he appreciated Xi’s commitment on the issue.

Biden says he reiterated US position on Taiwan during meeting with Xi

President Joe Biden said Wednesday evening that he reiterated US “One China” policy during talks with the Chinese President Xi Jinping earlier in the day.

Under Washington’s longstanding “One China” policy, the US acknowledges China’s position that Taiwan is part of China, but has never officially recognized Beijing’s claim to the island.

CNN’s Eric Cheung and Nectar Gan contributed to this post.

Biden raised human rights, detained US citizens during meeting with Xi

President Joe Biden raised areas of concerns about China’s actions as they relate to detained US citizens, human rights and “coercive activities in the South China Sea” with Chinese President Xi Jinping.

Biden said he provided Xi with the names of those thought to be detained during their meeting Wednesday in California.

Biden touts resumption of military-to-military communication with China

US President Joe Biden walks to attend a press conference about his meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping before the start of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Woodside, California, on November 15.

President Joe Biden on Wednesday evening touted that his meeting with Chinese leader Xi Jinping resulted in the resumption of communication between the US and Chinese militaries.

The two countries have gradually been restoring communications after Beijing cut those ties in August 2022, following a visit from then-House Speaker Nancy Pelosi to Taiwan.

NOW: Biden is speaking at a news conference

US President Joe Biden is speaking at a solo news conference in California following his meeting with China’s President Xi Jinping.

Xi calls on US not to “suppress or contain” China, Chinese state media reports

Chinese President Xi Jinping speaks during a meeting with US President Joe Biden, not pictured, during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Leaders' week in Woodside, California, on November 15.

Chinese leader Xi Jinping called on the United States to “not scheme to suppress or contain China” during extensive talks with President Joe Biden near San Francisco on Wednesday, Chinese state media reported.

The two leaders “emphasized the need for mutual respect, peaceful coexistence, maintaining communication and conflict prevention,” according to Xinhua.

The meeting marked a significant step forward for the two powers, which have gradually been restoring communications after Beijing cut those ties in August 2022, following a visit from then-House Speaker Nancy Pelosi to Taiwan.

The two countries agreed to resume high-level military communication and cooperate on anti-drug crackdown, as well as resume meetings between their defense ministries and maritime military security consultations, and start talks between leaders of theatre commands, Xinhua said.

Xi urges US to show real commitment in not supporting “Taiwan independence”

Chinese leader Xi Jinping told US President Joe Biden the United States should “take real actions to honor its commitment of not supporting ‘Taiwan Independence’,” Chinese state media reported.

In the two leaders’ meeting, Xi urged the US to stop arming Taiwan and support China’s “peaceful reunification,” according to a readout released by Chinese state news agency Xinhua.

The Chinese leader also noted that the Taiwan issue has always been “the most important and sensitive issue” in US-China relations, according to Xinhua.

Xi’s remarks on Taiwan come as the self-ruled island is gearing up for a key presidential election in January, where tensions with China are set to be a top item on the campaign agenda.

China’s ruling Communist Party claims Taiwan as its territory, despite never having controlled the island of 23 million people. Xi has vowed to never renounce the use of force to “reunify” with Taiwan.

Biden and Xi discussed Middle East and Taiwan, US official says

US President Joe Biden and Chinese President Xi Jinping attend a bilateral meeting at Filoli estate on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit, in Woodside, California, on November 15.

President Joe Biden did most of the talking as Chinese President Xi Jinping mostly listened in their conversation about the Middle East, a senior US official said.

Biden encouraged Xi to use China’s leverage with Iran to warn against a wider escalation. In the talks, Foreign Minister Wang Yi said they’d already held discussions with the Iranians on the topic.

It remained unclear to Biden’s aides afterward how seriously Iran was taking China’s messages.

Biden made clear to Xi during the talks that he viewed Hamas as separate from the Palestinians.

The men had a “substantial” exchange on Taiwan and Xi made clear that concerns over the island were the biggest and most dangerous issue in US-China relations.

Xi said China’s preference was for peaceful reunification and laid out conditions under which use of force would be utilized. Biden responded by reiterating the US position was to maintain peace and stability in the region.

“President Xi responded, ‘Look, peace is all well and good, but at some point we need to move towards resolution more generally,’” the official said.

In the meeting, the US asked China to respect Taiwan’s electoral process in the lead-up to a vote in January.

Despite continuing US concerns about China’s massive military buildup around Taiwan, officials emerged from the meeting believing Xi was not preparing for a massive invasion.

Over the course of the meeting, Xi “revealed quite clearly a deep knowledge of some of the debates about China in the United States and I think in some respects, he’s quite sensitive to come of those discussions.”

Biden-Xi talks included "very direct" exchanges on technology, economy and nuclear issues, US official says

US President Joe Biden and Chinese leader Xi Jinping’s summit talks in California were “very direct” and included more back-and-forth discussion between the two men than their meeting a year ago, a senior US official said.

Biden was “very direct” with Xi on a number of topics, the official said, while Xi also raised his concerns about rhetoric inside the United States about China.

At one point, Xi told Biden he believed there was unfair negative publicity about the Chinese Communist Party in the United States.

In one exchange about restrictions the US has applied on technology exports to China, Xi likened the steps to “technological containment.” Biden responded by saying the US was not going to provide technology to China that could be used militarily against it.

Biden also raised direct concerns to Xi about harassment of American businesses in China, the official said.

The two men discussed artificial intelligence and agreed to work together moving ahead on the new technology. 

And Biden told Xi it was important for China to be more transparent on nuclear issues, as it rapidly expands its arsenal.

Biden did not “pull any punches,” the official said, noting Xi experiences little pushback within the Chinese system.

Biden was “respectful” but “clear.”

The moments of tension, however, were interspersed with some levity. When Biden wished Xi’s wife a happy birthday (which happens to fall on the same day as Biden’s birthday next week), Xi said he’d been working so hard he’d forgotten.

He thanked Biden for reminding him. 

Biden and Xi agreed to steps on fentanyl and restoring military communication in talks, official says

US President Joe Biden greets Chinese President Xi Jinping before a meeting during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Leaders' week in Woodside, California on November 15.

President Joe Biden and Chinese President Xi Jinping agreed to take steps to curb fentanyl production and restore military communication during their summit Wednesday, a senior US official told CNN.

Biden also made clear China should lean on Iran to avoid steps that would aggravate the tense situation in the Middle East. The leaders also stressed that they wanted to stabilize their countries’ relationship after months of heightened tension.

The results, which were expected ahead of the talks, amount to progress in improving the still-tense US-China relationship but they stopped short of a joint statement or other declaration of cooperation.

The senior US official said China agreed to go after companies who produce precursor chemicals to fentanyl, the powerful narcotic that has fueled a drug crisis in the United States. The US will watch closely to see if China follows up on the commitments made in the summit.

Xi also agreed to mechanisms that would address potential military miscalculations and agreed to forums for the two sides to present their concerns.

Senior administration officials said leading up to Wednesday’s summit that their Chinese counterparts had been “reluctant” over the past few months to agree to re-establishing military-to-military communications.

But it was an issue that Biden himself – and his top advisers like Secretary of State Antony Blinken, national security adviser Jake Sullivan and Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin – raised in “nearly every conversation we’ve had with the Chinese,” as the US tried to underscore that it was “absolutely critical” that this channel be re-opened.

US officials said that the Chinese spy balloon incident, in particular, underscored the importance of military-to-military communications.

China and US to resume high-level military communication and cooperate on drug crackdown, state media says

Chinese leader Xi Jinping and US President Joe Biden agreed to resume high-level military communication and cooperate on anti-drug crackdown following their hours-long summit, Chinese state media reported.

The leaders agreed to “resume high-level communication between the two militaries on the basis of equality and respect,” according to a readout released by China’s state agency Xinhua. The two sides will also resume meetings between their defense ministries and maritime military security consultations and start talks between leaders of theatre commands.

The two sides also agreed to establish an anti-drug working group to carry out anti-drug cooperation, as well as an intergovernmental dialogue on artificial intelligence, Xinhua reported.

The two leaders also pledge to further increase flights early next year and expand exchanges in education, international students, and the culture, sports and business sectors, according to Xinhua.

Biden-Xi summit has concluded

US President Joe Biden’s summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping has concluded, the White House said.

The two presidents began their meeting just after 2 p.m. ET. Following opening remarks, several sessions and a working lunch, the two leaders closed out with a walk around the historic estate south of San Francisco.

Biden told reporters during the walk that the talks were going “well,” and added on social media that “real progress” was made.

Biden is expected to hold a solo press conference in the 7 p.m. ET hour.

Biden says "real progress" made in meeting with Xi

US President Joe Biden said on social media he has made “real progress” in his talks with Chinese leader Xi Jinping.

Biden and Xi have been meeting for hours at a historic estate south of San Francisco.

 Biden takes a walk with Xi, says talks are going "well"

US President Joe Biden and Chinese President Xi Jinping walk together after a meeting during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Leaders' week in Woodside, California, on November 15.

US President Joe Biden and Chinese President Xi Jinping took a walk following their working lunch on Wednesday.

The men walked very slowly side-by-side down a brick walkway, each wearing their suit jackets. 

They did not have a translator with them and did not appear in heavy conversation, aside from Biden pointing out something in the trees.

Biden waved with both hands to reporters. When asked how talks were going, he made a thumbs-up sign and said: “Well.”

Biden is expected to hold a solo press conference once the summit has concluded. The two presidents began their meeting just after 2 p.m. ET.

By the numbers: Biden's news conferences

President Joe Biden’s news conference Wednesday in the Bay Area will mark the president’s 32nd news conference since taking office, according to CNN’s analysis. 

It is rare for Biden to hold a solo news conference: This marks his 14th solo news conference since taking office, and the third solo news conference of 2023. He has held 18 joint news conferences alongside another world leader. 

The average length of Biden’s solo news conferences is 38 minutes – the longest was 111 minutes and shortest was 16 minutes.

Former President Donald Trump, by contrast, held 88 news conferences overall during his presidency, and at the same point in his presidency, he had held 54 news conferences, per an analysis of University of California-Santa Barbara data. Former President Barack Obama held 163 news conferences and had held 63 at this point in his presidency. And former President George W. Bush held 210 news conferences during his presidency, and 62 at this point in his presidency. 

Recent presidents who had held fewer news conferences at this point include former President Ronald Reagan, at 20, and former President Richard Nixon, at 22. 

Here's what Biden and Xi are eating for lunch

President Joe Biden is now participating in working lunch with Chinese President Xi Jinping following the first session of their summit, which lasted nearly two hours.

The two leaders are joined by US Secretary of State Antony Blinken and national security adviser Jake Sullivan, along with two Chinese officials, according to the White House.

The White House also shared the lunch menu, which includes:

  • Herbed Ricotta Ravioli
  • Artichoke Crisps
  • Tarragon roasted Heritage Chicken
  • Carolina Gold Rice Pilaf
  • Charred Broccolini + Brussels Sprouts
  • Almond Meringue Cake
  • Praline Buttercream
  • Concord Grape Sauce

First session of Biden-Xi summit ends

President Joe Biden and Chinese President Xi Jinping attend a bilateral meeting at Filoli estate on the sidelines of the APEC summit, in Woodside, California, on November 15.

The first session of the summit between US President Joe Biden and Chinese President Xi Jinping ended after a little more than two hours.

The leaders still have two more closed-press sessions before the summit concludes.