December 5, 2023 Israel-Hamas war | CNN

December 5, 2023 Israel-Hamas war

split erin and idf spox
CNN presses IDF spokesperson on the ratio of civilian casualties. Hear his response
01:33 - Source: CNN

What we covered here

  • Top UN officials are warning of an “apocalyptic” situation in war-torn Gaza with “no place safe to go” for civilians, as Israel’s war with Hamas spreads to the south, where many had previously sought refuge.
  • Israel’s military said its troops are “in the heart of” Khan Younis in southern Gaza and have “completed the encirclement” of the Jabalya refugee camp in the northern part of the enclave.
  • Tens of thousands of internally displaced Palestinians have arrived in Gaza’s southernmost governorate of Rafah over the past two days, the UN’s humanitarian agency said Tuesday, as it warned of overcrowding and the spread of disease. Currently, almost 1.9 million people, more than 80% of Gaza’s population, have now been displaced, another UN agency said.
  • Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Tuesday the IDF should retain control for the disarmament of Gaza after the war, rejecting the idea that an international force could be responsible for security in the Gaza Strip. 
  • Here’s how to help humanitarian efforts in Israel and Gaza.
50 Posts

More than 60% of homes in Gaza have been destroyed. Here's what you should know

Palestinians inspect the damage to a home following an air strike on Monday, December 4.

Since October 7, 61% of homes and residential units in Gaza have been destroyed, according to the Hamas government in the enclave.

Of the 305,000 affected units, 52,000 are completely destroyed and 253,000 are partially damaged, an official from the Hamas government media office said in a news conference from Gaza on Tuesday. 

Here are other headlines you should know:

  • Developments on the ground: The Israel Defense Forces said Tuesday that its troops are “in the heart of Khan Younis” and that troops are encircling the city located in southern Gaza. Video and witness accounts indicate there have been multiple strikes in the area of Deir al-Balah in central Gaza Tuesday as well, with many casualties being taken to the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Hospital. Also, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Tuesday that the IDF should retain control for the disarmament of Gaza after the war, rejecting the idea that an international force could be responsible for security in the Gaza Strip. And US officials expect the current phase of Israel’s ground operation of Gaza targeting the southern end of the strip to last several weeks before Israel transitions, possibly by January, to a lower-intensity, hyper-localized strategy that narrowly targets specific Hamas militants and leaders, multiple senior administration officials tell CNN.
  • Hostages: Israeli’s public broadcaster, Channel 11, obtained audio from a private meeting between former hostages and Israel’s security cabinet. In the audio, former hostages detailed the trying conditions of their captivity. Also, some Israeli hostages were given anti-anxiety medication prior to their release, an official from Israel’s health ministry told the Knesset, or parliament, on Tuesday.
  • Developments out of Lebanon: Lebanon’s caretaker prime minister wants to spare his country “from any major war that might occur” as the conflict between Israel and Hamas is leading to the fear of rising regional tensions. Meanwhile, a Lebanese soldier was killed and three others were wounded in an Israeli attack on Tuesday, the Lebanese army said on social media.
  • Humanitarian aid and support: Fifty trucks carrying humanitarian aid entered Gaza through the Rafah crossing Tuesday, including two trucks specifically carrying fuel, according to an Egyptian official. Additionally, the US military airlifted another 36,000 pounds of critical supplies to Gazans on Tuesday, Pentagon spokesperson Brig. Gen. Pat Ryder said Tuesday. Meanwhile, power has been returning gradually to Gaza following Monday’s blackout, according to PalTel, the only remaining major telecommunications operator in the strip. Also, Israel’s prime minister said his country’s war efforts in Gaza are supported by its humanitarian effort. Netanyahu said Israel is allowing in the “bare minimum” of fuel trucks and also is aiming to prevent disease outbreaks in the enclave that could halt the ground operation. Elsewhere, the Norwegian Refugee Council has been forced to halt nearly all aid operations in Gaza “due to the bombardment, the chaos and the panic,” said its secretary general, Jan Egeland. And Mary Robinson, former United Nations high commissioner for human rights and chair of The Elders group, has urged the US to reconsider its military aid to Israel, calling for restraint from “those who have power.”
  • International involvement: US President Joe Biden’s administration has begun to stress publicly that the United States’ efforts to shape Israel’s military operations to be more surgical and deliberate to limit civilian casualties in Gaza have been fruitful. FBI Director Christopher Wray said the bureau is working “around the clock” to pinpoint and stymie potential attacks by individuals inspired by the October 7 Hamas attacks on Israel. Additionally, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken announced a new policy on Tuesday to prevent extremist Israeli settlers responsible for violence in the West Bank from coming to the United States. And, during a trip to Egypt Tuesday, US Aid Administrator Samantha Power announced the US will provide an additional $21 million in aid to Gaza.

UN rejects idea of acceptable ratios for Gaza's civilian deaths after Israeli military's comments 

Jonathan Conricus poses for a picture in the military base of Har Dov on Mount Hermon, between Israel, Lebanon and Syria on October 30, 2019. 

The United Nations has described the remark by an Israel Defense Forces spokesperson to evaluate civilian deaths in Gaza in “ratios” as “tasteless”.

On Monday, Jonathan Conricus, IDF spokesperson, told CNN that a ratio of two Palestinian civilians killed in Gaza for every Hamas militant is a “tremendously positive ratio” given the challenges of urban combat. 

The UN’s focus is on avoiding any civilian deaths, Dujarric said, during an exchange at his daily press briefing on Tuesday — though he acknowledged this has not been successful in Gaza.

Almost 16,000 people have been killed in Gaza since October 7, according to figures compiled by the Hamas-controlled health ministry in Gaza

Israel's assessment on civilian-Hamas militant fatality ratio is "dead wrong," US Rep. Seth Moulton says

Moulton appears on CNN on Tuesday, December 5.

US Rep. Seth Moulton told CNN’s Erin Burnett he disagrees with Israel Defense Forces (IDF) spokesperson Jonathan Conricus’ assessment that two civilians killed for every Hamas militant is a “tremendously positive” ratio. 

“No I think it’s dead wrong,” Moulton said.

Moulton, a member of the House Armed Services Committee who served in Iraq, cited a study commissioned by retired Army Gen. Stanley McChrystal, which said for every civilian killed, about 10 terrorists are recruited. 

The congressman added that in a poll conducted just before October 7, six out of 10 Gaza residents indicated that they did not support Hamas. 

“Israel was actually going into a favorable situation where most of the Palestinians were against Hamas as well. The concern is they’ve actually turned most of the Palestinians against Israel,” Moulton said. 

Chair of The Elders group urges US to reconsider its military assistance to Israel

Mary Robinson attends a news conference on June 29.

Mary Robinson, former United Nations high commissioner for human rights and chair of The Elders group, has urged the US to reconsider its military aid to Israel, calling for restraint from “those who have power.”

Robinson spoke to CNN’s Isa Soares in the wake of a statement released by The Elders, describing Israel’s response to the October 7 attacks as “disproportionate” and the “level of inhumanity” it is carrying out in Gaza as “intolerable.” 

The Elders, founded by Nelson Mandela, is a grouping of mostly former world leaders “working for peace, justice, human rights and a sustainable planet,” according to the group’s website.

Since 2016, the US has provided $3.8 billion annually in military assistance to Israel as part of a 10-year Memorandum of Understanding between the two countries.

Robinson highlighted that ordinary Palestinian civilians who are “getting caught up” and killed in the conflict in Gaza are “not Hamas terrorists.”

“The UN is urging, the UN High Commission here in Geneva is urging, we are all urging restraint. But words aren’t enough. And those who have power to restrain must now restrain,” Robinson said. “And that in particular is the United States.”

Robinson urged the US to exercise this restraint by publicly voicing its disapproval that its “military arsenal is being used this way” in Gaza. “It hasn’t said that explicitly. It should,” Robinson added.

This post has been updated with additional information.

Israel revoked visa of UN humanitarian coordinator, minister of foreign affairs says

Lynn Hastings, United Nations humanitarian affairs coordinator, is seen at a news conference in Gaza on January 31.

Israel has revoked the visa of the United Nations humanitarian coordinator due to the “bias of the UN,” according to the Israeli minister of foreign affairs.

“We will no longer be silent in the face of the bias of the UN,” Israeli Foreign Minister Eli Cohen said in a post on X, the platform formerly known as Twitter.

Cohen said Lynn Hastings, who is the deputy special coordinator for the Middle East peace process and the UN resident coordinator for the Occupied Palestinian Territory, failed to speak out against Hamas for the acts committed during its October 7 attack.

Stephane Dujarric, spokesperson for the UN secretary general, said Hasting had her visa revoked last week. Still, Dujarric said the UN secretary general has “full confidence” in Hastings. 

“I can only reiterate the Secretary-General’s full confidence in Ms. Hastings, the way she’s conducted herself, and the way she’s done her work,” Dujarric said.

IDF concedes it struck Lebanese soldiers while targeting Hezbollah in "self defense"

The Israel Defense Forces admitted Tuesday that it struck Lebanese soldiers while acting in “self defense” against Hezbollah, the IDF said on social media. 

The IDF claimed it “operated in self defense” against what they said was an imminent threat coming from Lebanon. The threat came from near the southern Lebanese village of Odaisseh in the Marjayoun district, where the IDF says a Hezbollah launch area and observation point exists.

According to the Lebanese Armed Forces, one soldier was killed and three more were injured. 

The IDF said they were notified after the strike that soldiers from the Lebanese Armed Forces had been harmed. 

The IDF added that the incident is under review.

It is believed to be the first fatality of the Lebanese Armed Forces since the escalation of the conflict this year. 

Netanyahu says war efforts are supported by humanitarian efforts — but aid groups say it's not enough

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks during a news conference on Tuesday, December 5.

Israel’s prime minister said his country’s war efforts in Gaza are supported by its humanitarian effort. Benjamin Netanyahu said Israel is allowing in the “bare minimum” of fuel trucks and also is aiming to prevent disease outbreaks in the enclave that could halt the ground operation.

Answering a question about Israel potentially losing leverage against Hamas if it allows more humanitarian aid into Gaza, Netanyahu said: “The war efforts are supported by the humanitarian effort … this is because we follow laws of war because we know that if there would be a collapse — diseases, pandemics, and groundwater infections — it will stop the fighting.”

Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant said Tuesday that Israel has “the right to demand certain things” concerning humanitarian aid, including allowing the Red Cross to visit Israeli hostages who remain in Gaza “or at least allow the transfer of some related elements such as medicines” to the hostages.

Meanwhile, international aid organizations have argued that the amount of aid reaching Gaza is insufficient. 

Lynn Hastings, United Nations humanitarian coordinator, said on Monday that a “more hellish scenario is about to unfold” if more aid is not allowed to enter Gaza.

Mirjana Spoljaric Egger, the president of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), said during a visit to Gaza on Monday that “an unimpeded and regular flow of aid must be allowed to enter Gaza.” 

Current phase of Israel's ground operation of Gaza could end by January, US officials say

An Israeli artillery unit operates at the border with Gaza on Tuesday, December 5.

US officials expect the current phase of Israel’s ground operation of Gaza targeting the southern end of the strip to last several weeks before Israel transitions, possibly by January, to a lower-intensity, hyper-localized strategy that narrowly targets specific Hamas militants and leaders, multiple senior administration officials tell CNN.

But as the war enters this new ground, the White House is deeply concerned about how Israel’s operations will unfold over the next several weeks, a senior US administration official said.

The US has warned Israel firmly in “hard” and “direct” conversations, they said, that the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) cannot replicate the kind of devastating tactics it used in the north and must do more to limit civilian casualties.

The US has conveyed to Israel that as global opinion has increasingly turned against its ground operation, which has killed thousands of civilians, the amount of time Israel has to continue the operation in its current form and still maintain meaningful international support is quickly waning.

In perhaps the most direct public warning to date, Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin admonished Israel that it can “only win in urban warfare by protecting civilians.”

Devastating death toll: Almost 16,000 Palestinians have been killed since Israel began its campaign in October, following Hamas’ terror attack on Israel on October 7, according to the Hamas-run Gaza Ministry of Health. Israel believes it has killed “several thousand” Hamas militants, an Israeli official said.

Though senior Biden administration officials have publicly called on Israel to do more to minimize civilian deaths, they have been careful to avoid directly admonishing any of Israel’s tactics, believing officials believe it is more effective to quietly counsel Israel behind the scenes rather than loudly shame them.

The senior administration official told CNN that they did not feel comfortable using the word “receptive” to capture Israel’s response so far to the administration’s military advice —contrary to some public statements from senior-most members of the administration.

Both in public and in private, Israeli officials maintain that part of their end goal is to weaken Hamas to such an extent that the group can never repeat the attack that it unleashed on Israel on October 7.

That goal, one senior US official told CNN, is unlikely to be achieved by the end of the calendar year, and Israel is expected to continue pursuing that objective in the next phase of the conflict that US officials see as a “longer-term campaign.”

Read more about the US view of Israel’s ground operation of Gaza.

More than 60% of Gaza houses damaged since October 7, Hamas government says

Palestinians inspect the destruction caused by air strikes on their homes in Khan Yunis in Gaza on Monday, December 4.

Since October 7, 61% of homes and residential units in Gaza have been destroyed, according to the Hamas government in the enclave.

Of the 305,000 affected units, 52,000 are completely destroyed and 253,000 are partially damaged, an official from the Hamas government media office said in a news conference from Gaza on Tuesday. 

Hamas claimed that 121 government buildings and 69 schools are completely out of service, and 275 schools were partially damaged. 

Hamas demanded the immediate introduction of 1,000 trucks of daily aid and one million liters of fuel to rebuild the health care sector, especially hospitals and other vital facilities.

Israeli health ministry official says some hostages were given anti-anxiety medication prior to release

Some Israelis held hostage by Hamas in Gaza were given anti-anxiety medication prior to their release, an official from Israel’s health ministry told the Knesset, or parliament, on Tuesday.

Clonex is the name in Israel for Clonazepam, a benzodiazepine that has a calming effect, and is used to treat seizures and relieve anxiety.

Mizrahi did not provide evidence for the claim.

IDF should retain control for disarmament of Gaza after war, Netanyahu says

Netanyahu speaks during a press conference on Tuesday, December 5.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Tuesday that the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) should retain control for the disarmament of Gaza after the war, rejecting the idea that an international force could be responsible for security in the Gaza Strip. 

It’s not the first time Netanyahu has called for post-war Israeli military control in Gaza.

In November, Netanyahu told CNN that Israel’s security role in a post-war Gaza would be an “over-riding, over-reaching military envelope,” but did not explain what that meant.

Biden decries reported sexual assaults by Hamas and says acts must be forcefully condemned

US President Joe Biden on Tuesday decried reported sexual assaults committed by Hamas during its attack on Israel, calling on “all of us” to condemn the acts.

Speaking at a fundraiser in Boston, Biden accused Hamas of refusing to release additional women hostages and ending the pause in fighting that the US helped broker.

“Let me be crystal clear: Hamas’ refusal to release the remaining young women is what broke this deal and end the pause in the fighting. Everyone still being held hostage by Hamas need to be returned to their families immediately. We’re not going to stop,” he said.

More context: Hamas has denied that its militants committed rape during the October 7 attack. The group’s statement also rejected that Hamas targeted festival-goers at the Nova music festival. At least 260 bodies were recovered from the festival site, according to Israeli rescue service ZAKA.

Israeli police are investigating whether rape occurred during the attack, using forensic evidence, video and witness testimony, CNN first reported in November. Israel’s police acknowledge their investigation may take months.

US military airlifts 36,000 pounds of supplies to Gaza, Pentagon says

The US military airlifted another 36,000 pounds of critical supplies to Gazans on Tuesday, Pentagon spokesperson Brig. Gen. Pat Ryder said on Tuesday.

He said that as with previous airlifts, “the supplies were delivered via a US Air Force C-17 to Egypt to subsequently be transported via ground into Gaza and then distributed by UN agencies.” 

Ryder added that additional flights are expected “in the coming days.”

More than 100 people were released by Hamas during truce. Here's what we know about them

An 8-year-old soccer fan who enjoys playing video games. Young-adult siblings dancing away at a desert music festival. A 67-year-old agricultural expert and her relatives enjoying a family gathering.

These were a few of the 105 people who were released by Hamas during a temporary truce with Israel, which started on November 24 and ended early December 1.

Under the terms of the agreement, which was finalized after weeks of tense negotiations, Israel released three imprisoned Palestinians for every Israeli hostage allowed to leave Gaza. The framework saw 80 Israelis, some of whom hold dual citizenships, released from captivity. By the end of the pause in hostilities, 240 Palestinians had been freed from Israeli prisons, mainly women and minors, and many of whom had been detained but never charged.

Additionally, a number of foreign nationals — 23 Thai citizens, one Filipino and one dual Israeli-Russian citizen — were freed as part of separate negotiations outside the truce.

The temporary agreement, accompanied by an uptick in desperately needed humanitarian aid entering the besieged enclave, represented the first major diplomatic breakthrough in the conflict.

Click here to learn more about each hostage who has returned from Gaza so far.

US State department calls on Israel to allow more humanitarian assistance into Gaza

The Israeli government needs to allow more humanitarian assistance into Gaza, US State Department spokesperson Matt Miller said Tuesday.

He noted that the number of trucks with humanitarian aid entering Gaza is lower than it was before the pause, and that needs to increase.

Fifty trucks carrying humanitarian aid entered Gaza through the Rafah crossing Tuesday, including two trucks specifically carrying fuel, according to an Egyptian official. Before the October 7 attack, about 455 aid trucks were crossing into the area each day, according to the United Nations. 

“We are engaging with the government of Israel at every level to try to increase the amount of humanitarian assistance that is getting in, so people do have food and people do have water,” Miller said.

As the Israel-Hamas war enters its ninth week, signs are emerging of social order breaking down, with reports of looting by people struggling to survive.

Miller also said that the US is working with the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNWRA) “to try to identify sites where civilians can go to be safe from harm and working with the government of Israel to ensure that those sites are protected and are not targeted.”

Video and eyewitness accounts indicate multiple strikes in Deir al-Balah in central Gaza

Video and witness accounts indicate there have been multiple strikes in the area of Deir al-Balah in central Gaza on Tuesday, with many casualties being taken to the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Hospital.

Dozens of videos CNN commissioned from a freelance journalist on the ground in Deir al-Balah show men digging through rubble in the aftermath of a strike, which destroyed a large, multi-story building. 

In one video, a blanket appears to be covering a dead body as people at the scene prepare to move the body. In another video, men are seen searching for someone trapped under the concrete, and one man says he can hear a voice inside the rubble.

The spokesperson of Al-Aqsa Martyrs Hospital, Dr. Khalil Al Daqran, told CNN that more than 90 bodies arrived at the medical facility on Tuesday, in addition to 130 people who were injured. He said more casualties are arriving.

“Al Aqsa Martyrs Hospital is the only hospital in the central area and cannot accommodate such a large number of people, especially considering that massacres against our people are still ongoing,” he said.

One video received by CNN from a freelance journalist showed a stream of ambulances and private cars arriving at the medical facility, and several injured children being carried in. One dazed woman covered in dust is also helped into the hospital.

Many of those carried into the hospital appeared to have severe injuries, with some lying on the hospital floor as medics treated them.

Another video filmed in Deir al-Balah shows a Palestine Red Crescent Society ambulance fleeing the scene of nearby artillery fire, according to the aid agency.   

The PRCS shared the video, which was filmed by a local journalist in Gaza, alongside the caption: “Horrific scenes for Israeli tank artillery targets the vicinity of two PRCS ambulances today while attending to casualties in Deir Al-Balah, South of #Gaza.”

CNN geolocated the video to the southern part of the city. 

The video shows people running into the ambulance as blasts are heard nearby, as one person says, “The bombing is directly on us.” Through the window of the ambulance, a large plume of smoke can be seen rising in the distance. 

CNN has reached out to the IDF for comment. 

Al Daqran also called for more medical supplies to enter the enclave and for “Egypt to open Rafah (border crossing) to transfer the critically ill cases in Gaza and save their lives, especially due to the lack of medical aid in Gaza.”

On Tuesday, seven injured Palestinians, along with seven accompanying individuals, crossed into Egypt to receive medical treatment, as observed by a journalist working with CNN at the Rafah crossing.

Lebanon's prime minister says he is working to spare his country from "any major war"

Prime Minister Najib Mikati arrives to address the the UN General Assembly in New York in September.

Lebanon’s caretaker prime minister wants to spare his country “from any major war that might occur” as the conflict between Israel and Hamas is leading to the fear of rising regional tensions.

Prime Minister Najib Mikati said he is working with international partners, including the United States and the United Nations, to ensure Lebanon doesn’t get wrapped up in “any war that we do not know where it will lead.”

Mikati said that Lebanon continues to support the Palestinian cause and he stressed that any guarantees to avoid a wider war fall on Israel.

The Lebanese official also said negotiations will take place “in the coming months” to solve the ongoing border disputes with Israel with the support of the US, Europe and the UN.

“This issue takes a fundamental role with the aim of sparing Lebanon from any war that we do not know where it will lead. We hope that in the next three months we will reach a stage of complete stability on our borders,” Mikati said.

Some background: Israel and Hezbollah, Lebanon’s powerful militant group, have been exchanging frequent fire across the border for two months, using rockets, artillery, drones and airstrikes. 

A Lebanese soldier was killed and three others were wounded in an Israeli attack on Tuesday, the Lebanese army said on social media. It appears to be the first death of a Lebanese soldier since the two groups have been exchanging fire.

The Israeli Defense Forces said fighter jets struck Hezbollah targets in Lebanon, including infrastructure and weapons storage military posts on Tuesday morning, adding it identified several launches from Lebanon into Israel that fell into open areas. 

Israeli military spokesperson seeks to clarify comments made on civilian casualties in Gaza

The Israel Defense Forces spokesperson who on Monday told CNN that killing two Palestinian civilians for every Hamas militant in Gaza would be a “tremendously positive ratio” on Tuesday said that the IDF had not confirmed that those numbers were accurate. 

Jonathan Conricus, the spokesperson, said that he had only meant to say that he had seen a news report attributing those numbers to an unnamed Israeli official. “I confirmed that I saw the report. I didn’t confirm the numbers yet,” he told CNN on Tuesday.

AFP, citing a briefing for foreign media by senior Israeli military officials, reported on Monday that the Israeli military believes that about two civilians have been killed in Gaza for each Hamas militant.

AFP reported that the Israeli military official, when asked to confirm reports that around 5,000 Hamas militants had been killed, replied: “The numbers are more or less right.”

Conricus said that the IDF wants to get accurate numbers of civilians and combatants killed, adding that he thought the number would be known before the end of the war.

And he said the Israeli military was talking about active combatants when it counted how many Hamas fighters it killed: “Our definition is combatants, people who are fighting.” 

He repeated Israel’s regular assertion that the IDF was aiming to kill “as low as possible a number of civilians” and blamed Hamas for using people as human shields. 

He insisted again that a ratio of two civilians killed per combatant was better than seen in urban combat in places like Raqqa and Deir Ezzor in Syria, but added, “Every loss of life is sad, I should have chosen my words more carefully.”

US will provide $21 million in additional aid for Gaza

US Aid Administrator Samantha Power speaks to an Egyptian Red Crescent official as she arrives at the international humanitarian assistance hub in Al-Arish, Egypt, on Tuesday.

The United States will provide an additional $21 million in aid to Gaza, US Aid Administrator Samantha Power announced during a trip to Egypt Tuesday.

According to US Aid, this aid will provide:

  • Support for the provision of essential hygiene and shelter supplies, food, and market-based assistance for more than 120,000 people
  • Psychosocial care and health services for the health system in Gaza which US Aid described as “overwhelmed”
  • Support to bolster an NGO-operated field hospital in Gaza providing in-patient care

Her announcement for additional aid follows US President Joe Biden’s announcement of $100 million in humanitarian aid to Gaza on October 18.

Power visited El-Arish, Egypt, to meet with local officials and Egyptian and international humanitarian organizations, according to a US Aid press release.

At the time of her visit, the U.S. Department of Defense (DOD) airlifted 36,000 pounds of food assistance and medical supplies from Amman, Jordan, to El-Arish, at USAID’s request, the press release said.

The city of El-Arish lies roughly 28 miles from the Rafah crossing which links Egypt to Gaza.