November 22, 2023 Israel-Hamas war | CNN

November 22, 2023 Israel-Hamas war

112223 Wesley Clark vpx
Retired general on how Israel and Hamas will use the truce to their advantage
01:25 - Source: CNN

What we covered here

  • Israel and Hamas reached a deal for a four-day pause in fighting and the release of at least 50 hostages held in Gaza – but none will be freed before Friday, according to the Israel National Security Council.
  • Previously, the expectation had been that the first releases would take place as early as Thursday. The pause in fighting was also delayed until Friday, an Israeli official told CNN.
  • US officials have a working list of 10 hostages they believe are likely to be released on day one, a source familiar told CNN. It was not clear whether any of the three American hostages — including 3-year-old Abigail Edan — would be among them.
  • The head of UNICEF has called the Gaza Strip “the most dangerous place” in the world right now to be a child, saying over 100 children have died per day for weeks.
  • Here’s how to help humanitarian efforts in Israel and Gaza.
55 Posts

Hostages won't be released before Friday. Here are other headlines you should know

No hostages will be released before Friday, according to the Israel National Security Council. The start of an agreed temporary truce in fighting is also delayed until Friday, an Israeli official told CNN.

There is uncertainty over the reasons behind the delay from Gaza, with one Israeli official familiar with the matter downplaying its seriousness. They reduced the issue down to “fairly minor implementation details.”

Israel’s Supreme Court rejected a legal challenge to the Gaza hostage deal. Also, the hostage deal does not include the “release of murderers,” Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Wednesday while disclosing more details from the agreement.

Here are other headlines you should know:

  • More on the hostage situation: “Intensive” work was needed to broker the Israel-Hamas hostage deal, according to the the Qatari minister of state for foreign affairs who also served as the lead negotiator for the deal. As part of the deal, the United States and Israel will both pause drone flights over Gaza for six hours each day, Deputy National Security Adviser Jon Finer told CNN. Additionally, US officials have a working list of 10 hostages they believe are likely to be released from Gaza on day one, a source familiar told CNN.
  • Humanitarian crisis: The Gaza Strip is “the most dangerous place” in the world to be a child, according to the executive director of the United Nations Children’s Fund. Elsewhere, a total of 284 injured patients have been evacuated into Egypt since Israel launched attacks on Gaza following the October 7 Hamas attack, according to Egyptian government press office director Ayman Walash. Also, the Red Cross will be allowed to visit and offer medical support to the hostages that remain in Gaza after some of them are returned, Netanyahu said.
  • International input: The Biden administration will watch the implementation of the deal made between Israel and Hamas, National Security Council spokesperson John Kirby said on Wednesday. The Norwegian Refugee Council said it needs longer than a four-day pause in fighting between Israel and Hamas to expand aid operations in Gaza, and the lull should lead to a full ceasefire.  
  • Israel Defense Forces claims: The IDF said it found further evidence of a tunnel complex under Al-Shifa Hospital in northern Gaza. The IDF said special forces had exposed “dozens of meters of a tunnel system” that passed under another building in the hospital complex, “as well as rooms where Hamas terrorists can operate and stay for extended periods.”

White House hopeful release of hostages will begin Friday as parties work out "final logistical details"

The Biden administration is hopeful the hostage release process will begin Friday morning as the parties work out “final logistical details,” National Security Council spokesperson Adrienne Watson said in a statement Wednesday night.

A senior US official elaborated that more time was needed to iron out details related to the locations and routes of each of the hostages as well as the logistics of moving them. 

A decision was made to wait one extra day to minimize things going wrong, said the official, who added Israel made the decision together with Qatar and Egypt, and that the US was consulted on and agreed with the decision.

The official also said the fact that Israel had not yet received the names of the first group of hostages to be released was not a serious issue, but added that it would be more worrisome if there was still no list by Thursday evening. 

After the expected release of women and children hostages begins, focus will turn to other groups held in Gaza

A woman holds portraits of hostages Erez Kalderon, 12, and of children of the Goldstein Almog family as protesters rally outside the UNICEF offices in Tel Aviv, Israel, on November 20.

After the expected release of the women and children hostages held by Hamas begins, focus will turn to other groups being held in the Gaza Strip that are expected to be more difficult to negotiate their release, sources say. 

Women and children have been the first priority to get released and if that is successful, it will leave men, Israeli soldiers and the remains of those killed — either bodies taken into Gaza on October 7 or those who were killed after.

It’s believed there are 236 hostages being held in Gaza. All 50 expected to be released in the first phase are Israeli women and children, some of whom also have other nationalities besides Israeli. 

A source familiar with the negotiations said US and Israeli officials viewed elderly men as being the next category of people that could be easiest to get out of Gaza, followed by foreign national men.

Both female and male soldiers were considered the hardest to negotiate out of Gaza, the source added. In addition, the parties would also need to work toward retrieving the bodies of those killed that Hamas is believed to be holding. 

The negotiation for those categories hasn’t started in earnest yet, the source said.

As a result of the complexity for the remaining hostages, another source familiar with the discussions confirmed that the others have not been part of the immediate conversations and therefore are on something of a separate track. 

Another complicating factor in the case of many of those who would remain, the person added, is that they’re not in Hamas custody but with other groups and individuals.

Gilad Shalit meets with French Ambassador to Israel Christophe Bigot at the French embassy in Tel Aviv, Israel on January 11, 2012.

Israeli soldiers held hostage could give Hamas huge leverage in negotiations. In 2011, Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit was exchanged for more than 1,000 Palestinian prisoners after years of negotiations. 

Following mandatory Israeli military service for both men and women, most Israelis become reservists and according to a person familiar with the talks, Hamas had initially wanted to consider the women hostages under 45 years old to be as soldiers as well.

Israel refused, another source familiar with the discussions said both sides ended up agreeing that only those women in uniform when they were abducted will be considered soldiers. 

Aside from Israelis, there are kidnapped nationals from other countries, like Thailand and Nepal, whose countries have been in contact with Qatar since Qatari mediators have been a main point of contact with Hamas, a person familiar with the discussions says. 

Israel’s military released security video from Gaza’s Al Shifa hospital that they claimed showed Hamas militants bringing one Thai and one Nepali hostage to the hospital, one of them bleeding on a stretcher.

There's uncertainty over the reasons behind the hostage deal delay, officials say

People look at pictures of Hamas' hostages during a demonstration in Tel Aviv, Israel, calling for their release on November 11.

There is uncertainty over the reasons behind a delay in the release of hostages from Gaza, with one Israeli official familiar with the matter downplaying its seriousness. They reduced the issue down to “fairly minor implementation details.”

Another official told CNN part of the reason was Israel had not yet received names of the first hostages to be released by Hamas.

Israeli media is reporting that neither Israel nor Hamas have signed the hostage release agreement, though it is not clear whether this should be enough to pause the deal. 

Even so, no Israeli official has expressed concern the entire arrangement has fallen apart.

Speaking at a Wednesday evening news conference held before the delay was announced, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu expressed confidence the agreement would soon go into effect, even as he offered few details about its implementation.

Earlier, the Israel Defense Forces spokesperson had struck a note of caution over the hostage release process.

Palestinian boy hopes for a longer truce as he arrives in Egypt for treatment  

Mohamed Khaled, 13, speaks with CNN on November 22.

Mohamed Khaled, who is only 13, lost a leg in an Israeli airstrike in Gaza. Now in Egypt for treatment, Mohamed tells CNN he hopes the truce is extended and becomes permanent.   

Mohamed said he was home with his family in al-Bureij in central Gaza “when a missile went through the ceiling of their home and exploded next to him.

“The shrapnel went through my leg here and severed it. My leg was a mangle of blood, flesh and bone,” Mohamed said.

“I could see all the flesh was gone after the second knuckle. Only the bone was sticking out,” he said, pointing to his bandaged hand and the missing middle finger.

When he spoke to CNN, Mohamed and his mother, Fatma Nofal, were inside an ambulance at the Egyptian side of the Rafah border crossing waiting for their documents to be processed. 

He is due to receive treatment in Egypt before he is transferred to the United Arab Emirates to get a prosthetic leg.  

Nofal said she hopes other injured kids would also be allowed to receive treatment outside Gaza while describing the dire situation she escaped.   

“The nursing staff are doing all they can. But they are overwhelmed,” the mother said. She said she has heard stories of patients with critical injuries who are “left with their family until they die.”

White House official says Biden administration will watch "very closely" to make sure Hamas sticks to deal

The Biden administration will watch the implementation of the deal made between Israel and Hamas, National Security Council spokesperson John Kirby said on Wednesday.

Kirby said that the administration will be watching “very closely” to make sure that Hamas holds up their end of the hostage deal.

Kirby also offered some explanation into the remaining American hostages, explaining that there are 10 unaccounted-for Americans, and they are all believed to be held captive at this time.  

Three Americans would fall into the women and children category that is part of the release deal, and the US is optimistic the three “will be in at least one of the increments.”

But he continued to express some caution: “We’ll have to watch — the truth is we won’t know for sure until we start to see people moving.”

Pressed by CNN’s Bianna Golodryga on whether there is proof all of the hostages are still alive, Kirby hedged. 

“Our information is limited about all the hostages, including the remaining American hostages. So I can’t tell you definitively that we have proof of life on all of them. But I can say that we have no indication to the contrary. So we’re going to continue to work on this as hard as we can,” he said.

No hostages will be released before Friday, Israel National Security Council says

No hostages will be released before Friday, according to the Israel National Security Council. The start of an agreed temporary truce in fighting is also delayed until Friday, an Israeli official told CNN.

Previously, the expectation had been that the first releases would take place as early as Thursday. No reason was given for the apparent delay.

Israel’s cabinet approved a deal early Wednesday for the release of hostages seized by Hamas in exchange for a four-day truce in Gaza.

Netanyahu says hostage deal does not include “release of murderers” from Israel 

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu attends a press conference in Tel Aviv, Israel, on October 28. 

The hostage deal does not include the “release of murderers,” Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Wednesday while disclosing more details from the agreement.

Most Israelis have welcomed the agreement, and Netanyahu said the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and security establishments fully support the deal with Hamas.  

But there has been concern from some that perpetrators of fatal attacks on Israelis could be among the list of Palestinians set to be released from Israeli jails. 

The vast majority of the Palestinians listed as eligible for release are male teenagers aged 16 to 18 – children under the United Nations definition – although a handful are as young as 14. Some 33 are women, according to a CNN count. 

Netanyahu credited the success of the agreement to the combination of Israel’s “non-stop massive military pressure” on Hamas and “heavy” diplomatic pressure Israel had been applying to release hostages taken by the militant group.  

He said he spoke to US President Joe Biden on Wednesday and thanked him for “acting, at my request, vis-à-vis the mediators, to achieve a significant improvement in the agreement, and such an improvement was indeed achieved.” 

“I believe that this combination [of diplomatic and military efforts] will allow the release of additional hostages in the next stages,” the prime minister said. 

During the truce, the IDF will “prepare for the continuation” of the war against Hamas, Netanyahu said.  

“The war continues, and will continue until we reach all of our goals,” he said.  

Netanyahu says Red Cross will be allowed to visit hostages held in Gaza

The Red Cross will be allowed to visit and offer medical support to the hostages that remain in Gaza after some of them are returned, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said in his first public address since the Israel-Hamas hostage deal.

He read lines from the agreement saying the Red Cross will visit them. 

Qatar has yet to receive identifying information of Gaza hostages to be released, diplomatic source says

Hamas had not yet provided Qatari officials with identifying information regarding the 50 hostages intended for release, a diplomatic source familiar with the deal told CNN.

However, the source said Qatar remained confident the list would be shared tonight local time.

The diplomatic source also told CNN that the agreement struck between Israel and Hamas would see 200 trucks per day entering the coastal enclave, carrying aid and other supplies, including fuel.

Remember: The hostage deal between Hamas and Israel, as laid out by key negotiator Qatar in a statement, would see hostages held captive by Hamas released in exchange for a number of Palestinian women and children in Israeli jails. The truce, meanwhile, would also allow the entry of “a larger number of humanitarian convoys and relief aid,” the statement said.

An Israeli official told CNN Wednesday that the truce is slated to begin at 10 a.m. local time (3 a.m. ET) on Thursday.

US officials have a working list of 10 hostages that they believe are likely to be released from Gaza on day one, a source familiar told CNN.

Biden discusses hostage deal in call with emir of Qatar

President Joe Biden spoke with Emir Sheikh Tamim Bin Hamad Al-Thani of Qatar, the White House said Wednesday. Officials have pointed to the emir as a key interlocutor with Hamas during negotiations on a hostage deal. 

Biden and the emir discussed the deal as well as developments in the region, the White House said.

Biden is also Biden also spoke with Israel President Benjamin Netanyahu Wednesday afternoon US time, an administration official tells CNN.

Readouts for both calls are forthcoming.

Biden is spending the Thanksgiving holiday in Nantucket, Massachusetts, with family, but he has made a series of calls to world leaders Wednesday. 

Return of hostages is a "complicated process yet to be finalized," Israeli military spokesperson says

Israeli army spokesman Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari speaks to the press from The Kirya, which houses the Israeli Ministry of Defense, in Tel Aviv, Israel, on October 18, 2023.

Coordinating the return of hostages from Gaza is not an easy task, Israel’s military spokesperson said at a briefing Wednesday evening.

In the early hours of Wednesday morning, Israel’s cabinet approved a deal for the release of hostages seized by Hamas in exchange for a four-day pause in fighting in Gaza, which is slated to begin Thursday morning. Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails will also be released as part of the deal.

Hagari said Israel’s military is cooperating with all the relevant bodies to administer “an orderly process” to receive hostages from Hamas.

The coming days will be “filled with moment of relief and moments of pain,” he said, warning that they could also include “attempts to carry out psychological terror, aimed against us by the terror organizations.” 

He also said that the chief of the general staff of the IDF, Herzi Halevi, has approved “the war’s plans and stages for the future, and particularly the readiness for the next few days.” 

Hagari stressed that “a long fight is ahead” for the Israeli military. 

Israel’s Supreme Court rejects legal challenge to hostage deal

Israel’s Supreme Court has rejected a legal challenge to the Gaza hostage deal which includes the release of at least 150 Palestinian prisoners held in Israeli jails.

The Almagor association, which was set up in 1986 to represent victims of terror, had claimed that the government’s decision, among a series of objections, intensified the risk of “the recurrence of serious acts of terrorism to which all the citizens and residents of the country are exposed.” 

Almagor had asked the Supreme Court to “annul the government’s decision … [and] order [the government] to discuss again the terms of the deal with Hamas,” according to information released by the Court.

The Court said it rejected the petition outright on the grounds that the hostage deal “is a clear political issue to which this court does not consider its involvement as necessary.”

The ruling clears any legal objection in Israel to the execution of the deal that involves the exchange of Israeli hostages in Gaza for the release of Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails.

US has a "working list" of hostages likely to be released by Hamas, source familiar says

Families and friends of about 240 hostages held by Hamas in Gaza call for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to bring them home during a demonstration in Tel Aviv, Israel, on November 21.

US officials have a working list of 10 hostages they believe are likely to be released from Gaza on day one, a source familiar told CNN. It was not clear whether any of the three American hostages —including three-year-old Abigail Edan — would be released on the first day.

The deal is structured in such a way that each day, a group of hostages to be released would be handed off to the Red Cross; the Red Cross would then take the group to a designated border point, which will largely depend on the location of those hostages, the source familiar said.

Fifty Israel hostages — including some with dual nationalities — are expected to be released over the four-day pause. Ten is the minimum number of hostages to be released each day, but that could be higher. Many of the first 50 hostages are expected to come out through Egypt, they said. 

The first swap had been expected to take place on Thursday, a source familiar with how hostages are expected to leave Gaza told CNN. However, the Israeli National Security Council said later that the pause would be delayed and no hostages are expected to be released before Friday.

The first two days of the hostage release will be treated as a “testing period” to make sure the process is working, the source said. By day three, there is expected to be intense discussions about the potential second phase of the hostage release beyond the initial group of 50.

Brett McGurk, a White House official, told CNN Wednesday he could not speak about the schedule of when the Americans would be released. He confirmed that three US hostages – Abigail and two women — are expected to come home as part of the 50 hostages released by Hamas. A total of 10 Americans are believed to be hostages.

McGurk said he is “hopeful” that the Red Cross will get access to the other hostages, but noted, “I cannot confirm that nor guarantee that.”

Meanwhile, the Israeli Supreme Court “has now greenlit the (hostage) deal to go forward,” thus clearing the way for the process to move forward this week, McGurk said. 

Read more.

IDF says it has discovered more tunnels at Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza

The Israel Defense Forces said it found further evidence of a tunnel complex under Al-Shifa Hospital in northern Gaza.

The IDF said special forces had exposed “dozens of meters of a tunnel system” that passed under another building in the hospital complex, “as well as rooms where Hamas terrorists can operate and stay for extended periods.”

In a statement Wednesday, the IDF said “the soldiers of the 7th Brigade also located two additional tunnel shafts near the hospital: one on a nearby street and the other in a nearby house.”    

The IDF has frequently alleged that Hamas uses the hospital buildings at Al-Shifa to store weapons and as headquarters.

The IDF also released video from inside the tunnel.

CNN is unable to verify independently the extent and nature of the tunnels discovered by the IDF.

These are some of the major components of the hostage deal, according to lead Qatari negotiator

The lead Qatari negotiator of the truce agreement between Israel and Hamas outlined some operational details about the deal in an interview with CNN.

The deal has two major components, he said:

  • One “specifically focuses on civilian women and children on each side” being released over several days.
  • And the other related to “quality” humanitarian aid and assistance to people in Gaza.

“We hope that within the four days, we will be able to complete the release of women and children in both sides, moving to the safe side, away from this war,” Mohammed bin Abdulaziz Al-Khulaifi, who is also Qatar’s minister of state for foreign affairs, told CNN Wednesday.

Israel and Hamas will have to meet certain “obligations” over a four-day pause to release a certain number of people daily, Al-Khulaifi said.

Al-Khulaifi said his team would monitor the fulfillment of both parties’ obligations and would report back to them daily. 

“By the first hours of the agreements, we will be notified of the official list of people each day. And by having that list, we will make sure that we notify either the sides, the parties themselves, or even the countries that have their hostages in the Gaza Strip currently,” he said. 

Hamas had previously said it needs pauses in fighting to gather the hostages who are being held in different places and by different Hamas-allied groups in Gaza.  

Meanwhile, fulfilling the provision of “quality” humanitarian assistance to Gazans will involve regional and international stakeholders — not just Israel, Al-Khulaifi said.

Al-Khulaifi said his team had managed to secure fuel for “vital” infrastructure, like hospitals. 

Here's what we know about the Palestinian prisoners on Israel’s list for potential release

Protesters chant during a rally in Ramallah city in the occupied West Bank, in support of Gaza and of Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails, on November 14.

The hostage deal between Israel and Hamas would see the return of 150 Palestinian prisoners held in Israeli jails in exchange for the release of at least 50 women and children held in Gaza, during a four-day pause in fighting.

The Palestinian prisoners concerned are women and children, Hamas said Wednesday, adding that the agreement also involves the entry of hundreds of trucks carrying aid relief, medical supplies and fuel to all parts of the besieged territory.

Here’s what to know about these prisoners who could be potentially released:

The charges: The Israeli government on Wednesday published a list of Palestinian prisoners for possible release with their ages and charges on which they are being held – throwing stones and “harming regional security” are among the most common. Others are listed as detained for supporting illegal terror organizations, illegal weapons charges, incitement, and at least two accusations of attempted murder. Some of the people are listed as being members of Hamas and other Islamic militant groups, but many of the prisoners are not listed as belonging to any organization.

The ages: Most of the Palestinian prisoners listed as eligible for release are male teenagers aged 16 to 18 – children under the United Nations definition – although a handful are as young as 14. Some 33 are women, according to a CNN count.

What to know about Palestinian prisoners held by Israel:

  • Around 8,300 Palestinian prisoners are currently held in Israeli jails, said Qadura Fares, head of the Palestinian Commission for Detainees and Ex-Prisoners’ Affairs.
  • More than 3,000 of them are being held in what Israel calls “administrative detention,” Fares told CNN, adding that this means they are being held without knowing the charges against them, and without an ongoing legal process.
  • Most of the prisoners are men, Fares said, adding that there are also about 85 women and 350 children in detention.

Israel has stepped up its arrests since Hamas’ attacks on October 7. Up to 2,070 arrests were documented in the occupied West Bank and Jerusalem in that month alone, according to the Palestinian Prisoner’s Society, a non-governmental organization dedicated to addressing the concerns of Palestinian detainees in Israeli prisons. That figure includes 145 children and 55 women.

Palestinian Authority Prime Minister Mohammad Shtayyeh claimed to Reuters last week that Israel had been ramping up arrests ahead of a hostage deal. “Israel is preparing for an exchange of prisoners, and they are arresting as many people as they can simply because they are preparing for such a deal,” Shtayyeh said.

Wednesday’s diplomatic breakthrough offers a glimmer of hope for the families of Palestinian prisoners, as well as those of Israeli hostages.

Hamas is holding 236 hostages in Gaza, including foreign nationals from 26 countries, according to the latest figures from the Israeli military. The abductions took place on October 7, when Hamas militants launched their brutal attack on Israel, killing at least 1,200 people.

Netanyahu and members of war cabinet to hold news conference Wednesday

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and members of the war cabinet will hold a news conference at 2:15 p.m. ET (9:15 p.m. local time) Wednesday in Tel Aviv, according to the prime minister’s office. 

Defense Minister Yoav Gallant and former Defense Minister Benny Gantz, who are members of the emergency war cabinet, are expected to be among those at the conference.

Norwegian Refugee Council says a 4-day pause in fighting "not enough" to facilitate aid operations in Gaza 

Th Norwegian Refugee Council said it needs longer than a four-day pause in fighting between Israel and Hamas to expand aid operations in Gaza, and the lull should lead to a full ceasefire.  

“We will do all that we can to provide relief to those in need in Gaza during the four-day humanitarian pause,” the secretary general of the humanitarian organization, Jan Egeland, said in a statement Wednesday.   

Egeland also highlighted some of the challenges the coming winter season poses to the people in Gaza. 

“Winter is looming, and it will be a disaster to reignite this conflict. Small shelters have housed scores of people, with little food and water and mounting health hazards. Children are traumatised, and many face a future without their parents and siblings. They need urgent, long-term help. This can only happen through a sustained ceasefire,” Egeland said in the statement.

Egeland added that “neither hostages nor access to humanitarian relief should ever become bargaining chips in political or military negotiations.”