November 21, 2023 Israel-Hamas war | CNN

November 21, 2023 Israel-Hamas war

hostage family vpx
Family member of hostage reacts to hostage release deal
01:00 - Source: CNN

What we covered here

  • Israel’s cabinet has approved a deal for the release of hostages seized by Hamas in exchange for a pause in fighting in Gaza.
  • The agreement would see the release of at least 50 hostages – women and children – in exchange for a 4-day truce in Israel’s air and ground campaign, according to a government statement. And it held out the potential for an extension, saying that an extra day would be added for each additional 10 hostages available for release. 
  • 150 Palestinian prisoners will be released from Israeli jails as part of the agreement, Hamas said in a statement.
  • Meanwhile, almost 1.7 million people have been displaced in Gaza since October 7, a UN agency said. And up to 50% of the buildings in northern Gaza and Gaza governorates have been damaged, according to an analysis of radar satellite data.
  • Here’s how to help humanitarian efforts in Israel and Gaza.
59 Posts

Israeli president calls hostage deal "painful" but backs Netanyahu's decision

Israeli President Isaac Herzog called the hostage deal struck with Hamas “painful and difficult,” in the first public comments by an Israeli leader since the agreement was announced early Wednesday.

“The difficulties are understandable,” he said in a translated post on X (formerly Twitter), but added he backed Netanyahu’s decision.

Meanwhile, a senior Israeli official told CNN the hostage release deal would be implemented after a 24-hour window to lodge an appeal with the Supreme Court has elapsed.

CNN reported earlier that it would be 24 hours before the start time of the truce would be announced.

The deal: The agreement would see the release of at least 50 hostages in Gaza — women and children — in exchange for a four-day pause in Israel’s air and ground assault on the enclave, according to the Israeli government.

It will also include the entry of aid and fuel, and the release of 150 Palestinian prisoners — women and children — held in Israeli jails, according to a Hamas statement.

Qatar urges international community to seize the "brief window of opportunity" for diplomacy

Mohammed Al-Khulaifi attends a meeting at the government palace in Beirut, Lebanon, on April 3.

Qatar’s lead negotiator said the hostage release agreement he helped broker between Israel and Hamas should prompt the international community to “seize this brief window of opportunity to generate further momentum for the diplomatic track.” 

Such a move was only way to solve the conflict, both in the short term and the long term, said Mohammed Al-Khulaifi, Minister of State at Qatar’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, in a statement. 

The deal: The agreement was reached after weeks of negotiations between Israel, Hamas and the United States, mediated by Qatar.

The deal would see the release of at least 50 hostages in Gaza — women and children — in exchange for a four-day pause in Israel’s air and ground assault on the enclave, according to the Israeli government.

It will also include the entry of aid and fuel, and the release of 150 Palestinian prisoners — women and children — held in Israeli jails, according to a Hamas statement.

Hamas pulled down its earlier statement, with a diplomatic source close to the talks telling CNN it was because the arrangement had been that Qatar would be first to announce the successful mediation.

“Today’s deal should bring home additional American hostages," Biden says

President Joe Biden speaks during a meeting in Washington on November 21.

US President Joe Biden issued a statement Tuesday night, after Israel, Hamas and Qatar announced an agreement that would see the release of some hostages held in Gaza.

Israeli military working out details for pause in fighting, spokesperson says

Lt. Col. Jonathan Conricus poses for a picture in the military base of Har Dov on Mount Hermon, a strategic and fortified outpost at the crossroads between Israel, Lebanon and Syria on October 30, 2019. 

The Israeli military is still working out details for the pause in fighting included in the hostage release deal, Israel Defense Forces (IDF) spokesperson Lt. Col. Jonathan Conricus told CNN’s Pamela Brown. 

Conricus said the exact timing of the pause remains to be determined. 

Conricus said he fears Hamas will use the pause in fighting to resupply and regroup.

“Of course we would rather continue to apply pressure on Hamas,” he said, “But this pause is for a very important cause.” 

“I can assure that we will be respectful of any agreement, that we will honor the commitments made by the Israeli government,” he added.

What the deal entails: The agreement would see the release of at least 50 hostages in Gaza — women and children — in exchange for a four-day pause in Israel’s air and ground assault on the enclave, according to the Israeli government.

While the exact names of the hostages to be released has yet to be publicized, Conricus said they are all Israelis, though some have dual nationalities. 

The deal will also include the release of 150 Palestinian prisoners — women and children — held in Israeli jails, according to a Hamas statement. It would also allow the entry of hundreds of trucks carrying aid relief, medical supplies and fuel to Gaza.

Conricus said the details of how the exchange will play out are also still being worked out. 

Qatar releases statement on hostage deal and "humanitarian pause"

Qatar, which played a key mediation role in negotiations between Israel and Hamas, has issued its own statement announcing what it called “an agreement for a humanitarian pause.”

In line with earlier announcements from both Hamas and the Israeli government, the statement from Qatar’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs said the pause in fighting would last four days, with the possibility of being extended longer.

It said the start of the pause would be announced within 24 hours.

What’s in the deal: The statement confirmed the deal sees the release of 50 civilian women and children currently held in Gaza, in exchange for Palestinian women and children detained in Israeli prisons. 

The statement did not put a number on how many Palestinians would be released, but appeared to indicate the number would increase the longer the truce agreement is in place.

It also said the pause will allow for a “larger number of humanitarian convoys and relief aid including fuel designated for humanitarian needs.” 

Israel has been highly reluctant to allow fuel into Gaza since October 7, and only agreed at the weekend to allow minimal deliveries to power sewage facilities and water supply systems.

The statement said Qatar was committed “to ongoing diplomatic efforts to de-escalate tensions, stop the bloodshed, and protect civilians,” and paid tribute to Egypt and the United States for helping get the deal over the line.

Family of 3-year-old American hostage hopes she will be released by her birthday on Friday

Abigail Edan, 3, is the youngest American hostage.

Families of American hostages in Gaza are still waiting to find out if their loved ones will be released as part of the deal that has been secured.

Among them are the relatives of 3-year-old Abigail Edanthe youngest American hostage, whose parents were killed by Hamas.

Her great aunt, Liz Hirsh Naftali, described the wait as excruciating.

Liz Hirsh Naftali, Abigail's aunt, speaks with CNN on Tuesday, November 21.

“For our family, we have spent the last seven weeks … worrying, wondering, praying, hoping,” she told CNN Tuesday night.

Abigail has a 6-year-old sister and 10-year-old brother, who both saw their parents being murdered during brutal October 7 Hamas attacks on Israel, Naftali said. The two younger siblings hid in a closet for 14 hours, she said. 

The family is holding on to hope that Abigail will be one of the first to be released. 

Israeli cabinet met for 6 hours before approving hostage deal, official says

The Israeli cabinet meeting to discuss the hostage release deal lasted about six hours – and topics ranged from the morality of the proposed deal to its battlefield implications, an Israeli official told CNN’s Jeremy Diamond.

Another government official, Gal Hirsch, told CNN that far-right Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, who had previously voiced concerns about the deal, ended up supporting it.

Only two people voted against the agreement, including far-right National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir.

Hirsch, who acts as a hostage coordinator for Israel, said he had told the hostages’ families early Wednesday the government “will do everything to bring all the hostages back home.”

The timeline for the first hostages to cross into Israel was still unclear, he added.

What the deal entails: The agreement would see the release of at least 50 hostages in Gaza, women and children, in exchange for a four-day pause in Israel’s air and ground assault on the enclave, according to the Israeli government.

The deal will also include the release of 150 Palestinian prisoners — women and children — held in Israeli jails, according to a Hamas statement. It would also allow the entry of hundreds of trucks carrying aid relief, medical supplies and fuel to Gaza.

Inside the painstaking negotiations between Israel, Hamas, the US and Qatar to free 50 hostages

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu grabbed Brett McGurk’s arm as he walked out of a tense meeting of the Israeli Cabinet over securing the release of hostages Hamas was holding in Gaza.

Earlier that day, Netanyahu and President Joe Biden had agreed over the phone that they were ready to accept the broad contours of a deal for Hamas to release 50 women and children who were being held hostage.

A major breakthrough had come two days earlier on November 12. Hamas – after refusing for days – had relented in offering identifying information about several dozen hostages, such as their age, gender and nationalities. The information confirmed that numerous children and toddlers had been taken captive on October 7.

Even though Israel and the US believed there were more than 50 women and children hostages, both sides agreed that they needed to move ahead with securing the release of those 50 – and hope that the deal might incentivize Hamas to release more after the initial group.

But hours after McGurk’s meeting with Netanyahu, everything went dark.

Read the full breakdown of how the hostage deal was reached.

150 Palestinian prisoners will be released from Israeli jails as part of hostage deal, Hamas says

One hundred and fifty Palestinian prisoners held in Israeli jails will be released as part of a deal reached with Israel over hostages held in Gaza, according to a Hamas statement early Wednesday.

The prisoners are women and children, the statement said.

Hamas confirmed the deal, brokered by Qatari and Egyptian mediation, which will see the release of 50 hostages, also women and children, held in Gaza since October 7. It also said the agreement involves the entry of hundreds of trucks carrying aid relief, medical supplies and fuel to all parts of Gaza.

Israel Defense Forces (IDF) spokesperson Lt. Col. Jonathan Conricus said the full list of relevant prisoners has yet to be released, but unlike the last hostage deal, this group does not include anyone who was involved in the October 7 attacks. 

“The mastermind behind many of the horrible things that are unfolding since October 7th, was indeed released in the latest hostage deal,” Conricus told CNN. “What I know is that the Palestinians that are being freed from prisons are not at all that caliber of terrorists that we were talking about before, not serious offenders.”

Conricus suggested the list of prisoners included in the deal will be released soon, following a short window for appeals. 

3 Americans could be part of hostage release of 50 women and children, officials say

Three Americans could be part of the agreement securing the release of 50 women and children held hostage in Gaza, senior US officials said.

Ten Americans remain unaccounted for, including two women and one 3-year-old girl, according to a senior administration official.

“We’re determined to get everybody home,” a senior administration official said when pressed by CNN’s MJ Lee on the remaining unaccounted for Americans.

Implementation will begin “about 24 hours” after a deal is announced by Qatar, the official said. They added there are “various locations where the hostages will be brought out,” which was part of the negotiations.

What’s next: After their safe passage, the released hostages will receive medical attention in Israel, National Security Council spokesman John Kirby told reporters earlier Tuesday, suggesting that some could have longer-term medical needs following six weeks in “abhorrent conditions.”

There will then be efforts to repatriate citizens to their home countries and connect them with their families. 

For any American citizens released, Kirby said, after medical care is prioritized, the US State Department will provide consular assistance.

It's unclear when the pause in fighting will begin, diplomatic source says

Though Israel’s cabinet early Wednesday approved an agreement for the release of 50 hostages held in Gaza in exchange for a four-day truce in fighting, the “details on when the pause starts are still unclear,” a diplomatic source familiar with the talks told CNN.

The Israeli government statement confirming the deal held out the potential for the truce to extend beyond the four-day period, in exchange for more hostages released.

Israel says 4-day truce in Gaza could be extended if more hostages are released

The Israeli government held out the potential for a truce to extend beyond the original four-day period, saying in a statement that an extra day would be added to the truce for each 10 additional hostages available for release.

The statement also made clear that Israel plans to resume its air and ground campaign “to complete the eradication of Hamas” once this round of hostage releases concludes.

Israel’s cabinet approved a deal that would see the release of some hostages from Gaza on Tuesday in exchange for a four-day truce in Israel’s air and ground campaign in the enclave. The deal was approved by a significant majority of the cabinet, a government source told CNN.

Granddaughter of a hostage says news of deal gives her "so much hope"

Anat Moshe Shoshany, whose grandmother was kidnapped from kibbutz Nir-Oz on the back of a moped, said hearing that the Israeli cabinet approved a deal for the release of some hostages held by Hamas gave her “so much hope.”

She added: “We’re fighting this fight for a very long time. It’s going to be the 47th day tomorrow. So we learn to be patient and be calm about it as much as we can. Because we can’t stand to fill all our hopes up and to disappoint – but I really do hope to see someone walking out of there. I think it will fill us with hope for others.”

Asked whether she had received any information regarding her grandmother’s well-being or whether her grandmother would be part of an initial hostage release, Shoshany said she didn’t have any confirmed information.

Some context: Israel’s cabinet approved a deal early Wednesday that would see the release of at least 50 hostages — women and children — held in Gaza by Hamas, in exchange for a four-day truce in Israel’s air and ground campaign in the enclave, according to a government statement.

Israel’s cabinet votes to approve deal to release at least 50 hostages in exchange for 4-day truce

Israel’s cabinet has approved a deal that would see the release of at least 50 hostages — women and children — held in Gaza by Hamas, in exchange for a four-day truce in Israel’s air and ground campaign in the enclave, according to an Israeli government statement.

The statement held out the potential for the truce to extend beyond the original four-day period, saying that an extra day would be added to the truce for each 10 additional hostages available for release.

The statement also made clear that Israel plans to resume its air and ground campaign “to complete the eradication of Hamas” once this round of hostage releases concludes.

The statement made no mention of the release of Palestinian prisoners held in Israeli jails, though it is understood this is also a key part of the deal. Earlier reports Tuesday suggested about 150 Palestinian prisoners — also predominantly women and children — would be released.

The deal was approved by the Israeli cabinet by a significant majority, a government source told CNN. 

A more detailed statement will be sent to families of the hostages later today, the statement read.

This post was updated with additional details from the Israeli government statement.

Israel’s cabinet votes to approve hostage release deal

Family and friends of Israelis being held in Gaza at a demonstration in Tel Aviv, Israel on November 21.

Israel’s cabinet has approved a deal that would see the release of some hostages from Gaza.

The deal was approved by a significant majority of the cabinet, a government source told CNN.

Israeli cabinet meeting in hostage deal has ended, source says

A meeting between Israeli cabinet members on a potential hostage deal has ended, according to an Israeli government source. There is no word on a result of the vote yet.

Qatar hopes to announce a hostage deal today. Here's what you should know

Qatar is hoping to announce a deal as soon as Tuesday to release several civilian hostages taken by Hamas in the October 7 attack in exchange for a pause in fighting, a diplomatic source and another source familiar with the talks told CNN. Qatar delivered a proposal early Tuesday morning following weeks of continuous negotiations, according to Majid Al-Ansari, Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokesperson.

US President Joe Biden confirmed Tuesday that efforts to retrieve the hostages are “now very close” following extensive negotiations over the past six weeks. The White House offered a broad overview of what will happen to the released hostages on Tuesday.

Here are other headlines you should know:

  • More on the hostage situation: A US official expressed optimism that a deal was achievable, saying “this is the closest we’ve been.” Two far-right Israeli parties that are members of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s coalition government —the Religious Zionism Party and Jewish Power party — suggested Tuesday that they would not support the hostage deal being considered by the government. Both Israel and Hamas are still working on the names of those who could be released in an exchange of hostages in Gaza, two Israeli sources told CNN Tuesday. They are expected to be mostly children as well as Israeli citizens and dual nationals, sources told CNN. The families of the hostages remain largely in the dark as negotiations continue. A source familiar with the negotiations said there is hope that with a potential hostage deal, they will be able to get significantly more aid into the Gaza Strip, working toward a goal of 400 trucks a day. The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) claims its ground operations in Gaza “create better conditions” for a potential return of hostages.” Although a hostage deal may be reached, Netanyahu said the war will continue. Also Tuesday, Palestinian poet Mosab Abu Toha has been released after questioning, according to the IDF.
  • Calls for ceasefire: The United Nations has called for an immediate ceasefire in Israel-Hamas war but said it would welcome a pause in fighting for the organization to be able to get more aid into Gaza, according to to UN relief chief Martin Griffiths. Additionally, the Chinese President also reiterated calls for an immediate ceasefire again of all parties in the Israel-Hamas conflict and for the release of detained civilians.
  • Humanitarian crisis: In its latest update on the humanitarian situation in Gaza, the main UN agency in the Gaza Strip said that almost 1.7 million people have been displaced since October 7. The UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East said that 930,000 internally displaced people were sheltering in its premises across Gaza as of November 19. The shelters are already severely overcrowded and have no more room for new arrivals, it said. And up to 50% of the buildings in northern Gaza and Gaza governorates have been damaged in the war since October 7, according to an analysis of radar satellite data, called SAR, carried out by researchers at the City University of New York Graduate Center and Oregon State University.  
  • More strikes: Wounded men, women and children were taken to hospitals in Gaza after Israeli airstrikes on the Jabalya area in northern Gaza, Reuters videos shot on Tuesday show. The IDF said early Tuesday that the Israeli Air Force was “preparing the battlefield” by focusing on “terror targets” in Jabalya. Also, two heavy explosions sent up large plumes of smoke in northern Gaza early Tuesday evening. The explosions shook windows and doorframes of a CNN position in Sderot, across from the border with Gaza.

US attorney general says Justice Department investigating deaths of Americans

US Attorney General Merrick Garland said the Justice Department is investigating the deaths of Americans who have died in the war between Hamas and Israel. 

“We always investigate deaths of Americans,” Garland said during a news conference Tuesday. “We are actively investigating the deaths of Americans using all the tools available to us.”

Dozens of Americans have died since the start of the war, including those who were killed by Hamas during the October 7 attack as well as Americans who served in the Israeli security forces. 

State Department spokesperson Matt Miller said Monday that 800 American citizens, legal permanent residents and family members have now left Gaza, while over a thousand remain. 

Garland also said the Justice Department is investigating connections Hamas has in the US, especially financial support coming from individuals inside the states.

US secretary of defense speaks with his Israel counterpart, Pentagon says

U.S. Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin testifies at a Senate Appropriations Committee hearing on Capitol Hill October 31, 2023, in Washington, DC.

US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin spoke again with his Israeli counterpart Defense Minister Yoav Gallant on Tuesday, the Pentagon said Tuesday. 

The two discussed Israel’s operations against Hamas as well as the “criticality of increasing and sustaining humanitarian aid and protecting civilians in Gaza,” according to the statement.

Austin also emphasized to Gallant the US’ support for Israel and “the importance of preventing regional escalation,” it said.