March 2, 2024 - Israel-Hamas war | CNN

March 2, 2024 - Israel-Hamas war

video thumbnail nima humanitarian aid investigation
CNN saw what's inside aid packs destined for Gaza, and investigates why they're not reaching civilians
05:41 - Source: CNN

What we covered

28 Posts

Our live coverage of Israel’s war against Hamas in Gaza has moved here.

A cargo ship has sunk in the Red Sea days after being attacked by Houthi rebels

A cargo ship struck last month by a ballistic missile fired by Yemen’s Houthi rebels has sunk in the Red Sea, the US Central Command said Saturday.

The sinking of the Rubymar, which was carrying 21,000 metric tons of fertilizer, presents an environmental risk in the Red Sea, according to US Central Command.

The M/V Rubymar, a Belize-flagged, UK-owned bulk carrier, had been slowly taking on water since February 18, when it was struck by one of two ballistic missiles fired from Houthi territory in Yemen.

Days later, it created an 18-mile long oil slick in the Red Sea.

The damage sustained by the Rubymar is potentially the most significant to a vessel caused by an attack launched by the Iran-backed Houthis, who have been targeting commercial shipping in the Red Sea for months.

The attacks on one of the world’s most important shipping routes have upended global trade and stoked fears of a wider regional conflict months into the Israel-Hamas war.

Meeting between Canada's Trudeau and Italy's Meloni canceled due to pro-Palestinian protests

A reception in Toronto where Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau was scheduled to host his Italian counterpart Giorgia Meloni was canceled on Saturday after hundreds of pro-Palestinian protesters blocked entrances to the event.

“Trudeau was scheduled to host the event for Giorgia Meloni, but doors were locked when hundreds of pro-Palestinian protesters arrived and called for an end to what they called the ‘siege in Palestine,’” according to a Canadian press gallery pool report. 

Meloni is visiting Canada in Italy’s role as the rotating president of the Group of Seven nations after visiting Washington on Friday.

Earlier in the day, Meloni and Trudeau agreed to enhance cooperation in priority areas, including energy security and the shift to a sustainable energy future, as well as artificial intelligence.

UN Security Council expresses 'deep concern' over deadly Gaza aid convoy incident

People at Al-Shifa hospital in Gaza City mourn over the body of a Palestinian killed in an incident when Israeli forces opened fire on crowds rushing at an aid distribution point on February 29.

The United Nations Security Council has expressed “deep concern” over a devastating incident that killed more than 100 Palestinians seeking aid on Thursday in northern Gaza, while acknowledging that an Israeli investigation is underway.

“The council members take note that an Israeli investigation is underway,” it added.

On Thursday, the day of the incident, Security Council members were unable to agree on a statement because of US objections.

The statement released Saturday said members of the Security Council “reiterate their demand for parties to the conflict to allow, facilitate, and enable the immediate, rapid, safe, sustained and unhindered delivery of humanitarian assistance at scale to the Palestinian civilian population throughout the Gaza Strip.”

The carnage: At least 118 people were killed and 760 injured Thursday when Israeli troops open fired on Palestinian civilians who were gathering around food aid trucks, according to the Palestinian Health Ministry in Gaza.

CNN is unable to independently confirm these numbers.

Israel’s military has denied that account, saying it fired warning shots to disperse a crowd.

On Friday, a spokesperson for the UN Secretary General, citing a UN team that visited the hospital where survivors were taken, said many of the injured civilians had suffered gunshot wounds.

“From what they saw, in terms of the patients alive and getting treatment is that there is a large number of gunshot wounds,” Stéphane Dujarric said.

Following the incident, UN Secretary-General António Guterres said an effective independent investigation was required.

US says more aid drops are coming to Gaza as ceasefire-hostage negotiations continue. Catch up here

After the first successful US airdrop of aid into Gaza on Saturday, the Defense Department is planning on conducting additional drops in the days ahead, according to a White House official. 

At the same time, a senior official in US President Joe Biden’s administration said Israel has “basically accepted” a six-week ceasefire proposal in Gaza, and it is now waiting on Hamas.

Find out more about today’s biggest headlines:

  • US airdrops aid into Gaza: After the US airdropped aid into Gaza — in a joint operation with Jordan — White House officials said they have seen Palestinian civilians distribute the tens of thousands of meals among themselves. Biden said Saturday the amount of aid flowing into Gaza is not enough. Meanwhile, aid agencies have criticized US airdrop plans as ineffective, as the United Nations warns hundreds of thousands in the enclave are on the brink of famine and US ally Israel continues to obstruct aid deliveries
  • State of ceasefire-hostage deal negotiations: A senior Biden administration official said there is a “framework deal” that Israel has “more or less accepted.” The sticking point, the official says, is that Hamas has not yet agreed to releasing a “defined category of vulnerable hostages.” CNN reported Friday that officials believed ongoing talks to reach an agreement in time for Ramadan, which starts in just over a week, were still on track — even after more than 100 Palestinians were killed Thursday as they tried to access food in Gaza City. More talks are planned in Cairo, according to two sources familiar with the matter. The exact timing of the talks is unclear, but they will be held at the expert level; recent talks in Paris have included the director level.
  • Harris to meet with Israeli minister: As negotiators try to hammer out a deal, US Vice President Kamala Harris will meet with Israeli war cabinet member Benny Gantz on Monday, according to a White House official. Gantz — who last month warned that Israel would expand military operations in the southernmost city of Rafah if hostages held by Hamas are not returned by the start of Ramadan — is also expected to meet with US national security adviser Jake Sullivan.
  • PIJ encourages attacks: Al-Quds Brigades, the militant wing of Palestinian Islamic Jihad, has called upon residents of the West Bank and Jerusalem to attack checkpoints and roads used by Israeli settlers during Ramadan, according to the group’s spokesperson. The Islamist organization is considered the second-largest militant group in the Gaza Strip after Hamas. While Hamas holds the majority of the hostages, videos from PIJ suggest that the group is also detaining some of them in Gaza.
  • Rafah strike: At least 11 people — including two health workers — were killed in an Israeli airstrike on a refugee camp next to a maternity hospital in Rafah, the Palestinian health ministry in Gaza said Saturday. The Israel Defense Forces claimed it targeted the PIJ in Rafah and that the hospital in the area was not damaged.
  • Protest at rally: Pro-Palestinian protesters interrupted US first lady Jill Biden at least four times during a campaign speech on Saturday in Arizona. It’s just the most recent example of the tense political climate at play in the Democratic Party. In January, President Biden was interrupted more than a dozen times by people protesting the war in Gaza.
  • Cargo ship sinks: A cargo vessel that was hit by a Houthi missile nearly two weeks ago has now sunk, according to Yemeni officials. Mohammed Ali al-Houthi, a prominent Yemeni Houthi figure, claimed that the British government could “salvage” the UK-registered vessel by permitting the entry of aid convoys into Gaza.

Days spent playing or going to school have been replaced by forced displacement and trauma for Gaza's kids

The Hamouda siblings, Kareem, 2, Ella, 6, and Sila, 4, at a pre-school graduation celebration June 15, 2023.

Before the war, Mohammed Hamouda and his wife, Dina, would stroll along beaches in northern Gaza, where their three young children loved to swim, eat ice cream, and ride camels on the shoreline.

On other days, the family of five sat with relatives on the balcony overlooking a green garden at their home in Beit Lahia.

Now, the sound of laughter has been replaced by that of Israeli strikes raining down on the enclave.

But the family has no home to go back to. They recently learned that their house in Beit Lahia was destroyed. Hamouda’s youngest child, Kareem, 2, is too young to understand, but his eldest children, Ella, 6, and Sila, 4, were devastated by the loss and would not stop crying. “I couldn’t find any words to console her (Ella),” he said.

Read the full story.

What to know about the humanitarian airdrops into Gaza

Aid airdropped by the US military falls over Gaza City on March 2.

The United States has, for the first time, airdropped aid into Gaza in an effort to alleviate a spiraling humanitarian crisis.

  • The aid drop included 38,000 meals: It was dropped from three US C-130 aircraft in 66 bundles along the Gaza coastline, according to US Central Command, in a joint effort with Jordan’s military. The White House said more drops will follow. A senior administration official said the US has seen civilians approach and distribute some of the aid.
  • The US is the latest among several nations to drop aid: Previously, Jordan, Egypt, the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, the United Kingdom and France have also delivered humanitarian supplies via this method. Jordanian aircraft made two more aid drops as part of the US mission Saturday, the country’s military said.
  • Coordination with Israel is critical: Israel controls the airspace over Gaza, so any aid-dropping efforts require coordination with Israeli authorities.
  • Airdrops can be imprecise compared to land routes: Earlier this week, a Jordanian plane appeared to miss its target, sending pallets of food into the sea. Video showed Palestinians swimming out to try to secure some rations.
  • Aid groups have been critical of the US plan: Beyond being imprecise, critics like Oxfam’s Scott Paul say airdrops provide a “paltry, symbolic amount of aid” when the US could really make an impact by ceasing the supply of weapons to Israel and demanding that Israel stop blocking wider aid efforts on the ground.
  • Palestinians are in a desperate situation: The aid that lands in the strip is only a fraction of what is needed, with Israel refusing to open more border crossings, the Rafah crossing between Egypt and Gaza working at a reduced rate, and the Kerem Shalom border crossing in Israel often blocked by protesters demanding the release of hostages in Gaza.

Israeli strike on refugee camp kills at least 11 Palestinians, including medical staff, health ministry says

At least 11 people have been killed in an Israeli airstrike on a refugee camp next to a maternity hospital in Rafah, the Palestinian Ministry of Health in Gaza said Saturday.

The strike hit the area where displaced Gazans had been taking shelter in tents outside the gates to the Emirati Maternity Hospital in Tal Al-Sultan in Rafah, the southernmost Gaza city.

The ministry said as many as 50 people, including children, were injured in the strike. A paramedic working at the hospital named Abdel Fattah Abu Marhi, and a nurse are among the dead, according to the ministry.

What the Israel Defense Forces says: The IDF claimed it targeted Islamic Jihad terrorists in Rafah on Saturday and that the hospital in the area was not damaged.

“Earlier today (Saturday), the IDF and ISA targeted Islamic Jihad terrorists and terror infrastructure in the area of Rafah,” according to the statement. “The precision strike was conducted against Islamic Jihad terrorists, and no damage was caused to the hospital in the area.”

After first US airdrop, Biden says amount of aid flowing into Gaza is not enough

US President Joe Biden vowed Saturday to help more aid reach Gaza after the first US humanitarian airdrops into the strip. 

The statement echoes comments the president made on Friday, when he said the US will “insist” that Israel allow more trucks and routes to be added so more aid can be delivered to the people of Gaza.

Remember: United Nations agencies this week warned of an imminent risk of famine for half a million people in Gaza, and aid groups have criticized US plans to drop food aid into the enclave as ineffective. Aid workers and government officials say Israel has engaged in a clear pattern of obstructing humanitarian efforts in the enclave.

Ceasefire talks are expected to resume in Cairo, according to sources

As international efforts to broker a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas continue, more talks are planned in Cairo, according to two sources familiar with the matter.

The exact timing of the talks is unclear, but they will be held at the expert level. Recent talks in Paris have included the director level.

Negotiators from the US, Israel, Egypt and Hamas are expected to attend, according to a diplomatic source familiar with the discussions. It’s not clear if Qatar will attend.

Discussions between Israel and Hamas would be indirect, in separate rooms. 

Israel has asked Hamas for a list of the hostages who are alive and dead. Hamas has still not responded to last Friday’s Paris meeting, which was followed this week by technical meetings in Doha with teams from US, Egypt, Qatar and Israel.

Israel has "basically accepted" 6-week ceasefire proposal and is waiting on Hamas, US official says

People walk through destruction in the Jabalya refugee camp in Gaza, on February 29.

Israel has “basically accepted” a six-week ceasefire proposal in Gaza, a senior official in US President Joe Biden’s administration told reporters Saturday.

A second phase of the proposal would be worked out over those six weeks “to build something more enduring,” the official said.

That same official said there is a “framework deal” that Israel has “more or less accepted.” The sticking point, the official says, is that Hamas has not yet agreed to a “defined category of vulnerable hostages.”

The official added the US has held “a number of meetings” in Israel and a meeting in Paris in the past several weeks. The official also said meetings are “ongoing” Saturday in Doha, Qatar.

Some background: CNN reported Friday that officials believed ongoing talks to reach a Gaza ceasefire agreement in time for Ramadan were still on track — even after more than 100 Palestinians were killed Thursday as they tried to access food in Gaza City. US officials said the carnage injected added urgency to the talks, and US President Joe Biden on Friday afternoon called for an “immediate ceasefire” for at least six weeks as part of a hostage deal.

US officials on Friday said there are no indications that the discussions had been significantly derailed, but much hinges on an expected Hamas response to what has been discussed in Paris and Doha in the past week between the other countries involved: Qatar, Egypt, Israel and the US. On Thursday, a Hamas official warned the negotiations could be impacted.

US has seen civilians approach and distribute airdropped aid in Gaza, according to official

People watch as the US military carries out its first aid drop over Gaza City, on March 2.

The US is monitoring the location where aid was airdropped into Gaza earlier Saturday, and officials have seen civilians approach the aid, according to a senior official in President Joe Biden’s administration. The official also said the US has seen the civilians distribute the aid among themselves.

Another senior administration official told reporters that the specific site in Gaza was chosen for Saturday’s drops because they believed that people were sheltering nearby and “in need.”

US Central Command said in a statement Saturday that the combined operation by the US and Royal Jordanian Air Force saw US C-130 aircraft dropping 38,000 meals along the Gaza coastline. There were 66 total bundles dropped – 22 from each of the three aircraft — a US official said. There was no water or medical supplies in the bundles. 

Another senior administration official said the US and Jordanian forces were not coordinating with any group on the ground. 

Cargo ship sinks 12 days after being hit by Houthi missile as Yemen warns of "environmental disaster"

This satellite image shows the Rubymar in the Red Sea on Friday, March 1.

The MV Rubymar, a cargo vessel that was hit by a Houthi missile twelve days ago, has now sunk, according to Yemeni officials Saturday.

The Belize-flagged, UK-registered and Lebanese-owned vessel was carrying 41,000 tons of fertilizer when it was struck by one of two ballistic missiles fired from Houthi territory in Yemen. The ship’s crew was forced to evacuate.

The sinking Rubymar created an 18-mile-long oil slick in the Red Sea, two US officials said previously. Satellite images showed the vessel continuously leaking oil. It is unclear what kind of substance caused the slick.

The damage sustained by the Rubymar is potentially the most significant to a vessel caused by an attack launched by the Houthis, who have been targeting commercial shipping in the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden for months, in what they say is retaliation for Israel’s war in Gaza.

CNN’s Haley Britzky, Oren Liebermann and Natasha Bertrand contributed reporting to this post.

US is planning more Gaza airdrops in the coming days after first one was "successful," White House says

US service members secure humanitarian aid, bound for airdrop over Gaza, onto a cargo aircraft at an undisclosed location on March 1.  

A White House official described its first airdrop of humanitarian aid into Gaza as “successful.”

The official added that the Defense Department is planning on conducting additional airdrops in Gaza in the days ahead. The official said they could not provide any further details at this time about what the additional airdrops would entail.

For context: Aid agencies have criticized US plans to drop food aid into Gaza as ineffective, as the United Nations warns hundreds of thousands in the enclave are on the brink of famine and US ally Israel continues to obstruct the bulk of aid deliveries. Some humanitarian officials have labeled it “a Band-Aid measure” and said the aid drops “mostly serve to relieve the guilty consciences of senior US officials.”

The US has started dropping aid in Gaza as it faces criticism from humanitarian groups. Here's what to know

Aid destined for an airdrop over Gaza is loaded aboard a US Air Force plane at an undisclosed location in Southwest Asia, on March 1. 

The United States has begun dropping humanitarian aid into Gaza by air, according to US Central Command.

The combined operation by the US Air Force and the Royal Jordanian Air Force saw three US C-130 transport planes drop 38,000 meals along the Gaza coastline on Saturday, CENTCOM said in a statement. There was no water or medical supplies.

US President Joe Biden announced the move Friday, saying more aid is desperately needed in the enclave, and that Israel must also allow for more trucks and routes for aid in Gaza.

Officials from several aid agencies, including the International Crisis Group and Oxfam, criticized the US plan as ineffective.

“Humanitarian workers always complain that airdrops are good photo opportunities but a lousy way to deliver aid,” the ICG’s United Nations director, Richard Gowan, said on X.

Oxfam’s Scott Paul wrote that the aid drops only “serve to relieve the guilty consciences of senior US officials,” who should instead cut military aid to Israel and push for an immediate ceasefire. CNN has documented how US ally Israel obstructs the bulk of aid deliveries to the enclave.

Here are other headlines you should know:

  • More deadly Israeli strikes: An Israeli strike on a refugee camp next to a maternity hospital in Rafah killed at least 11 Palestinians, including medical staff, according to the Ministry of Health in Gaza. More Israeli airstrikes elsewhere on Saturday killed at least 17 civilians and injured dozens of others, according to Palestinian news agency WAFA. The airstrikes targeted three houses in the central city of Deir al-Balah and furthern north in Jabalya, WAFA added.
  • Other developments on the ground: The Israeli military announced plans Saturday to temporarily suspend “military activities” in parts of Rafah and Deir al-Balah for several hours at a time over the course of several days until March 7 for “humanitarian purposes.”
  • Ceasefire deal: Ongoing talks to reach a ceasefire agreement to halt the fighting between Hamas and Israel in Gaza by Ramadan appear to still be on track. US officials on Friday said there are no indications that the discussions had been significantly derailed but much hinges on an expected Hamas response to what has been discussed in Paris and Doha in the past week between the other countries involved: Qatar, Egypt, Israel and the US. On Thursday, a Hamas official warned the negotiations could be impacted.
  • Gaza food aid tragedy: Many of the Palestinian civilians injured during the carnage at a food aid convoy on Thursday suffered gunshot wounds, according to a UN team that visited the hospital where survivors were taken. At least 118 people were killed and 760 injured when Israel Defense Forces troops opened fire on starving Palestinian civilians who were gathering around food aid trucks, according to eyewitnesses and the health ministry in Gaza. The IDF has denied that account, saying it fired warning shots to disperse a crowd. The UN has said an independent investigation is required to establish the facts, and nations such as France have backed that appeal.
  • Humanitarian crisis: UN Women, a United Nations organization dedicated to gender equality and the empowerment of women, called the war in Gaza “also a war on women” in a statement Friday. The organization estimates 9,000 women have been killed in Gaza since the October 7 attack on Israel by Hamas. And at least 10 Palestinian children have starved to death in Gaza, the UN reported on Friday, after a senior United Nations official warned Israel’s severe restrictions on aid entering the strip are creating a “man-made famine.”

"A temporary Band-Aid": Aid agencies criticize US airdrop plans in Gaza

Children wait to receive food cooked by a charity kitchen in Rafah, Gaza, on February 13.

Aid agencies have criticized as ineffective US plans to drop food aid into Gaza, where the United Nations warns hundreds of thousands are on the brink of famine, and US ally Israel continues to obstruct the bulk of aid deliveries.

President Joe Biden announced the move on Friday, saying “nowhere nearly enough” aid is entering the enclave. The first drop was made Saturday morning, according to two US officials.

Here’s what some humanitarian officials said after the plan was announced:

Richard Gowan, the International Crisis Group’s UN director, said:

Oxfam’s Scott Paul wrote on X that the aid drops “mostly serve to relieve the guilty consciences of senior US officials whose policies are contributing to the ongoing atrocities and risk of famine in Gaza.

“While Palestinians in Gaza have been pushed to the absolute brink, dropping a paltry, symbolic amount of aid into Gaza with no plan for its safe distribution would not help and be deeply degrading to Palestinians.”

Brian Finucane, a senior adviser at the International Crisis Group, said on X:

“If the U.S. government disavows the use of any meaningful leverage to bring the Gaza conflict to a close, it is left with desperate and inadequate measures like this to try to address the resulting humanitarian catastrophe around the margins.”

This post has been updated to reflect the first US airdrop was made Saturday.

JUST IN: US airdrops of aid into Gaza have begun

US military carries out its first aid drop in Gaza City on March 2.

The US has begun airdropping humanitarian aid into Gaza, according to two US officials.

President Joe Biden on Friday had announced the US would begin the airdrops soon after saying, “Aid flowing to Gaza is nowhere nearly enough.”

Three US C-130 transport planes dropped humanitarian supplies over Gaza on Saturday, according to a US official.

There were 66 total bundles dropped — 22 from each aircraft, the official said.

The bundles were meals dropped for the population of Gaza. There was no water or medical supplies.

Criticism of the US plan: Several aid agencies have previously criticized the US plans to drop food aid into Gaza as ineffective.

Richard Gowan, the International Crisis Group’s United Nations director, said on social media: “Humanitarian workers always complain that airdrops are good photo opportunities but a lousy way to deliver aid.”

Oxfam’s Scott Paul wrote on X that the aid drops “mostly serve to relieve the guilty consciences of senior US officials whose policies are contributing to the ongoing atrocities and risk of famine in Gaza.”

The UN has warned hundreds of thousands are on the brink of famine in the enclave.

This post has been updated with additional details on the drops and global reception of the plan.

Talks on an Israel-Hamas ceasefire deal appear on track despite killings at Gaza aid site, officials say

Ongoing talks to reach a ceasefire agreement to halt the fighting between Hamas and Israel in Gaza by Ramadan appear to still be on track, even after more than 100 Palestinians were killed on Thursday as they tried to access food in Gaza City, according to officials familiar with the discussions.

US officials on Friday said there are no indications that the discussions had been significantly derailed but much hinges on an expected Hamas response to what has been discussed in Paris and Doha in the past week between the other countries involved: Qatar, Egypt, Israel and the US. On Thursday, a Hamas official warned the negotiations could be impacted.

CNN has reached out to several Hamas officials about the potential deal but has not gotten a response.

In the immediate aftermath of the deaths of dozens of Palestinian civilians in Gaza on Thursday, US officials said the chaotic scenes injected added urgency into the hostage and ceasefire talks.

Read the full story here.

Large number of gunshot wounds among those injured at Gaza food aid site carnage, UN says

The United Nations say many of the Palestinian civilians injured during the carnage at a food aid convoy on Thursday suffered gunshot wounds, citing a UN team that visited the hospital where survivors were taken.

UN Secretary General’s spokesperson Stéphane Dujarric told a news conference on Friday “from what they saw, in terms of the patients alive and getting treatment is that there is a large number of gunshot wounds,” Dujarric said. 

At least 115 people were killed and 760 injured in an incident where Israel Defense Forces (IDF) troops used live fire as hungry and desperate Palestinian civilians were gathering around food aid trucks, the Ministry of Health in Gaza said.

Dujarric added that the UN envoy, made up of members from OCHA, WHO and UNICEF, which visited Al-Shifa, didn’t examine any of the dead bodies so cannot say if the same is true for those killed.

Al-Shifa took in more than 700 injured patients following the food aid site tragedy and about 200 of those remain hospitalized, Dujarric said.  

Conflicting accounts: There are mounting international calls for an independent investigation into the incident, with the circumstances disputed.

Israeli military spokesman Daniel Hagari said Israeli tanks fired warning shots to “cautiously” disperse a crowd gathering around an aid convoy, after seeing that people in the crowd were being trampled. 

But eyewitness accounts suggest the Israeli military opened fire on people near the trucks, causing drivers to pull away in panic.

At least 17 killed and dozens injured in Israeli strikes on Gaza, Palestinian news agency says

Israeli airstrike targeted Al-Bukhari Mosque in Deir Al-Balah, Gaza on March 2.

At least 17 civilians were killed, and dozens injured in Gaza following airstrikes from Israeli military on Saturday, according to Palestinian news agency WAFA.

The airstrikes targeted three houses in Deir al-Balah and Jabalia in Gaza, WAFA report added. 

CNN is unable to independently verify the casualty numbers or claims made by WAFA in its reporting. 

Fifteen of those killed were in two unidentified houses east of Deir al-Balah, central Gaza, WAFA reported quoting medical official. These houses were targeted by two Israeli “warplanes,” the report added.

Two others were killed in the Jabalia camp in northern Gaza, WAFA report said, adding, “Israeli fighter jets struck a house,” resulting in their deaths.

CNN has reached out to IDF for comment on the alleged airstrikes.

Mounting toll: The Gaza Ministry of Health said Saturday that the death toll in the Gaza Strip has risen to 30,320, and the total number of injuries has also risen to 71,533. There has been a huge impact on children, with about half of Gaza’s population under 18.