Flattened in a year
SCROLL DOWN

The Barakat family home in Al Rimal, northern Gaza, had white arched doorways and yellow walls lined with baby photos. This is where Abeer Barakat, 42, lived with her husband and their four teenage children.

“That house is a place that me and my husband have built together over the years. We chose everything in it,” the academic and lecturer told CNN last month. “Every inch of it means something to us.”

But on October 7 – when the Israeli military launched its assault on Gaza following the Hamas-led attacks in southern Israel – air raid sirens started to sound as bombs fell on the neighborhood west of Gaza City. Two days later, their house was hit by flying debris.

“Suddenly we just saw smoke everywhere. We couldn't see. The fumes of gunpowder were very bad to smell. The sound is deafening. When (my daughter) went inside, she said, ‘Mom, the room is no more.’”

“The walls had holes in them. A lot of my furniture had been broken, and the street was totally broken,” Barakat said. “Now, because of this war, we are scattered... We have no place to call home.”

Friends, aunts and colleagues lost their homes elsewhere in Gaza’s northern regions, Barakat reflected, as entire communities were “wiped out” in the early days of the war.

Israel's bombing campaign has created more than 42 million tons of debris in Gaza, which is 14 times greater than the combined total from all conflicts over the past 16 years, the UN reported in August. A year into the war, the figure is still growing.

To put that vast quantity of rubble into perspective, it would fill Central Park in New York City…

…to a height of 8 meters (about 26 feet).

The United Nations Environment Programme estimated in July that it would take at least eight years to clear that amount of debris from Gaza.

Flattened
in a year

How Israeli bombardment reduced most of Gaza to rubble

Published October 8, 2024

No one in Gaza has been left untouched by the yearlong Israeli offensive, which has forced some 1.9 million people from their homes.

Palestinians say they are barely surviving, let alone able to rebuild, under Israel’s bombardment and siege, which has decimated the healthcare system, damaged cultural sites, eviscerated academic institutions, and spawned a humanitarian crisis of hunger, displacement and disease.

CNN has spoken to people in Gaza’s five governorates – Northern Gaza, Gaza City, Deir al-Balah, Khan Younis and Rafah – whose lives and livelihoods have been turned to rubble, including doctors, shop owners, aid workers and educators. People in the north say they struggle to feed their families, while many displaced in central Gaza are pitched in flimsy tents surrounded by raw sewage. Further south, some are forced to stay in the ruins of their destroyed homes.

Barakat, like many, has sought shelter with relatives elsewhere in Gaza City but has revisited what remains of her home several times, in part to try to salvage what she can. “It’s very exhausting,” she said. “Every time I entered my room I would cry, because it felt like a nightmare. I couldn’t believe it.”

Listen to Abeer Barakat talk about how the loss of her home has changed her family

00:00

“Every piece of furniture, every corner of my home... It was the labor of our life,” she said. “It's not just walls. It's our emotions. Memories, love stories, sad stories.

“It’s not only the home that is scattered and broken. Our hearts are broken. We are no longer the same. Nothing is the same.”

Two photos of a destroyed building. A close-up of framed photos with young girls smiling. A cat sits on a ledge of a burnt-out floor of a room without a facade.
Framed photos, papers and mementoes are strewn among broken pieces of wall in the rubble of Abeer Barakat’s family home in Al Rimal, northern Gaza. Courtesy Abeer Barakat

Israel launched its military offensive against Hamas on October 7 after the militant group, which governs Gaza, attacked southern Israel. At least 1,200 people were killed and more than 250 were abducted, according to Israeli authorities, with 101 hostages still in Gaza.

Israeli attacks in Gaza have since killed at least 41,965 Palestinians and injured another 97,590, according to the Ministry of Health there. CNN cannot independently confirm the figures. Many of Israel’s strikes have hit civilian infrastructure. Israel has for years said Hamas fighters use mosques, hospitals and other civilian buildings to hide from Israeli attacks and launch their own. Hamas has repeatedly denied the claims.

A UN independent human rights probe in June accused both Israel and Hamas of committing war crimes and crimes against humanity.

As the Israeli military intensifies its war on multiple fronts in the region, people in Gaza fear the world’s focus has shifted from their plight.

Read the stories of five people who have been living and working amid Gaza’s rubble for the past year.

This map shows damage to human settlements across Gaza’s five governates as of September 13. The CUNY Institute estimates that 59% of buildings on the strip have been damaged.

Northern Gaza governorate

69% of buildings damaged

As of Sept. 13, 2024
As of Sept. 13, 2024

Rescue crews try to pull a girl from the wreckage of a building destroyed by Israeli airstrikes in Jabalya refugee camp, northern Gaza. Thousands of people are believed to be missing under the rubble.

Northern Gaza was the hardest-hit governorate in the early weeks of Israel’s offensive.

“They left us with nothing”

Mahmoud Almadhoun, shop owner

Wide pans of rice and soup steam over makeshift stoves at a soup kitchen in Beit Lahia, in northern Gaza. Dozens of displaced people cram against a barrier, stretching out empty bowls.

Before the war, Mahmoud Almadhoun owned a shop selling mobile devices. But like many other retailers across the ravaged enclave, Israel’s bombing campaign destroyed his business – leaving him homeless. These days, Almadhoun runs this soup kitchen. “We were doing well, things were good. But now, there is no shop left, no home,” he told CNN on September 19. “All of our homes have been completely destroyed... They left us with nothing.”

Three photos of a soup kitchen. One shows dozens of people, mainly children, waiting behind a low barrier arms oustretched holding plastic and metal bowls. A man fills their bowls with steaming hot orange-colored soup as they crowd around him in anticipation. A pile of soup pots lay behind a makeshift stove that ha a few giant metal soup pots cooking.
Palestinians running this soup kitchen in Beit Lahia, northern Gaza, fill at least 450 pots of soup per day. Courtesy Mahmoud Almadhoun

Israel’s siege and bombardment have propelled the entire population of more than 2.2 million people in Gaza towards the risk of full-scale famine. At least 38 children have starved to death and 3,500 children are at risk of death due to malnutrition, Gaza’s Ministry of Health, and Government Media Office (GMO) reported last month.

Israeli forces have directly hit at least 34 bakeries in Gaza, according to Ismail Al-Thawabtah, the GMO’s director general. All 148 bakeries have been put out of service, he said, citing severe fuel shortages and the lack of flour entering the strip. Meanwhile, shortages have inflated food prices – at the same time as Palestinians whose livelihoods have been destroyed struggle to earn.

Almadhoun said he feeds between 600 and 800 families per day in the northern Gaza strip, telling CNN that his initiative is a testament to the Palestinian commitment to life under siege. “Thank God we survived physically,” he said. “That is our greatest victory.”

undefined

Gaza governorate

74% of buildings damaged

As of Sept. 13, 2024
As of Sept. 13, 2024

In this governorate we find Al-Shifa Hospital, one of many to have been damaged by the Israeli offensive over the past year.

Al-Shifa Hospital has been the target of multiple Israeli military operations which have heavily damaged the facility. It was considered a top-level teaching hospital.

“Healthcare system in ruins”

Dr Marwan Abu Sa’ada, General Manager of Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City

The sound of bombing, strikes and helicopters engulf Al-Shifa Hospital, in northern Gaza, as medical workers attempt to revive healthcare services in what was once the largest facility in the strip.

“After what happened at Al-Shifa Hospital in March, the idea of being there at night is very scary,” Ali Alghaliz, an emergency doctor, told CNN on September 17. “Doing night shifts there is… a very, very huge risk to your life.”

The Israeli campaign has paralyzed the medical system in Gaza. At least 19 out of 36 hospitals are not functioning, the UN’s Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) said on October 2. More than 986 medical workers have been killed, the Ministry of Health reported on October 3.

The doctor wears a white vest looking at the burnt-out destroyed hospital building. There are no walls on the facade, inside the rooms are visible and they are empty of all distinguishing features that make it a former hospital.
Dr Marwan Abu Sa’ada surveys ruined buildings at Al-Shifa Hospital. Khader Al-Za’anoun/Wafa

Israeli forces raided Al-Shifa Hospital for the second time in March with the stated aim of targeting Hamas militants – unleashing a wave of destruction, bulldozing roads and leaving at least 381 bodies in mass graves, according to witnesses and local officials. Medical staff were detained, and displaced Palestinians were targeted by Israeli snipers and helicopters while trying to flee, the Ministry of Health said at the time. Israel said its troops had killed Hamas militants, and seized weaponry and intelligence documents.

Before the war, the teaching hospital housed 700 beds, 26 operating rooms and 32 ICU beds, according to Dr Marwan Abu Sa’ada, the general manager of the complex – as well as the largest neonatal department in the occupied Palestinian territories. At least 250,000 patients were treated annually in the emergency department alone. Now, just half of the facility has been renovated, added Abu Sa’ada.

“The devastating war in Gaza destroyed everything – buildings, trees, people – leaving our healthcare system in ruins,” said Abu Sa’ada. “Not a single stone was left unturned.”

Deir al-Balah governorate

49% of buildings damaged

As of Sept. 13, 2024
As of Sept. 13, 2024

People look through the rubble of buildings in April in Nuseirat refugee camp, central Gaza, a densely populated area that was home to tens of thousands of people before the war.

“Impacts of uncleared debris are severe”

Samer Abuzerr, public health scientist

Ribbons of smoke from makeshift fires run through the dusty streets of the Nuseirat refugee camp in central Gaza. Clouds of dust from uncleared rubble also pollute the air, according to Samer Abuzerr, a public health scientist displaced with his wife and their three daughters and son.

“The health impacts of uncleared debris in Gaza are severe and long-lasting,” he told CNN last month.

A young boy walks on a street filled with pieces of wall, broken concrete, blue plastic bags, pipes and rubble. The roof of the building behind him is collapsing under the weight of fallen concrete.
A boy walks through the rubble of a house damaged by Israeli bombardment in Nuseirat camp, central Gaza, in July. Majdi Fathi/NurPhoto/AP

As many as 150,000 housing units have been destroyed, the GMO reported in September. Palestinians suffering the immediate trauma of losing their homes must also contend with the hazards posed by mounds of waste, unexploded ordnance, asbestos and human remains buried under vast piles of rubble.

Weapons remnants pose a particular threat to children, Abuzerr told CNN. Exposure to asbestos fibers can lead to cancers such as mesothelioma, while the presence of uncleared rubble in areas where people are trying to shelter can exacerbate asthma and bronchitis among children and cause skin infections and injuries, he added. In August, the World Health Organization reported 995,000 cases of acute respiratory infections in the strip.

Meanwhile, poor sanitary conditions make the spread of diseases via water and carriers like mosquitoes more likely, “creating a public health nightmare in an already overburdened healthcare system,” said Abuzerr. “The pollution from these makeshift fires, combined with the dust from destroyed buildings, has significantly worsened air quality."

Further south, in Khan Younis, the wreckage of a university campus struck by Israel’s bombardment is a reminder of the severe disruption to education in Gaza.

Khan Younis governorate

55% of buildings damaged

As of Sept. 13, 2024
As of Sept. 13, 2024

A woman and two children pass along a street in Khan Younis next to a flattened mosque, one of 825 damaged or destroyed in Gaza, according to Gaza's Government Media Office.

undefined

“A generation’s aspirations turned to dust”

Samer Abuzerr, assistant professor

Abuzerr misses the students who brought his seminar room to life at the University College of Science and Technology in Khan Younis, in southern Gaza.

“There was a unique joy in being part of their journey toward becoming the next generation of health professionals,” the assistant professor told CNN. “Seeing the enthusiasm in their eyes and their desire to contribute to the well-being of our community gave me immense pride and hope for the future.”

Listen to Samer Abuzerr talking about what being a Palestinian in Gaza means to him

00:00

But Israeli forces hit the facility on January 7, OCHA reported. According to the UNICEF-led Education Cluster, 85% of school buildings had been destroyed or damaged as of July 6. The Palestinian Ministry of Education in Gaza confirmed that Israeli attacks have killed 11,600 students, more than 750 teachers and school staff, and 130 scholars, academics and university professors.

A large heavily damaged building with the words “AL AZHAR UNIVERSITY-GAZA’ stands surrounded by rubble and bent metal.
Al Azhar University in Gaza City, northern Gaza, is among numerous higher education facilities to have been damaged or destroyed. Source: AFP/Getty Images

“Universities are not just buildings; they are symbols of resilience, knowledge and hope. To witness their destruction is to see a generation’s aspirations turned to dust,” added Abuzerr.

He told CNN that several of his colleagues and students had been killed since the war began – including one of his “brightest students” who had been working on a public health project aimed at improving water and sanitation practices in refugee camps. “Each loss is a reminder of the fragility of life here and it amplifies the sense of injustice we live with daily."

The father-of-four said he is haunted by the reality that his children’s academic prospects are hanging in the balance – like those of many young Palestinians. “I worry that this lost time will never be recovered and the damage to their intellectual and emotional development will be irreversible,” he said.

“At the same time, I cling to the hope that, through our collective resilience, we can somehow create a better future for them, despite everything.”

Young children sit on the floor of a tent structure with white plastic walls writing with pencils on paper.
Children learn in a makeshift classroom in a displacement camp in Rafah, southern Gaza. Every school in the strip has been closed since last October, UNICEF says. Said Khatib/AFP/Getty Images

Rafah governorate

59% of buildings damaged

As of Sept. 13, 2024
As of Sept. 13, 2024

Deserted tent camps and buildings are dotted across Rafah, near the border with Egypt, after an Israeli ground incursion forced hundreds of thousands of Palestinians to flee the city earlier this spring for other central and southern areas of the strip.

Most displaced people in Gaza are living in makeshift shelters with fabric walls and have on average 1.5 square meters (16 square feet) of space, according to the UN, which is about the area of a single bed.

undefined

“The needs and devastation are indescribable”

Hisham Mhanna, communications officer for the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC)

Hisham Mhanna remembers the moment he was forced to leave his office in Rafah, before Israeli forces launched a ground incursion into the southern Gazan city in May. Throngs of people, pregnant women and children among them, fled carrying whatever they could squeeze into their backpacks – without the promise of safety ahead.

“It was an apocalyptic scene,” the communications officer for the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) told CNN in September. "Over the past 16 years, there has been a number of military operations that Palestinians in Gaza and their families could to some extent rebuild their lives (after)... This time they have lost everything.”

A convoy of vehicles piled with personal items like bags and rugs pass through a road with destroyed buildings in the background.
As of September there were 1.8 million people in the south of Gaza, the majority of whom were forcefully displaced, says the UN. Ali Jadallah/Anadolu/Getty Images
Two photos, one has a young girl carrying an old lady on her back as she walks along a road. Also a convoy of vehicles laden with personal items like bedding and cooking pots.
Only 11% of people in the south of Gaza have not been forcefully displaced, according to the UN. Many have been forced to move multiple times. Ahmad Salem/Bloomberg/Getty Images, Abdel Kareem Hana/AP Photo

Like other local aid workers in the strip, Mhanna is trying to bring relief to his compatriots. But the Israeli offensive has led to “indescribable” humanitarian demand, he warned, citing sustained Israeli aid sanctions, lengthy truck inspections, damaged roads, strikes on aid convoys and impeded access to the north as among the challenges.

Meanwhile, the closure of the Rafah crossing by Israeli forces in May reduced the entry of aid into the strip, said Mhanna. The Israeli agency that controls the flow of aid into Gaza said on September 25 that at least 52,955 trucks carrying more than 1 million tons of aid had entered the enclave since the fighting erupted. But humanitarian agencies say it is not enough.

Listen to Hisham Mhanna reflect on one year of war in Gaza

00:00

The UN has accused Israel of creating a “man-made” catastrophe in Gaza. Just two weeks ago, the agency reported that at least 46% of coordinated humanitarian movements in Gaza were denied or impeded by Israel.

“If you walk through the displaced areas where people exist... You can tell how much suffering they have endured in trying to survive,” Mhanna told CNN. “Areas that used to be very busy with people walking around – markets, parks, campus areas – have just turned into rubble and sewage lakes."

“How come the world cannot stop this killing machine?”

Palestinians try to find moments of reprieve among a ruined landscape. But some told CNN they are irreparably scarred by the horror of searching for loved ones buried under collapsed buildings.

At least 10,000 people are missing and believed to be entombed under the rubble in Gaza, according to the GMO.

Barakat, the academic and mother from Gaza City, says she is tormented by the memory of trying to find the remains of her four nephews and niece after they were killed by an Israeli attack in northern Gaza’s Al-Ansar neighborhood on July 9.

"When my husband and the rest of the family went to extract them from under the rubble, they found that they were in bits and pieces,” she said. "When you look at this piece and you remember that this was a human, a complete human being, this is something that will keep toying in your mind... For three nights after they (were) killed, I (kept) dreaming about them.

Listen to Abeer Barakat talk about finding hope in faith

00:00

“My son helped in the process of extracting the remains of their bodies... My son was broken because these cousins, they were like his brothers,” she said. “He was devastated.

"Every time I see someone who I know is being killed, or he loses his family, I cry. I cry to the level that I feel pain in my throat and in my stomach,” she told CNN. “I keep questioning, why is this happening to us? How come the whole world cannot stop this killing machine?

"Please do not let our lives go unseen or unnoticed, and do not leave our blood to go dry in vain.”

Mapping methodology

Damage analysis of Copernicus Sentinel-1 satellite data by Corey Scher of CUNY Graduate Center and Jamon Van Den Hoek of Oregon State University; data as of Sept. 13, 2024. The damage assessment represents a conservative estimate of likely damage to human settlements (cities, towns, villages) and does not include potential damage to agricultural or other vegetated areas.

Additional sources: United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (base map data); Google (satellite image).

Credits
Writer and Reporter
Sana Noor Haq
Visual editors
Henrik Pettersson and Sarah-Grace Mankarious
Data and graphics
Rachel Wilson
Maps
Renée Rigdon
Illustration and animation
Yukari Schrickel
Developer
Special Projects, CNN Visuals
Photo editor
Toby Hancock
Editors
Laura Smith-Spark and Kathryn Snowdon
Contributing reporters
CNN's Eyad Kourdi, Abeer Salman and Kareem Khadder contributed reporting. Khader Al-Za'anoun of Wafa, the official Palestinian news agency, contributed reporting.
Top image
Ali Jadallah/Anadolu/Getty Images