January 5, 2023 GOP deadlocked over House speaker vote | CNN Politics

January 5, 2023 GOP deadlocked over House speaker vote

mccarthy vpx 010523
McCarthy after failing on 11th vote: 'It's OK if it takes a little longer'
03:35 - Source: CNN

What we covered here

  • The House has adjourned until noon Friday after Rep. Kevin McCarthy suffered a stinging 11th defeat in the race for House speaker. 
  • After three days of voting, this is now the longest speaker contest in 164 years.
  • McCarthy has continued to negotiate with a group of hardline Republicans who’ve derailed his bid, proposing key concessions in his push to get more votes.
  • About this process: A nominee needs 218 votes, but the number required could change if members withhold their votes. The House can’t kick off the new Congress or swear in new members until a speaker is elected.
91 Posts

Our live coverage of the House speaker election has moved here.

McCarthy says there's no timeline for getting to 218 votes and defends concessions he has made

McCarthy talks with the media after the House voted to adjourn for the evening on Thursday, January 5.

After the House voted to adjourn for the night, Rep. Kevin McCarthy told reporters that while there has been progress in negotiations, there was no timeline on when he could get to 218 votes.

McCarthy’s bid for speaker – he lost 11 votes in the House this week – has been stymied by about 20 fellow Republicans.

“I have the longest speech on the floor so apparently I like to make history,” McCarthy said, referring to an address of 8 hours and 32 minutes he made in November 2021 aimed at stalling President Biden’s plan to expand the social safety net. “If this takes a little longer, that’s OK,” he added.

McCarthy also addressed why differences weren’t resolved before Tuesday, saying “we tried to sort it out before Jan. 3.”

On the concessions he’s made so far, McCarthy said he’s not concerned about giving just one member the power to call for a vote to oust the speaker. “I’m very fine with that,” McCarthy said. “I’m not afraid. … I won’t be a weaker speaker.”

McCarthy also denied that any members would lose committee assignments and said there have been no negotiations that involved giving subcommittee chairmanships to dissidents.

House GOP members scheduled to hold a conference call on Friday

House Republicans are scheduled to hold a conference call Friday, a source familiar tells CNN.

Rep. Kevin McCarthy and his allies had wanted to avoid another in-person conference-wide meeting after Tuesday’s in-person meeting led to private tensions spilling out into public view.

But the thought is that a call could potentially minimize that, as members from all sides of the conference continue to try to come to a deal over the speakership.

Here's what to know about Thursday's multiple votes for speaker

Despite making key concessions to get the top job, McCarthy on Thursday was again unable to persuade enough Republicans to elect him Speaker of the House — failing to get the required majority after 11 rounds of voting that have taken place over three days.

This has been the longest contest for speaker in 164 years.

As the stalemate continues, tensions are rising. One reliably conservative GOP lawmaker told CNN about the “increasing frustration” among centrists at the number of concessions McCarthy has offered opponents as he scrambles to get to 218 votes.

Here are the key details:

  • Opposition: Twenty Republican lawmakers, despite continued talks and concessions, have so far declined to support McCarthy. Republicans again nominated Rep. Byron Donalds for four of five of Thursday’s voting rounds. After getting a few votes on the eighth ballot, Rep. Kevin Hern was also officially nominated for the ninth, 10th and 11th rounds of voting. Notably, Rep. Matt Gaetz voted for former President Donald Trump during the seventh and eighth ballots, and he nominated the former president for speaker in the 11th ballot. Trump only received one vote in that round.
  • “Present” votes: GOP Rep. Victoria Spartz, who initially voted for Rep. Kevin McCarthy, voted present on Wednesday and for all five ballots Thursday. She said at the beginning of the day she felt talks needed to make more progress and that McCarthy needed to “move the needle” first.
  • Ongoing negotiations: McCarthy allies and opponents are pushing for a deal Thursday tonight in an attempt to show progress, a source says. But, at least four Republican members are leaving town Friday because of various family issues. Lawmakers hope to have some sort of agreement tonight and then a deal to adjourn at some point over the next 24 hours in order to come back Monday, a separate source says.
  • “Motion to vacate”: In a series of new concessions first reported by CNN Wednesday night, McCarthy agreed to propose a rules change that would allow just one member to call for a vote to oust a sitting speaker, sources say. McCarthy had initially proposed a five-member threshold, down from current conference rules that require half of the GOP to call for such a vote. 
  • Other concessions: McCarthy also agreed to allow for more members of the Freedom Caucus to serve on the powerful House Rules Committee. While McCarthy’s allies are willing to swallow most of the deals, they are drawing a line in the sand over one issue: committee gavels for the holdouts. Later, in a meeting with moderates, McCarthy downplayed the concessions he’s made so far.
  • McCarthy’s thinking: Asked if he is concerned that he could be a short-lived speaker because of the concessions he’s made to give one member the power to call for a vote seeking a speaker’s ouster, McCarthy said, “No, not at all.” Thursday morning before the House reconvened, McCarthy said he feels talks are “making progress,” adding that lawmakers are “working together to find a solution.”
  • Democrats: Rep. Hakeem Jeffries continues to have the unanimous support of his caucus. He told reporters before voting started Thursday that his party does not plan to help the GOP, and will continue to be present and stand united. President Joe Biden said he is closely watching the House.
  • A historic floor fight: This is the longest speakership bid in more than 160 years. It took nine ballots for Rep. Frederick Gillett of Massachusetts to be elected speaker in 1923. And in 1849, the House had been in session so long without being able to elect a speaker – 19 days – that members voted to elect their speaker with a plurality rather than a majority. Members ultimately confirmed the plurality election with a majority vote.

A marathon of speaker ballots: Here's a look at Thursday's votes

Rep. Kevin McCarthy has now failed to win a majority of votes across 11 ballots over three days in his push to become House speaker.

Despite continued talks, 20 Republicans have consistently not voted for him (up from 19 defections in the first two rounds) — and instead have nominated other candidates to take votes away from McCarthy.

The House will remain paralyzed until this standoff is resolved. It’s now the longest contest in 164 years.

Here’s a look at how the votes panned out on Thursday:

Seventh: 

  • 212: Jeffries
  • 201: McCarthy
  • 19: Donalds
  • 1: Other — Trump
  • 1: Present

Eighth:

  • 212: Jeffries
  • 201: McCarthy
  • 17: Donalds
  • 3: Others — Trump, Rep. Kevin Hern
  • 1: Present

Ninth:

  • 212: Jeffries
  • 200: McCarthy
  • 17: Donalds
  • 3: Hern
  • 1: Present

10th:

  • 212: Jeffries
  • 200: McCarthy
  • 13: Donalds
  • 7: Hern
  • 1: Present

11th:

  • 212: Jeffries
  • 200: McCarthy
  • 7: Hern
  • 1: Trump
  • 12: Other — Donalds
  • 1: Present

The House has voted to adjourn until Friday

The House has voted to adjourn until noon on Friday — without a clear decision on a speaker. The House cannot continue any business or swear in new members without filling the speaker role.

Lawmakers voted five times on Thursday, but Rep. Kevin McCarthy was unable to secure the votes to win the speakership.

Members say negotiations are ongoing.

The House is voting on whether to adjourn until noon Friday

The House is now voting on whether or not to adjourn until noon ET on Friday.

The motion needs a simple majority to pass.

McCarthy is defeated in 11th ballot for House speaker

Kevin McCarthy was defeated again in the 11th round of voting for House speaker.

This is now the longest speaker contest in 164 years.

His GOP opponents nominated two other Republicans – Rep. Kevin Hern and former President Donald Trump – to draw votes away from McCarthy.

Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries had the unanimous support of his caucus.

The final tally was:

  • 212 for Rep. Hakeem Jeffries
  • 200 for Rep. Kevin McCarthy
  • 12 Rep. Byron Donalds
  • 7 for Rep. Kevin Hern
  • 1 Donald Trump
  • 1 present vote

McHenry says House is probably not going to adjourn any time soon

GOP Rep. Patrick McHenry, a key negotiator who is trying to lock in support for Rep. Kevin McCarthy for speaker, said the House is “probably not” going to adjourn any time soon. 

But he expressed optimism about the state of the negotiations. 

“Each meeting is more positive than the last. And that’s a very nice sign,” McHenry told reporters as he emerged from the GOP negotiating room. 

“This is gonna be a nice evening eventually, just a question of when,” he said. 

When asked if there was a deal physically on paper he quipped, “Yeah, no, we’re not quite digital yet.” 

“What we want to do is have assurances on paper about what the process is and how to deliver these conservative reforms that I think the conference will appreciate and endorse,” he said. 

McCarthy's PAC has given hundreds of thousands of dollars to those now opposing him for speaker

Rep. Kevin McCarthy steered hundreds of thousands of dollars in campaign cash to members of the GOP caucus now threatening his bid for Speaker of the House, FEC records show.

Since 2008, McCarthy’s leadership PAC, Majority Committee PAC, has given $316,000 to 17 of the Republican members now opposing him.

One of the largest beneficiaries is also one of McCarthy’s most vocal opponents, Freedom Caucus Chair Scott Perry, who has received more than $50,000 from McCarthy’s PAC since 2012. 

McCarthy has also given at least $25,000 to Reps. Michael Cloud, Andrew Clyde, Andy Harris and Ralph Norman over the years.

McCarthy’s contributions to the rebellious members were made through his leadership PAC, Majority Committee. Leadership PACs are fundraising vehicles that exist in addition to a candidate’s primary campaign committee. Prominent members, leveraging their profile, use them to raise and dispense extra cash to their allies.

Here’s a look at contributions:

  • Scott Perry: $52,500
  • Andy Harris: $26,000
  • Michael Cloud: $25,000
  • Andrew Clyde: $25,000
  • Ralph Norman: $25,000
  • Andy Biggs: $20,000
  • Matt Gaetz: $20,000
  • Dan Bishop: $20,000
  • Matt Rosendale: $20,000
  • Byron Donalds: $20,000
  • Paul Gosar: $17,500
  • Anna Paulina Luna: $10,000
  • Bob Good: $10,000
  • Mary Miller: $10,000
  • Chip Roy: $5,000
  • Eli Crane: $5,000
  • Keith Self: $5,000

McCarthy appears to suffer defeat in 11th ballot for House speaker

Rep. Kevin McCarthy stands with his eyes closed at the back of the House chamber during the 10th round of voting on Thursday.

Rep. Kevin McCarthy appears to have suffered defeat in the 11th ballot for House speaker as more than five Republicans opposed his bid.

The current bid for House leadership is now the longest speaker contest in 164 years.

A group of hardline Republicans have so far derailed McCarthy’s bid to become House speaker — even after McCarthy reportedly proposed major concessions late Wednesday.

No member of Congress can be sworn in until a House speaker is elected.

Why CNN says “appears to” suffer a defeat before the gavel goes down: Members-elect have the ability to change their votes before the vote is gaveled over. CNN is following along and tallying the voice votes as they happen, but it’s important to be clear that anything could technically change before the vote ends. 

GOP holdout says McCarthy deal includes changes sought by opponents

GOP Rep. Ralph Norman, one of the GOP holdouts voting against Rep. Kevin McCarthy, told CNN a deal that is in the works includes certain changes they are looking for.

“This is changes that we want,” Norman told CNN after viewing a deal in GOP Rep. Tom Emmer’s office.

Norman said the majority of the deal revolves around rule changes like a 72-hour rule to review bills, term limits, and open amendments.

The deal, he said, did not address committee assignments. 

Norman added that he was not sure if there was enough support from lawmakers to adjourn the House tonight.

McCarthy currently huddled in speaker's ceremonial office with key negotiators

Rep. Kevin McCarthy is currently huddled in the speaker’s ceremonial office, off the House floor, and was just joined by key negotiators: Rep. Byron Donalds, Rep. Tom Emmer and Rep. Chip Roy. 

The three Republicans scrambled up to the second floor to meet McCarthy after a lengthy negotiating session in Emmer’s office with other lawmakers, where they were viewing an emerging written deal to break the stalemate over McCarthy’s speakership.

Lawmakers just started voting on an 11th speakership ballot.

NOW: House begins voting on 11th ballot for speaker

The US Capitol is illuminated at sundown on Thursday.

The House is now voting for the 11th time for speaker — the fifth round on Thursday alone – as Republicans remain gridlocked.

A group of 20 lawmakers has stood in the way of Rep. Kevin McCarthy’s quest to be speaker.

Democrats, who are in the minority, have stood united behind their nominee, Rep. Hakeem Jeffries.

In addition to McCarthy and Jeffries, former President Donald Trump and Rep. Kevin Hern were nominated for the speaker role in this round.

It’s unclear if anything will change however as McCarthy has lost the last 10 ballots. ##Speaker Vote##

Rep. Matt Gaetz nominates former President Trump for speaker on 11th ballot

Rep. Matt Gaetz nominates former President Donald Trump in the 11th round of voting on Thursday night.

Rep. Matt Gaetz, one of the Republicans who has refused to back Rep. Kevin McCarthy for House speaker, nominated former President Donald Trump in the 11th round of voting Thursday night.

There’s no rule that the speaker is a House member. Members can vote for anyone, and they can protest by skipping the vote or voting “present.”

Gaetz voted for Trump during the seventh and eighth ballots earlier today.

McCarthy nominated for 11th speaker ballot

The House pushes on with its effort to elect a new speaker — nominating Rep. Kevin McCarthy for an 11th round of voting.

It is the fifth ballot today, over the course of the last three days.

McCarthy was nominated by Rep. French Hill.

The Republican lawmaker reflected on how difficult the job of House speaker is, saying it “takes a special personality” with a great amount of “humility and patience.”

JUST IN: McCarthy is defeated in the historic 10th speaker ballot

Kevin McCarthy was defeated again in the historic tenth round of voting for House speaker after he lost multiple votes to Reps. Byron Donalds and Kevin Hern.

This is now the longest speaker contest in 164 years.

McCarthy still had 20 total GOP lawmakers voting against him and GOP Rep. Victoria Spartz voted present again. Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries had the unanimous support of his caucus.

The final tally was:

  • 212 for Jeffries
  • 200 for McCarthy
  • 13 for Donalds
  • 7 for Hern
  • 1 present vote

Meet the clerk presiding during the speaker vote

House clerk Cheryl Johnson, top right, reads the results of a vote for House speaker on Thursday.

Cheryl Johnson, the House clerk who has presided over the contentious votes taking place this week during the speakership elections, is no stranger to turbulent times in the House of Representatives.

Already, in the nearly four years in which she has held the job, she has been present for two impeachment hearings as well as the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol riot.

Her typical duties include preparing and delivering messages to the US Senate, receiving messages from the US president and the Senate when the House is not in session, and certifying the passage of all bills and resolutions by the chamber.

Johnson was first sworn in as the 36th House Clerk by then-House Speaker Nancy Pelosi on Feb. 25, 2019, and again on Jan. 3, 2021. Along with the House Sergeant at Arms, she led House impeachment managers as they walked over articles of impeachment against Donald Trump to the US Senate in 2020 and 2021.

Since John Beckley was elected as the first House clerk on April 1, 1789, Johnson is one of only four women to hold the title and the second Black person in the role.

Read more.

GOP lawmaker says new deal could influence some votes, but other hardliners will "never yield" to McCarthy

GOP Rep. Pete Sessions of Texas said Republicans have had a “breakthrough” in negotiations that are set to possibly take place Thursday night. The proposed deal would help “reduce” the number of lawmakers who are voting against McCarthy, he told CNN Thursday.

McCarthy has already failed to reach a majority of the vote for 10 straight rounds of voting that have taken place over the last three days.

He said the process has been “longer than what we would have wanted,” saying that the fact that debate is happening in such a public setting makes it more difficult.

“I think getting three or four, five more people will be progress,” he said, but added that a group of around seven or eight lawmakers will “never yield” to McCarthy. Sessions hopes, though, that if some of the hardliners take a deal, that could influence others.

Lawmakers are already starting to consider the negotiations: Rep. Ralph Norman, one of those key holdouts, says there’s an offer “on paper” and he has been invited to come look at it. He walked into the whip’s office to review it.

CNN’s Melanie Zanona contributed reporting to this report.

Hear Rep. Pete Sessions:

f53b005c-95a0-49c2-9631-7bb0d6cc5032.mp4
05:06 - Source: CNN

McCarthy appears to suffer a historic defeat in 10th speaker ballot

Rep. Kevin McCarthy stands in the center aisle of the House chamber on Thursday.

Rep. Kevin McCarthy appears to suffer a historic defeat in the 10th ballot for House speaker as more than five Republicans opposed his bid.

The current bid for House leadership is now the longest speaker contest in 164 years.

A group of hardline Republicans have so far derailed McCarthy’s bid to become House speaker — even after McCarthy reportedly proposed major concessions late Wednesday.

No member of Congress can be sworn in until a House Speaker is elected.

Why CNN says “appears to” suffer a defeat before the gavel goes down: Members-elect have the ability to change their votes before the vote is gaveled over. CNN is following along and tallying the voice votes as they happen, but it’s important to be clear that anything could technically change before the vote ends. 

Read more

Republicans scramble to end impasse over McCarthy’s imperiled speakership bid
What you need to know about the House speaker election
What happens in the House when there is no speaker?
House adjourns again without electing a speaker with McCarthy’s bid in peril
Here are the 20 House Republicans who voted against McCarthy for speaker on the third ballot

Read more

Republicans scramble to end impasse over McCarthy’s imperiled speakership bid
What you need to know about the House speaker election
What happens in the House when there is no speaker?
House adjourns again without electing a speaker with McCarthy’s bid in peril
Here are the 20 House Republicans who voted against McCarthy for speaker on the third ballot