December 8, 2022 Brittney Griner and Russia-Ukraine news | CNN

December 8, 2022 Brittney Griner and Russia-Ukraine news

Viktor Bout Moscow Airport SCREENGRAB
Hear what Viktor Bout said after he landed in Russia
01:42 - Source: CNN

What we're covering

  • WNBA star Brittney Griner is heading home after she was released from a Russian jail in a prisoner swap for convicted arms dealer Viktor Bout.
  • Thursday’s swap did not include another American that the US State Department has declared wrongfully detained, Paul Whelan.
  • In a phone interview with CNN, Whelan said he was happy Griner was released but expressed disappointment in his continued Russian detention.
  • Meanwhile in Ukraine, settlements in the eastern Donetsk region and northeastern Kharkiv region have come under heavy Russian fire, officials said.
55 Posts

Brittney Griner's family expresses gratitude to Biden, offers prayers for Paul Whelan's return

Brittney Griner’s family expressed gratitude to President Joe Biden and his administration “for the tireless work they did to bring Brittney home” in a statement released Thursday night.

The statement added:

Biden administration weighing some other kind of offer to secure Whelan's return, official says

The Biden administration has ideas about “new forms of offers” it is going to try with the Russians in an effort to secure American Paul Whelan’s release, a senior administration official said. 

The official said there is a recognition that the US needs to make available “something more, something different” from what it has offered thus far. 

This position comes as Whelan told CNN the administration would have to look at what it has “that these people want, and hopefully give it to them, or I’ll be here for a long time.”

Russia views Whelan as a spy, the administration official explained, which means it puts him in a different category. The official didn’t rule out the US offering a Russian spy in US custody. 

Former governor Bill Richardson says Biden made right decision on Griner swap

Former Gov. Bill Richardson, who worked to help secure the release of Brittney Griner from Russia, said President Joe Biden made the right decision on the prisoner swap.

Richardson and his namesake foundation privately work on behalf of families of American hostages and detainees being held overseas.

“We now have to concentrate on Paul Whelan,” Richardson said. “I think we have to make an effort to get him out before the end of the year.”

Richardson expressed frustration over failed efforts to bring Whelan home. 

“We have tried, my foundation, for four years to get Whelan out and somehow it always falls short. We tried it during the Trump administration, early on in the Biden administration and it seems at the very end, possibly because of the espionage charge, because he’s a Marine …. he’s wrongfully detained, the Russians hold on to him at the very end, and this is what happened again, but that doesn’t mean that there isn’t a possibility that we can get him out. I think we can,” he said.

Putin defends attacks on Ukraine infrastructure targets. Here are the top headlines from today

WNBA star Brittney Griner is on her way back to the US after being released from Russian detention in a prisoner swap for convicted Russian arms dealer Viktor Bout. The swap did not include Paul Whelan, another American the State Department has declared wrongfully detained. 

Meantime, Russia’s war in Ukraine is far from over. Nearly 10 months after his invasion of Ukraine began, Russian President Vladimir Putin on Wednesday acknowledged that the conflict is “going to take a while.”

Here are the top headlines today from the war:

  • Concerns at the Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant: A top Ukrainian official said his government is working with the UN’s nuclear watchdog agency to create a security zone around the plant. But, Ukraine’s state-owned nuclear company Energoatom claimed Russian forces had deployed new weapons at the facility. A spokeswoman for the Russian Foreign Ministry cast doubt on the prospects for an agreement earlier this week, saying, “The station is located on Russian territory and is fully controlled by Russia.”
  • Explosions near a key southern port: Loud explosions and a fire were reported in the city of Berdiansk near the Sea of Azov. The city and port have been occupied by Russian forces since the early days of the conflict. Its port has previously been targeted by Ukrainian forces. The Ukrainian-appointed head of the city’s military administration confirmed the explosions, though Russian-appointed officials there denied any attack.
  • Fighting in Donetsk and Kharkiv regions: Russian forces are holding their lines along the border between the Kharkiv and Luhansk regions and had shelled nearly a dozen settlements in the course of the day, the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine said. Further south, the Donetsk front lines continue to see heavy Russian shelling in nearly 20 areas, according to the military.
  • Missiles hit Russian airfields: Ukraine’s army has significantly streamlined its protocol for approving unmanned aerial vehicles and other weaponry, according to the country’s defense minister. It comes days after Moscow accused Kyiv of drone strikes on air bases deep inside its territory. The defense minister explained that the previous process to approve one or two drones could take up to two years — but now, seven Ukrainian-made UAVs have been green-lit for operation over the past 30 days.
  • Race to repair Ukrainian energy grid: “Frost, rain with snow and strong wind” paired with continuing clashes are hindering repairs to Ukraine’s power grid, as technicians race to get energy infrastructure damaged in weeks of relentless Russian strikes back up and running, according to state energy company Ukrenergo.
  • Putin comments on Russian attacks: The Russian president made rare public comments specifically addressing the attacks on Ukraine’s energy infrastructure. Putin, who ordered the invasion of Ukraine on Feb. 24, said of the war, “Yes, we are doing it. But who started it?” He listed a series of events he blames on the Ukrainians: “Who hit the Crimean bridge? Who blew up the power lines from the Kursk nuclear power plant?” 

US concluded Viktor Bout was not a security threat before Biden agreed to Griner deal, White House says

The Biden administration conducted a security assessment in the lead-up to the deal to trade Brittney Griner for Viktor Bout and determined the convicted arms dealer would not pose a threat to US security, a White House official told CNN. 

One reality that the assessment took into account, the person said, is the fact that Bout has been in prison for over a decade and therefore has not been actively engaged in any recent criminal activity. 

This kind of security assessment is typically made whenever the government is in negotiations to try to bring home an American who is deemed to be wrongfully detained abroad.

But, other than to say that the security assessment conducted on Bout was “thorough,” the official would not elaborate on how the US was able to be certain that the Russian arms dealer wouldn’t pose a future risk to the country.

Since news of the Griner-Bout swap became public, the administration has confronted criticism and concerns regarding what Bout may do as a free individual – and questions about the value of releasing such a notorious person.

Bout’s 25-year sentence in the US was for conspiring to kill Americans, acquire and export anti-aircraft missiles, and provide material support to a terrorist organization. Bout has maintained he is innocent.

Earlier in the day, when asked whether a risk assessment had been conducted on Bout, White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre told reporters she would not offer any details about what intelligence Biden was given about Bout.   

"It's Joe Biden. Welcome, welcome home": Inside the Oval Office as Brittney Griner gained her freedom

In the days leading to Brittney Griner’s release, US officials grew increasingly convinced it was no longer a matter of if, but when.

That reality was the driver behind an invitation to Brittney’s wife Cherelle Griner earlier this week to come to the White House early Thursday morning, according to a senior administration official. 

The invitation was to meet with national security adviser Jake Sullivan, Biden’s top national security official who had briefed Cherelle Griner several times over the course of the nearly 10 months her wife had been detained in Russia. The agenda was an update on a process that was clearly moving toward resolution. 

By the time Cherelle Griner arrived at the White House, it was clear Brittney Griner was on the verge of being released. She had been moved from the penal colony where she’d been detained to Moscow. The final deal, one official acknowledged, was clearly in its end game. 

As Cherelle Griner waited to meet with Sullivan, however, a change in venue signaled what was about to happen. With no explanation, Griner was led back to the Oval Office, where President Joe Biden was waiting. 

Biden delivered the first official confirmation that Brittney Griner was on her way home, something he’d told aides he wanted to do himself. Shortly after, advisers delivered the official notification to Biden and Cherelle Griner: Brittany Griner was secure and in the hands of US officials. 

Biden then brought Cherelle Griner to a chair set up next to his at the Resolute Desk. Vice President Kamala Harris, Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Sullivan stood nearby. 

Brittany Griner was then connected to the room by speaker phone — her first call to her wife since she’d been freed. 

“It’s Joe Biden. Welcome, welcome home,” Biden said when the line connected, according to the official. After a short conversation between the three, Biden showed Cherelle to the private dining room, where she was able to continue the call with her wife privately. 

Less than an hour later, the two stood side by side down the hall in the Roosevelt Room. 

President Joe Biden meets Cherelle Griner about the release ofher wife  Brittney Griner, Thursday, December 8, 2022, in the Oval Office.

Related article Inside Biden's agonizing decision to take a deal that freed Brittney Griner but left Paul Whelan in Russia | CNN Politics

Plane carrying arms dealer Viktor Bout has arrived in Moscow, Russian state media reports

A plane carrying Russian arms dealer Viktor Bout, according to local media, lands in Moscow on December 8.

A plane carrying Russian arms dealer Viktor Bout landed in Moscow following a prisoner swap for US basketball star Brittney Griner, according to Russian state television channel Russia 24.

Bout’s wife and mother were waiting and hugged him as soon as he walked off the plane, Russia 24 footage shows.

The channel earlier released video of Bout boarding a plane, getting a quick medical check and calling his family.

Bout told a reporter in Moscow he learned that he’d be returning to his native country in the middle of the night – and that he “didn’t even get to say goodbye to anyone.”

Griner is expected to land in San Antonio, Texas, Thursday but the exact timing is unclear.

Who is Viktor Bout? Bout, nicknamed the “Merchant of Death” by his accusers, is a former Soviet military officer who was serving a 25-year sentence in the US on various charges, including conspiring to kill Americans.

You can read more about the convicted arms dealer here.

This post has been updated with comments from Bout to Russian media.

Griner lawyer says there were positive signs in the last week concerning her possible release

Maria Blagovolina speaks to CNN's Jake Tapper about Griner's release.

One of Brittney Griner’s lawyers in Russia, Maria Blagovolina, said there were indications last week that something was happening in relation to her possible release.

She noted that the weeks since Griner was transferred to a new detention facility in Mordovia had been very stressful for the basketball star as she’d also caught the flu.

“This is not a holiday resort. This is jail, and the conditions there are really harsh, and that’s true. But what I can say for sure, that Brittney has not complained and was treated very well – and I think that the reason for this is mostly because of her very likable character. People like her,” Blagovolina said. “So everybody who is around her just is trying to help her, to support her.” 

The lawyer added that the support Griner received from people in the US had helped her remain strong over the past nine months.

Griner expected to land in San Antonio following release from Russian detention

After being released from Russian detention to US officials in Abu Dhabi, American basketball star Brittney Griner is flying back to the US and expected to land in San Antonio, Texas, a US official confirmed to CNN.

It is not clear when she is expected to land.

State Department Spokesperson Ned Price said that US officials will discuss with Griner “what she needs” when she arrives back in the US.

Trevor Reed and the seven Americans who returned from Venezuela in early October were brought to San Antonio, where they underwent a Department of Defense program known as PISA (Post Isolation Support Activities) meant to acclimate them back to normal life.

Whelan's sister says she spoke to Biden

Elizabeth Whelan speaks with reporters in Washington, DC, on May 4.

Elizabeth Whelan, the sister of detained US citizen Paul Whelan, spoke with President Joe Biden on Thursday afternoon. She told CNN it was a “good call.” She also spoke with Secretary of State Antony Blinken.

She told CNN’s Jake Tapper that people should not be divided over WNBA star Brittney Griner’s release and that the criticism over the deal is “purposefully missing the nuance of what happens in negotiations over wrongful detainees.”

Whelan said she does not believe her brother knows the full extent of the efforts to free him, noting the family has to be careful what they tell him because they assume the Russians are listening. 

Paul Whelan, in an exclusive call with CNN, said he was happy that Griner was released, but expressed disappointment in his continued Russian detention. “I don’t understand why I’m still sitting here,” he said by phone from the penal colony where he is being held in a remote part of Russia.

A senior administration official told reporters earlier that Elizabeth Whelan “was visited in person by a senior US government official to share and talk through at length the news about Brittney.”

“I would also emphasize that the president has made clear to the Whelan family that when they are ready, he is eager to personally convey his commitment to Paul’s case and his resolution to keep them informed of our efforts,” the official said.

Donetsk and Kharkiv regions see heavy Russian attacks, according to Ukrainian military

The Ukrainian military said settlements in the eastern Donetsk region and northeastern Kharkiv region have come under heavy Russian fire.

“More than 20 attacks from [Russian] multiple rocket launchers [are] on the positions of our troops and settlements along the contact line,” the military said.

The General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine said Russian forces were holding their lines along the border between the Kharkiv and Luhansk regions and had shelled nearly a dozen settlements in the course of the day. 

Oleh Syniehubov, head of the Kharkiv region military administration, told Ukrainian television that in northern parts of Kharkiv, towns recently taken back by Ukrainian forces near the Russian border were constantly being shelled, including in Vovchansk.

Further south, the Donetsk front lines continue to see heavy Russian shelling in nearly 20 areas, according to the military, especially around Bakhmut and Avdiivka. Battles in the region have become a war of attrition involving mortars, tank fire, artillery and explosives dropped from drones — with much of the countryside pockmarked with craters. Neither side has taken any meaningful territory in several months along that part of the front line.

The General Staff said that in the southern regions of Zaporizhzhia and Dnipropetrovsk, 22 settlements had come under fire, with two attacked by Russian aircraft. And there was also Russian tank and artillery shelling of nearly 20 settlements in recently liberated parts of Kherson region on the west bank of the Dnipro River.

Here’s the latest map of control:

Sen. Rubio says the Griner deal was a bad trade, despite relief she's coming home

Sen. Marco Rubio speaks at a campaign rally in West Miami on October 9.

Florida Sen. Marco Rubio, who is the top Republican on the Senate intelligence committee, said the Biden administration cut a “bad deal” in securing Brittney Griner’s release, while also expressing relief she has been free.

Rubio warned the deal will “incentivize the taking of more Americans around the world.”

Asked by CNN if he would not have made this deal if he were president, Rubio said he hoped the deal with the Russians “would have been part of a broader arrangement that would have included every American that’s being held hostage.”

“We have to recognize, even as we’re happy in Americans coming home, it does incentivize the taking of more Americans around the world,” he said.

Rubio added that he thinks Griner will be “very grateful and have a greater appreciation for the greatness of this country and how special it is.”

Other Republican leaders also criticized the deal:

Florida congressman Mike Waltz told Fox News that he is “happy for the Griner family, but in the long-term, appeasing terrorists, appeasing dictatorships never works in the interests of the United States.”

Waltz was critical of the lack of a deal freeing Whelan.

“My heart breaks for the Whelan family,” he said. “What was his crime? Not being a celebrity? Not checking enough boxes for Hollywood? The fact that we left a US Marine behind and made this choice, and I don’t buy … President Biden saying we didn’t have a choice.”

Wyoming Sen. John Barrasso echoed that sentiment in an interview with Fox Business.

“It’s absolutely wrong to leave the Marine there,” he said, referring to Paul Whelan. “He may not be forgotten but he’s still there.”

Russian state media shows video of Griner and Bout boarding planes

Brittney Griner is seen boarding a plane on Thursday.

Russian state television channel Russia 24 showed video on Thursday of Brittney Griner and Viktor Bout as they were boarding their planes as part of a prisoner swap. 

The video showed Griner leaving what the presenter said what was her place of detention. She then got into a van. The next clip showed Griner walking on a tarmac toward a plane, boarding the aircraft, showing her US passport and sitting down in one of the seats. 

Griner was asked, “are you ready for a flight?” and she replies, “yes,” while smiling. 

Part of the footage showed Bout walking onto a tarmac, boarding a plane and sitting down inside. The footage was shot in Abu Dhabi, according to Russia 24.

After Bout sat down, he got a quick medical check and called his family.

This video grab shows Brittney Griner and Viktor Bout during the exchange.
Viktor Bout is seen boarded on a plane on Thursday.

Analysis: What Viktor Bout’s return to Russia says about Vladimir Putin

Viktor Bout arrives at a criminal court in Bangkok ,Thailand, in 2010.

On the surface,  US basketball star Brittney Griner and Russian arms dealer Viktor Bout are accused of ludicrously different crimes. Griner was sentenced to a Russian penal colony for possession of a single gram of cannabis oil. Bout is allegedly the most prolific arms dealer of the past decades, fueling conflicts in Africa and beyond – and more specifically being convicted in a US court of plotting to kill Americans.

But the circumstances and political pressure on both sides reversed this imbalance.

Griner gained a significance to Americans, forcing the Biden administration to negotiate with the Kremlin at the worst point of US-Russian relations since at least the end of the Cold War. Bout’s outsized importance to Russia — despite coming to be known as the “Merchant of Death” — has always been the bigger puzzle.

The fact that this exchange happened during the Russian invasion and brutalizing of Ukraine says two things.

First: Moscow and Washington are able to do business even as Russian bombs kill innocent Ukrainian civilians, and the US provides arms to Ukraine that are killing Russian soldiers, and that nuclear powers can work on other thorny issues while bullets are flying. This is a good thing for everyone on the planet. It means some cool heads prevail, and basic interests win out.

Second: It also shows some weakness on the side of Putin. At a time when he is hawkishly flaunting nuclear rhetoric against the West, he is also agreeing to high profile diplomatic deal to get back a figure of outsized, complex importance to Russia’s elite, the intelligence community, and national pride. He is not someone Moscow would – to paraphrase the ugly slogan of Russia’s invasion in which hundreds of soldiers’ bodies have remained strewn on the battlefield – “leave behind.” These are the very people that Putin wants to curry favor with now.

Yes, it is a win for Putin, but one that comes at the cost of exposing his weakness and his need to keep the military elite he relies upon content.

Viktor Bout tells relatives he is back in Russia, according to state media 

Viktor Bout, the US-traded Russian arms dealer, notified his wife and mother that he is in Russia during a phone call on Thursday, according to state broadcaster 24 and news agency TASS.

During the phone call, Bout reassured his relatives that he was fine. According to the broadcast, a special aircraft carrying Bout made a stop in the Russian city of Makhachkala for refueling.

How the exchange happened: The prisoner exchange was completed successfully at Abu Dhabi Airport on Thursday, the Russian foreign ministry said earlier Thursday.

The statement confirmed that Abu Dhabi received WNBA star Brittney Griner by private plane from Moscow after the Russian authorities released her, in conjunction with the reception of Bout on a private plane from Washington after the US authorities released him, in the presence of specialists from the UAE and Saudi Arabia.

German chancellor believes risk of Russia using nuclear weapons has decreased

German Chancellor Olaf Scholz speaks to the media in Berlin on December 1.

The risk of Russia using nuclear weapons in the war with Ukraine has lessened in response to international pressure, German Chancellor Olaf Scholz said in a new interview.

The remarks, published Thursday by Germany’s Funke media group, were later posted by Scholz on Twitter.

He was responding to a question about whether the threat of nuclear escalation had been averted. 

Moscow voiced a different tone earlier this week: On Wednesday, Russian President Vladimir Putin said the threat of nuclear war is increasing and stopped short of pledging that Russia would not be the first to resort to nuclear weapons in a conflict.

“As for the idea that Russia wouldn’t use such weapons first under any circumstances, then it means we wouldn’t be able to be the second to use them either – because the possibility to do so in case of an attack on our territory would be very limited,” he said.

But Putin said he viewed the Russian nuclear arsenal primarily as a deterrent, rather than a provocation.

“We have a strategy … namely, as a defense, we consider weapons of mass destruction, nuclear weapons – it is all based around the so-called retaliatory strike,” he said. “That is, when we are struck, we strike in response.”

More from the interview: Scholz was also asked if Germany supports French President Emmanuel Macron’s openness to providing security guarantees for Moscow in the case of peace negotiations. The chancellor said the priority was for Russia “to end the war immediately and withdraw its troops.”

Scholz, who spoke to the Russian president last week, added that ”we have to talk to each other despite this terrible situation. So that Putin also hears our point of view again and again.”

CNN’s Katharina Krebs contributed to this report.

US DOJ officials expressed frustration about prisoner swap when deal narrowed to 1-for-1, sources say

After months of behind-the-scenes discussions inside the US government about efforts to secure the release of Americans held in Russia, including Paul Whelan and Brittney Griner, the outlines of a deal emerged in the past week, people briefed on the matter said. 

White House officials briefed government agencies that the Russians would only agree to swap convicted Russian arms trafficker Viktor Bout for WNBA player Brittney Griner. 

Justice Department officials, who were always opposed to releasing Bout, expressed frustration that an earlier deal that included Whelan had been narrowed to Griner.

One US official said law enforcement officials raised strenuous objections and were told the decision had been made. 

For law enforcement officials from the FBI and the Drug Enforcement Administration, which spent years and elaborate efforts to try to capture the convicted arms dealer, the release of Bout raised additional concerns about the precedent the deal could set. 

Viktor Bout looks out from inside a detention center in Bangkok, Thailand, in 2009.

Bout, a former Soviet military officer, was serving a 25-year prison sentence in the United States on charges of conspiring to kill Americans, acquire and export anti-aircraft missiles, and provide material support to a terrorist organization. Bout has maintained he is innocent.

The publicity surrounding Griner — including celebrities posting criticism of the Biden White House on social media for not moving more quickly to secure her release — appeared to raise the Russian price for Griner’s release, law enforcement officials say.

That adds to concerns that the deal increases the likelihood that Russia, Iran and other countries could use the arrest of Americans to try to use the publicity to gain concessions the US otherwise wouldn’t give.

Series of explosions in Russian-held Berdiansk reported on local social channels

Local social media channels in the Russian-occupied city of Berdiansk reported loud explosions and a fire there Thursday morning, though Russian-appointed officials denied any attack.

Berdiansk is a city and port close to the Sea of Azov on Ukraine’s southern coast and has been occupied by Russian forces since the early days of the conflict. Its port has previously been targeted by Ukrainian forces.

The explosions were confirmed by Viktoria Galitsyna, the Ukrainian-appointed head of the city’s military administration, and Petro Andriushchenko, an adviser to the mayor of Mariupol. Neither official is in Berdiansk.

Galitsyna said the explosions had occurred at a Russian-held airfield just north of the city. Andriushchenko said that, judging by what was being reported locally, something “very big detonates.” The sound of the explosions had been heard in nearby villages, he said.

Moscow-backed leaders reject reports: The head of the Russian-appointed administration in Berdiansk, Aleksandr Saulenko, denied the reports.

Saulenko said Ukrainian “couch officials” who had fled to Zaporizhzhia were trying to “mislead users of social networks and messengers by spreading fake messages about explosions near the airport in our wonderful and quiet city.”

“Trust only the official information of the Berdiansk (military administration), which is located in the city and has all the information first-hand,” Saulenko said.

Biden official: Russia made clear that Bout "was never a bargaining chip" for Whelan

John Kirby, National Security Council coordinator for strategic communications, speaks to CNN's Kate Bolduan.

John Kirby, National Security Council coordinator for strategic communications, said the Biden administration will continue to work to get detained US citizen Paul Whelan back to the US after a release was secured for Brittney Griner on Thursday.

“Viktor Bout was never a bargaining chip for Mr. Whelan, and the Russians consistently made that clear. So I think we need to make that well-known. We will work as hard today and tomorrow and the next day to get Mr. Whelan home as we have been working since he’s been in Russia wrongfully detained,” Kirby told CNN’s Kate Bolduan.

In July, CNN reported that the Biden administration offered to exchange Bout, a convicted Russian arms trafficker serving a 25-year US prison sentence, as part of a potential deal to secure the release of Griner and Whelan, according to people briefed on the matter.

“It has to do with the nature of the sham charges against him, which were based on espionage,” Kirby told CNN Thursday.

Paul Whelan is escorted inside of a court building in Moscow in 2019.

Whelan, a US citizen and former Marine who was arrested in 2018 on espionage charges — which he has consistently and vehemently denied — is serving a 16-year prison sentence in Russia.

Kirby said that the US is “not back to square one” in its negotiations for Whelan’s release, adding that “we are going to stay at those active discussions going forward.”

In an exclusive call with CNN today, Whelan said he was happy that Griner was released but was “disappointed” the Biden administration had not done more to secure his release.

Pressed on whether the world is more dangerous with Bout freed, Kirby said, “I can assure you … our focus on our national security interests is not going to change. … And so with Mr. Bout being back on the street, we’re gonna stay focused on making sure we can defend this country.”

CNN’s Betsy Klein contributed reporting to this post.

Read More

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is named TIME magazine’s person of the year
Russian missiles hit Kyiv as G7 summit begins in Europe
Exclusive: Russian general who oversaw atrocities in Syria led cluster bomb attacks on civilians in Ukraine

Read More

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is named TIME magazine’s person of the year
Russian missiles hit Kyiv as G7 summit begins in Europe
Exclusive: Russian general who oversaw atrocities in Syria led cluster bomb attacks on civilians in Ukraine