November 16, 2022 Russia-Ukraine news | CNN

November 16, 2022 Russia-Ukraine news

Maj Mike Lyons 111622
Missile that hit Poland may have come from Ukraine
02:56 - Source: CNN

What we covered here

  • The leaders of Poland and NATO said the missile that killed two people in Polish territory Tuesday was likely fired by Ukrainian forces defending their country against a barrage of Russian strikes, and that the incident appeared to be an accident.
  • This is the first time a NATO country has been directly hit during the conflict. NATO head Jens Stoltenberg said Russia bears “ultimate responsibility” for the incident, “as it continues its illegal war against Ukraine.” 
  • Russia launched its biggest wave of missile attacks on Ukrainian cities in more than a month Tuesday, leaving more than seven million people without power.
  • The top US military general, Mark Milley, said that the Ukrainian aim of kicking Russia out of all its territory was a “very difficult task” and one that is not likely to be accomplished anytime soon.
64 Posts

Ukrainian ambassador to UN says Kyiv is ready to cooperate with Poland on missile investigation

Ukraine’s Ambassador to the UN Sergiy Kyslytsya told the UN Security Council on Wednesday that the country is “ready to cooperate with the Polish side” on the investigation into the missile that killed two people in Poland on Tuesday.

Earlier on Wednesday, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said his country wants to establish all the facts surrounding the missile that landed in Poland and noted in his daily video address that “clarification of all the circumstances of how Russian aggression crossed the Polish border” was now an issue before the UN Security Council.

The ambassador also told the Security Council that Russia’s attacks were creating a humanitarian disaster that could spill beyond Ukraine.

Some context: The leaders of Poland and NATO said the missile that killed two people in Polish territory on Tuesday was likely fired by Ukrainian forces defending their country against a barrage of Russian strikes and that the incident appeared to be an accident.

The blast occurred outside the rural eastern Polish town of Przewodow, about four miles (about 6.4 kilometers) west of the Ukrainian border on Tuesday afternoon, roughly the same time as Russia launched its biggest wave of missile attacks on Ukrainian cities in more than a month.

CNN’s Tim Lister contributed to this report

Polish ambassador to NATO says missile incident was ultimately the responsibility of Russia

Tomasz Szatkowski, Polish ambassador to NATO

The Polish ambassador to NATO said that the “ultimate responsibility lies with Russia,” following the deadly missile that landed on Polish territory on Tuesday that left two people dead.

Speaking to CNN, ambassador Tomasz Szatkowski said that the incident would not have happened if Russia did not attack Ukraine and engaged in war crimes by attacking civilian infrastructure. 

When asked about how Polish people are feeling following the incident, Szatkowski said that “a certain level of apprehension is understandable,” adding that authorities are doing a lot in order to reassure the population.

Later Wednesday, Russia’s Ambassador to the UN Vasily Nebenzya rejected those claims.

“We have long ago stop being surprised by your attempts, in any circumstances in spite of fact or common sense, to blame Russia for everything,” Nebenzya said during the UN Security Council meeting in New York.

“Today, in spite of clear evidence of Ukrainian-Polish provocation, many representatives of western countries have stated to the effect that even if the missiles were launched by Ukraine, it’s still Russia that is to blame for destroying critical infrastructure,” Nebenzya added.

Some more context: The leaders of Poland and NATO said the missile was likely fired by Ukrainian forces defending their country against a barrage of Russian strikes, and that the incident appeared to be an accident.

Poland’s investigation into the incident continues.

This is the first time a NATO country has been directly hit during the conflict. NATO head Jens Stoltenberg also said Russia bears “ultimate responsibility” for the incident, “as it continues its illegal war against Ukraine.” 

President Zelensky says Ukraine wants all data connected to missile that landed in Poland

President Volodymyr Zelensky says Ukraine wants to establish all the facts surrounding the missile that landed in Poland on Tuesday, killing two people.

Polish officials have indicated that it is likely a Ukrainian missile, deployed by its air defenses amid waves of Russian missile attacks Tuesday, landed inside its border.

Zelensky said in his daily video address that “clarification of all the circumstances of how Russian aggression crossed the Polish border” was now an issue before the UN Security Council.

Zelensky said he had spoken with Polish President Andrzej Duda and expressed his condolences but insisted that it was “Russian aggression” that had claimed the lives of two Polish citizens.

Zelensky said Wednesday had been “a long and hard day,” following the onslaught of Russian missile strikes on infrastructure targets on Tuesday.

“Emergency and stabilization blackouts continue in 18 regions and in Kyiv. These are millions of consumers. We are doing everything to restore electricity – both generation and supply,” he said.

As for the recently liberated city of Kherson, Zelensky said his administration was doing its best to restore key services.

US State Department aware of Brittney Griner's whereabouts at Russian penal colony, spokesperson says

Brittney Griner waits during a hearing in Khimki, Russia, in August.

The US State Department is aware of detained WNBA star Brittney Griner’s whereabouts, principal deputy spokesperson Vedant Patel said Wednesday.

Patel said they know the location of Griner – who was transferred from Moscow to a penal colony — through lawyers, and “formally the Russian Federation has still failed to provide any official notification for such a move of a US citizen, which we strongly protest.”

Patel did not provide details on where she has been moved, saying at a briefing, “our embassy and our mission in Moscow has continued to press for more information about her transfer and her current location and those requests continue to be ongoing.”

He said he was not aware that anyone from the embassy had been able to speak with Griner since her transfer.

Remember: Griner was convicted of deliberately smuggling drugs into Russia and sentenced to nine years of jail time in August in a case that has raised concerns she is being used as a political pawn in Russia’s war against Ukraine.

Judge Anna Sotnikova of the Khimki city court delivered the sentence and fined Griner 1 million rubles, or about $16,400. She said the court took into account Griner’s partial admission of guilt, remorse for the deed, state of health and charitable activities. Prosecutors had asked that she be sentenced to 9.5 years in jail.

Prior to the verdict, Griner apologized to the court and asked for leniency in an emotional speech.

Top US general: Ukraine "kicking the Russians physically out" of country not likely to happen soon

Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Mark Milley speaks during a press briefing at the Pentagon on November 16 in Arlington, Virginia.

Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Mark Milley said that the Ukrainians’ aim of “militarily kicking the Russians physically out of Ukraine is a very difficult task” and one that is not likely to be accomplished “anytime soon.”

Speaking at a press conference Wednesday, Milley said Russia occupies about 20% of Ukraine, and he noted that Kherson and Kharkiv, which the Ukrainians have reclaimed “are relatively small compared to the whole.”

Milley caveated by saying that “politically, there may be a political solution where politically the Russians withdraw.”

CNN has reported on the divisions in the Biden administration as Milley has seemed to push for a more urgent diplomatic outcome, and the Biden administration has had to work to reassure the Ukrainian government, outside experts, and former US officials that it will not push Ukraine to imminently seek negotiations with Russia after comments Milley made last week.

Poland reiterates investigation into missile incident will be joint operation with US

Poland has said that investigations at the site where a missile landed will continue to be a joint operation with the United States.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has demanded that Ukrainian experts be allowed access.

American investigators are now working at the site, Polish President Andrzej Duda said Wednesday.

“Since President Biden declared support in a conversation with me yesterday, I accepted this support, so this investigation can be said to be conducted jointly by us and the American side or by the North Atlantic Alliance and us,” he said.

US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin also confirmed that US experts are on the ground in Poland assisting with the Polish investigation.

Zelensky said Wednesday in a meeting with Ukrainian media that a group of Ukrainian experts must be allowed access to the site.

He also said he wanted to see “the number on the missile, because all missiles have numbers on them.” And he said that Ukrainian representatives should be invited to a virtual NATO meeting regarding the incident.

Polish President Duda meets with US CIA director in Warsaw, Polish security official says

Polish President Andrzej Duda met with CIA Director Bill Burns in Warsaw Wednesday after an incident in eastern Poland that left two people dead, according to Poland’s National Security Bureau chief, Jacek Siewiera.

“In the evening, the President @AndrzejDuda spoke with the head of the CIA, William Burns, who is in Warsaw after his visits to Ankara and Kiev,” Siewera wrote in a post on Twitter sharing a picture of the meeting.

He added that the general security situation as well as the context of the recent events were discussed. “Lots of work on the PL-US line today.”

A US official told CNN that Burns had previously scheduled meetings with Polish officials including Duda. They discussed the current situation and the director reaffirmed the US commitment to providing support to Ukraine and thanked Poland for its continued partnerships including in intelligence channels, according to the official.

Poland has said that it will continue to jointly investigate with the US the site where a missile landed on Tuesday.

Top US general tried to speak with Russian counterpart on Tuesday but attempts were "unsuccessful"

Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Mark Milley attempted to speak with his Russian counterpart Gen. Valery Gerasimov on Tuesday following the missile that fell in Poland, but the attempts were not successful, Milley said during a press conference at the Pentagon on Wednesday.

Milley spoke with his Ukrainian counterpart, his Polish counterpart and other chiefs of defense in Europe after the explosion in Poland yesterday, he said.

“My staff was unsuccessful in getting me linked up with General Gerasimov,” Milley said.

“I did talk to my Ukrainian counterpart, Gen. [Valerii] Zaluzhny — talked to him several times in fact — also Polish counterpart and several other (chiefs of defense) in Europe,” he added.

#Poland##

Top US general: Russia has lost strategically, operationally and tactically

Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Mark Milley speaks at a press conference at the Pentagon in Washington, DC, on November 16.

Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman Gen. Mark Milley says Russia has failed “every single” objective in its war against Ukraine.

“Russians have failed every single time. They’ve lost strategically, they’ve lost operationally and, I repeat, they lost tactically. What they’ve tried to do, they failed at,” Milley said Wednesday at a press conference with Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin after a meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group. “The strategic reframing of their objectives, of their illegal invasion, have all failed, every single one of them.”

Milley listed Russia’s failure to “overrun all of Ukraine” at the start of the war as well as after their refocus on the Donbas region and the capture of Zaporizhzhia and Kherson.

“Across the entire frontline trace of some 900 or so kilometers, the Ukrainians have achieved success after success after success, and the Russians have failed every single time,” said Milley.

US defense head: No contradiction of assessment that Ukrainian defense missile caused Polish explosion

US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin, left, and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Mark Milley speak to members of the press at the Pentagon on November 16 in Arlington, Virginia.

The US has seen no information so far that contradicts Polish President Andrzej Duda’s “preliminary assessment” that the explosion in Poland yesterday that left two dead “was most likely the result of a Ukrainian defense missile,” Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin said at a press conference at the Pentagon on Wednesday. 

“Whatever the final conclusions may be, the world knows that Russia bears ultimately responsibility for this incident,” Austin added. 

The US has “full confidence” in the Polish government’s investigation into it, Austin said.

“They’ve been conducting that investigation in a professional and deliberate manner, and so we won’t get ahead of their work. We’re going to stay in close touch with our Polish counterparts as well as with our NATO allies and other valued partners,” Austin said. 

The explosion in Poland and Russia’s continued attacks against civilian infrastructure are “another reminder of the recklessness of Russia’s war of choice,” Austin said.

US says it is confident in Polish investigation into deadly missile incident

Polish police officers search for missile wreckage in a field in Przewodow, Poland, on November 16.

The United States said it has “full confidence” in the Polish investigation into the missile that killed two people near the country’s border with Ukraine.

The “party ultimately responsible” for the incident is Russia for its ongoing invasion, National Security Council spokesperson Adrienne Watson said in a written statement Wednesday. 

“We have full confidence in the Polish government’s investigation of the explosion near their border with Ukraine, and we commend them for the professional and deliberate manner in which they are conducting it,” Watson wrote.

Earlier Wednesday, Polish President Andrzej Duda said that the missile that hit his country Tuesday was “probably an accident” from Ukraine’s air defenses and that “there is no indication that this was an intentional attack on Poland.” 

“That said, whatever the final conclusions may be, it is clear that the party ultimately responsible for this tragic incident is Russia, which launched a barrage of missiles on Ukraine specifically intended to target civilian infrastructure. Ukraine had — and has — every right to defend itself,” Watson said.

Ukrainian security Service says Russian "torture chamber" in Kherson discovered

A Ukrainian police officer stands at a preliminary detention centre which Ukrainians say was used by Russian service members to jail and torture people in Kherson, Ukraine, on November 16.

The Ukrainian Security Service (the SBU) says it has discovered another “torture chamber” allegedly used by Russian forces during the occupation of Kherson.

The Russians had “kept local patriots who refused to cooperate with the enemy in inhuman conditions,” the SBU said.

“Kherson residents were interrogated and brutally tortured. During the inspection of the torture chamber, law enforcement officers found items that directly indicate signs of torture.” 

NATO should "keep a cool head" following missile incident in Poland, Estonia's prime minister tells CNN

Estonia's Prime Minister Kaja Kallas arrives for the second day of a EU leaders Summit at The European Council Building in Brussels, Belgium, on October 21.

Estonian Prime Minister Kaja Kallas told CNN that NATO allies must “keep a cool head” in light of Tuesday’s missile incident in Poland that left two people dead.

“I think we really have to keep a cool head, knowing there might be a spillover effect, especially to those countries that are very close [to Ukraine],” Kallas told CNN’s Christiane Amanpour in an interview Wednesday.

On Wednesday, Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki said that “materials collected by our services and provided by our allies most probably indicate that the explosion in Przewodów, in eastern Poland, was caused by the shooting down and destruction of a Russian missile.” Polish President Andrzej Duda said that the missile was “probably an accident” from Ukraine’s air defenses.

Russia blamed Ukraine’s air defense system for the missile explosion and said there was “a deliberate provocation in order to escalate the situation.” 

Estonian leader Kallas told Amanpour that NATO allies should see the bigger picture when it comes to the incident. 

“Of course, Russia wants to concentrate on this one incident, but the problem is Russia is waging a full-scale war in Ukraine,” the Estonian prime minister told CNN.

“Yesterday, they did [their] biggest rocket attacks so far, hitting civilian infrastructure, hitting civilians everywhere, trying to make Ukraine really run out of electricity, bombing the electricity grid so it will be dark and very cold. This is the reason we’re talking about this,” Kallas said about Russian missiles striking across the country on Tuesday.

NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg said Wednesday that one of NATO’s top priorities at the moment is to provide more air defense systems to Ukraine.

Kallas told Amanpour that “air defense, all the equipment that we have, must be given to Ukraine so they can defend themselves.”

“I can’t look into their warehouses, and see what they [NATO members] actually have, but I can call on the leaders of NATO allies who have more, and say ‘please look to your storage, look to your warehouses, find things that you have, do agreements with [the] private sector who is developing equipment,’ so that we can send top equipment to Ukraine and end this war once and for all,” Kallas said.

Russian says delegation was denied visas to participate in session of security organization in Warsaw

Russia’s delegation won’t attend the fall session of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, which is set to take place next week in Warsaw, because Poland has rejected the delegation members’ visas, a senior Russian official said Wednesday. 

Admission of the Russian delegation to the OSCE session “would violate the principle of solidarity with Ukraine,” the head of Poland’s delegation to the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly, Barbara Bartus, said in response to the request for visas, according to Vladimir Dzhabarov, first deputy chair of the Russian Federation Council Committee on International Affairs. 

“Unfortunately, we received an outrageous response from the head of the Polish delegation to the OSCE parliamentary assembly, Ms. Bartus, who literally said that she does not see any possibility of Russian and Belarusian representatives participating in the autumn session of the OSCE PA in Warsaw,” Dzhabarov said during a parliament session. 

“We expect that a similar problem with restricting the access of the members of our delegation to the assembly’s events may be repeated in February when the winter session is planned in Vienna and also next July with regards to the annual session in Canada,” Dzhabarov said.

Pro-Russian authorities in Kherson urge evacuation as shelling continues

A woman walks past a damaged building in the town of Nova Kakhovka, Ukraine, on October 30.

Residents and officials in the part of Kherson region still occupied by Russian forces are being urged to leave for Russia.

The Military and Civil Administration in Russian-occupied Oleshky, which lies on the east side of the Dnipro river, said on Telegram that it “strongly recommends that the residents of the district leave for safe regions of the Russian Federation.”

Employees of the Russian-installed administration of Nova Kakhovka, a city in Kherson, have already relocated to safe places, according to the city administration Tuesday.

As a result of damage to fiber-optic lines in the city, there is no internet or mobile network.

According to the statement, “this does not mean that Nova Kakhovka, Tavriysk and all other settlements were abandoned.” Crews of communal enterprises and services work in standby mode and ensure the functioning of energy and water supply systems in the city.

British foreign secretary says UK will not rush to judgment on Poland missile incident

James Cleverly leaves Downing Street on September 6, in London, England.

British Foreign Secretary James Cleverly said the UK would not rush to a judgment about the origin of a missile which landed in a Polish village Tuesday, killing two people. 

“We are not going to rush to judgment. Our response will always be led by the facts,” Cleverly said Wednesday in a speech to the British Parliament, adding the investigation into the incident would be led by Poland. 

Cleverly’s warning comes after NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg told a Brussels news conference that “preliminary analysis suggests that the incident was likely caused by a Ukrainian air defense missile fired to defend Ukrainian territory against Russian cruise missile attacks.” 

“But let me be clear, this is not Ukraine’s fault,” Stoltenberg said, adding, “Russia bears ultimate responsibility, as it continues its illegal war against Ukraine.”

The foreign secretary condemned Putin’s “brutal air campaign” on Ukraine on Tuesday, when waves of missiles hit cities across the country. 

Cleverly added the strikes were “Putin’s revenge for Ukraine’s successes on the battlefield, where Russian forces have been expelled from thousands of square miles of territory and now he is trying to terrorize the people of Ukraine and break their will by leaving them shivering in cold and darkness.” 

UK Defense Secretary Ben Wallace also said Wednesday that he cannot speculate on the missile incident.

Asked what conversations he has had with NATO counterparts, Wallace said that he was in touch with his Polish counterpart on Tuesday, “offering my support.” 

His Polish counterpart “replied that they were obviously waiting for intelligence and indeed details to emerge,” Wallace said.

US official: Ukrainian military tells US, allies it attempted missile interception near Poland strike location

The Ukrainian military told US and allies that it attempted to intercept a Russian missile during the timeframe and near that location of the Poland missile strike, a US official told CNN.

It’s not clear this air defense missile is the same missile that struck Poland, but this information has informed an ongoing US assessment of the strike. 

A Pentagon spokesperson referred CNN to comments by US President Joe Biden last night: “It’s unlikely, in the minds of the trajectory, that it was fired from Russia. But we’ll see. We’ll see.” 

Polish PM says explosion Tuesday probably caused by shooting down of a Russian missile

Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki said that the explosion in Poland yesterday near the border with Ukraine was likely caused by a Russian missile being shot down “without any intention on either side.”

“Materials collected by our services and provided by our allies most probably indicate that the explosion in Przewodów, in eastern Poland, was caused by the shooting down and destruction of a Russian missile,” he said.

Morawiecki tweeted that “there are many indications that one of these missiles fell on Polish territory without any intention on either side.”

Earlier Wednesday, Polish President Andrzej Duda said his government doesn’t have any evidence to suggest that the missile that landed in Poland on Tuesday was fired by Russia.  

“Probably it was shot by the Ukrainian Air Defense, and unfortunately, it fell onto Polish territory,” he said.

He reiterated that nothing shows that it was an “intentional attack” against Poland. 

It's mid-afternoon in Kyiv. Here's what you need to know

Poland’s president and the head of NATO have today both said that it’s likely that the missile strike that killed two people in a Polish border village Tuesday was accidentally caused by Ukrainian air defenses, with no sign that it was a intentional attack on Poland.

Yet this is the first time a NATO country has been directly hit since the conflict began in February. Alliance chief Jens Stoltenberg said that: “Russia bears ultimate responsibility, as it continues its illegal war against Ukraine.” 

Meanwhile, residents across Ukraine face emergency power cuts following Russia’s barrage of strikes targeting energy infrastructure on Tuesday.

Here are the latest developments:

  • “Not Ukraine’s fault”: The origins of the missile that struck eastern Poland with deadly consequences are still under detailed investigation, though Stoltenberg said early analysis suggests it was “likely” fired by Ukraine’s defenses.
  • Emergency blackouts hit Ukraine: Residents in multiple Ukrainian regions will face further scheduled and unscheduled power cuts Wednesday, a day after Russia fired scores of missiles at the country.
  • Missile threatens diplomacy: Global leaders scrambled to alleviate the fallout from Tuesday’s incident. French President Emmanuel Macron echoed his G20 counterparts and said the group should send a “very clear message to avoid escalation.”
  • What the Kremlin says: Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov praised the United States’ reaction to the missile incident in Poland, saying it was “restrained” and “professional,” contrasting statements from Poland and other countries. The Polish Ministry of Foreign Affairs has said the missile that fell in Poland was Russian-made. On Wednesday, Polish President Andrzej Duda said that the strike was “probably an accident” from Ukraine’s air defenses. US President Joe Biden called for an emergency meeting of the leaders of the G7 and NATO countries on Wednesday. Biden said the preliminary information refutes reports that the missile was fired from Russia.
  • War dominates G20: The paragraph on the war in Ukraine was the most intensely discussed section of the G20 joint leaders’ declaration, Indonesian President Joko Widodo said Wednesday, as the summit wrapped.
  • Grain deal concerns: Leaders at the G20 summit called for the “full implementation” of the Black Sea Grain Initiative after Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov cast doubt on the future of the agreement, which was negotiated to ease a global food crisis inflamed by the war.